Timothy O'Toole's Pub Reviews

Everyone enjoyed the food here. They have also been on man vs food

Great atmosphere and ambiance. Great service by Mikayla! We had the fish and chips and OMG, it was so good! Fried and seasoned to perfection. Instead of fries, I asked for mashed potatoes topped with cheddar cheese and bacon. It was no problem and delicious. WE WILL DEFINITELY GO BACK!!

Stopped in for drinks with my boyfriend! I had a berry martini and the caramel apple mule and they were both great! We also had the Mac and cheese as an appetizer and it was SO delicious, hands down my favorite Mac I ve ever had! Reasonably priced and good atmosphere

Really enjoyed ourselves. Drinks PERFECTLY MIXED! Food Reasonably priced. Great Atmosphere. Covid Compliant. Safe.

Went conservative with this one, and was super impressed by everything. The building immediately impresses with the entry stairway as soon as you walk in, and the structure as a whole was clean and well managed.

The $10 burger was filling and cooked perfectly, and came out so quickly that it seemed like the cook took off his apron and delivered the plates himself as soon as they came off the grill. I couldn't really tell though, cause the guy was so clean that he mirrored the presentation standards of the hosts.

The drink special was on point, too.

Checking into our hotel we were told by our hotel receptionist about Timothy O'Toole's. When we were looking at the menu we saw wing brought to another table and they looked delicious. We had 4 different kinds of wings and they tasted as good as they looked. Good food definitely a little more pricey but definitely worth trying.

Great prices during happy hour but when our server brought us our check they had charged us full price for the Sam Adams drafts even though both their printed and online menus show it as being on the happy hour. Would have ordered something different if we had been told it was no longer on the offer. This aside the service was good and giving it 5 stars as it s a great sports bar with good drink and food specials in an area that is otherwise completely dead / for tourists.

Great place to have a good burger, wings and drink. Service is great so is the atmosphere!

We visited on Mother's day and it was really a great experience. Customer service, our waitress and food was on point. We will visit again this summer

Great pub on the Magnificent Mile. Huge beer list. Our server was friendly and attentive. The food was top notch. Highly recommend.