Pros: Top location not far from Central Park, the ...

Pros: Top location not far from Central Park, the Metro, 5th Avenue and and and ... Very friendly and helpful staff and properly equipped rooms, plus a well-functioning wifi.

Negative: equipment a bit older, little lounge outside the room.

In the end, you simply have to include the price in the evaluation. If you get the stay around $ 100 / room the night for me it tends towards 5 * in terms of value for money. At $ 150-200, that's more like 3 *, which is still "ok".