Login or sign up
For business

Papa Jay's

3.5· 92 reviews
Average ratingAverage
3.5/ 5

Based on 92 reviews

547%
411%
38%
212%
123%
Ask AI

Ask Trustburn about Papa Jay's

Based on 92 reviews on Trustburn

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

David Cline
Reviews 1

Pizza is the best. Had The Pepperoni Special. Delivered hot and in a timely manner. And just have to add everyone was very professional. The delivery person had a Papa Jays shirt and car was also well signed. Thank you for a great meal when I didn't feel like going out or cooking.

Meredith Borne
Reviews 1

The pizza was OK but way over priced. When the person who took my order said $19.18 for a Lg. Hawaiian I almost told them to forget about it, wish I had now. I was even more upset when it got here and it was the size of a medium, thin and had very little sauce. I have ordered from here in the past and thought the pizza was fairly good and the price was good too. After tipping I paid $23 for nothing. Very disappointed!

Shawna
Reviews 1

Well, everything was going great until this one time. Normally dont have a problem with the place except with the drivers constantly showing up to the neighbors house. But that's beside the point. Waited over an hour for our food, which has never happened before. Normally doesnt take that long to make ravioli and put together an italian sub. but whatever right? Could have been a busy Wednesday night..but again not my point. Now on the menu it clearly states "All cold subs include lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, green peppers & onions". So ordered a spicy italian sub the same way we have ordered it just like the 500 other times it's been ordered. But what we got was pretty much a cheese sandwich with a few pieces of meat. Is this a joke? Like I mean what happened to the rest of the sub? No veggies? Yeah I get it, we all make mistakes. But when you have waited over an hour for cold ravioli and a sad excuse for an Italian sub, kinda really pisses a person off. 2 stars, and that's me being extra generous because the food is decent when made the right way.

perrysmash1
Reviews 1

The food is ok, but everything is extremely overpriced. They don't have small pizzas, but don't let that fool you. Their medium is a small but they will charge you a medium price for it. I ended up paying over $13 (and that was after a discount) for a small pizza w/a couple regular toppings. Not worth the hassle.

Stin
Reviews 1

I ordered a vegetarian calzone and substituted the green pepper for banana peppers. I got a calzone with banana peppers, pineapple, cheese and sauce. ya'll missed the onions, mushrooms, and broccoli and just gave me pineapple for some reason (the worst topping that I didn't ask for). I still like the food. but when I pay 20 bucks for a meal, I expect it done right, or at least close. I asked for 6 toppings (including the sauce and cheese) and I got 4, one of which wasnt even the right topping. I would show the receipt along with the picture of the calzone, but the delivery driver only asked me if I wanted it instead of handing it to me with the box like he was supposed to. Unfortunately I said no because I thought I wouldn't need it. Conspiracy? I don't know. Lesson learned I guess. I cant really recommend this place unless you enjoy gambling. 2 stars for the potential.

Caitie Taylor
Reviews 1

Have found multiple hairs in my food, MULTIPLE TIMES. I used to order here a lot but the sanitation and food safety and prep is clearly subpar. Would recommend other great places in dover who don t have hair in their food on multiple occasions. Do better Papajays.

Michelle Anderson
Reviews 1

I just paid 14 dollars each for what should have been 2 lrg subs. Instead I get 2 subs that are almost the same size as a half I have leftover from friday not to mention they are so sopping wet the paper theyd beenwrapped in is falling apart. . I called and was told I couldn't get my money back and that I got what I ordered bc even tho they were in small sub roll they put the same amount of meat in them.... I took pictures the one that isn't wet I'd a half of a ckn salad sub leftover from Friday....
Apparently they ran out of their regular rolls and it was just too bad for me needless to say I'm pretty angry

Lisa Tanguay
Reviews 1

Ordered a Large steak and cheese pizza for my boyfriend and I to share. Both really hungry, just got home late from work. After over and hour of waiting by the door they bring a steak and cheese sub. My boyfriend for some reason just took it confused and they left. So I called the restaurant right when he left and explained we would really like to give the sub back and just get the pizza, very politely. They agreed and made a pizza. I called 1 hour later to see if they were still coming because I waited another hour by the door. They said the delivery driver just left with my pizza and is on the way. I waited another 1 hour by the door. NEVER SHOWED UP. I waited a total of 3 hours by my door and never ate dinner that night because I don t like subs. That delivery driver must have enjoyed our pizza at home that night. Terrible customer service.

Brian Emmerson
Reviews 1

I ordered 1 sub and a small onion ring. I live 5 mins from the restaurant. The food took 1 hour and and 20 mins to get here. When it finally arrived, i got the completely wrong order. The delivery person proceeded to ask me to my face if i wanted to leave a tip. Are you serious?! HA! Also, when i initially ordered on the phone, the person who took my order asked if i wanted to leave a tip on my card, and i said yes, $7.00. (Which is over 20%). Unreal. Worst place ever. This is not the first experience ive had similar to this and this experience in particular is what drove me to finally leave a review and stop ordering from this low-level dive. And yeah, i did eat the food i recieved. And no, i did not enjoy it. Haha!

Kellie Welch
Reviews 1

I love that they are always friendly and awesome when delivering. The online ordering and points system is easy and a great layout. The only thing I could critique is the oil. It needs to be changed out more or fish and frys need to be cooked in different oil. The drys have a very distinct fish taste and it turns not only my stomach but my friend has a fish allergy and it's made him sick.

Robby C.
Reviews 1

always in search of a great Italian sub. I was really looking forward to trying Papa Jay's. The sub had all the right components except the ham...you just don't use smoked ham on an Italian sub because of the smoked genoa. It's 2 different smoked tastes and do not compliment each other...change to cooked ham and we will purchase again.

Lionel Houde
Reviews 1

When I worked there the owner always kept the standards up on making the food: safety, flavor, value and timely delivery. Sounds like a few employees are rude lately and I can't tell you anything about that, but if he's running the place like he did in 2006, just talk to him and let him know your problems. He gets to the cause of the problem and fixes it.

Taylor Perkins
Reviews 1

So I ordered the chicken alfredo and the chicken parm dinner the chicken alfredo had no chicken in it and they try to give me cut up chicken fingers instead of chicken parm so apparently they don't know the difference so be careful what you order from here they don't know what they are doing

Cathy Barton
Reviews 1

I just ordered from here for the first time. The meatball sub was excellent. The Greek salad? It was the poorest excuse of one I have ever had. The dressing came in a Ken's packet. Very little feta. Two round slices of pepper. Maybe 3 cucumbers. This salad was $8.99. Way, way, way over priced. The sub was $5.99 and much better. I would order again but obviously will not be getting a salad.

Randy Heller
Reviews 1

Keep in mind that Dover now has at least 15 pizza parlors, so there is plenty of competition. The caveat here is that the ovens are likely run too hot, or some other issue (I'm no pizza chef). Too often the bottom of the pizza is overcooked and occasionally even blackened.

Kale
Reviews 1

Their "pizza sauce" tastes like tomato paste right out of the can. The dough was paper thin, so everything fell off the pizza the second you pick it up. Everything tasted very artificial and just gross. A medium sized Hawaiian "pizza* for almost 20 bucks (after taxes, etc). I would've been better off getting a frozen pizza from Cumberland Farms. Don't waste your money here.

Erin Kilmain
Reviews 1

Papa Jays delivery is always fast and they always deliver my food hot. The pizza sizes are unique though ..they run on the smaller side so when I want a large sized pizza I order the Extra Large cause the Large is a bit small and looks more like a medium. However the sauce is very good and I enjoy their pizza.

Sean
Reviews 1

I placed an order online and about an hour later I ended up calling the store. the gentleman who answered the phone said that they were very busy and that he had to call people in for deliveries he was apologetic to the minimum but an hour for two subs just seems awful. I will not be ordering online ordering for delivery from this place again I will just pick up the food I do enjoy the food it is always good when I get it but today was just not a good day for them.

Linda Miceli
Reviews 1

My first & last time I would do business with Papajay's. I ordered a sausage mushroom & oinion pizza. It had Little to no sauce (looked like a white pizza), th dough is hand toss after it thaws out-tasteless, 8 sausage slices (thin), 5 mushrooms, & 2 whole onions (99% onion). The parking lot is hard to access & park. The delivery person parked in a way he blocked the entrance/exit. When I went back inside & asked if he was leaving or could he move his car his response was I parked the wrong way. He walked past me & the manager said I was rude. So if you like lousy pizza & unprofessional staff by all means this is the place to go in Dover. The photos they posted shows a truck parked in the same direction I parked.

Keith Brown
Reviews 1

For the price thought we'd get more. Burger for $6.99 was very small, and bun was hard. Paid $3.99 for a 2 liter of Diet Pepsi that expired August 1st, and it is September 3rd. $13.99 for a pizza the size of a dinner plate. The grinders we ordered for tomorrow appear to be decent though. All in all overpriced for the portions, and the expired soda is not likely fatal, but a nail in the coffin for this review. We had 4 similar options to decide between, hopefully this helps others make the right decision, as we did not.

Kelly Brooks
Reviews 1

I recommend going straight though papa Jays instead of door dash. We had a issue and tried to cancel yet doordash wouldn t allow it. Called Papa Jays and they held the order till we finally got it figured out. I really appreciated the service provided by Papa Jays!

diva downtown
Reviews 1

Good pizza friendly staff and reasonably priced. Not so much a dine in place however they do have a few tables to sit at. Have enjoyed their pizza while there ( you can get slices as well as whole pizzas) and have had their delivery. Good pizza each time. So appreciate the consistency.

E. Henry Harris
Reviews 1

As a lactose intolerant guy, I can normally stomach a few slices of pizza without issue as long as I have my lactaid. Went to Papa Jays and did just that before realizing I d forgotten my medicine. The bathroom was unlocked fortunately but I tripped over several rats while trying to sit down and ended up spraying all over the place. The worst part is this happened months ago and I ve heard it has not yet been cleaned up. Papa Jay. Please at least try to clear some rats out and for Pete s sake make food that doesn t suck.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Papa Jay's