The only way to review this place is to break it i...

The only way to review this place is to break it into categories. Food, coffee/drinks, and pastries.

The sandwiches are good and what I would recommend. What really makes Ithaca Bakery shine is it's bread and bagels. This is the corner Stone of their business and how they started.

The coffee is so so and I wish the Baristas were trained better. The drinks we're totally not consistent depending on who made them for you. So, I would recommend going to Gimme for your coffee and drinks.

The pastries are hit or miss. There are hand full of products that are made from scratch and these are the ones you want to eat up. The key lime bar and the lemon bars are amazing. The best cake you can have here is the vegan chocolate cake. I would probably Skip any of the other cakes. The scones are also fantastic and the cheddar chive biscuits are out of this world when fresh or microwaved.

I would say give it a shot. It is definitely a mixed reviewed place for many reasons. If anything, get your bread and bagels from here.