Sugar River Wholesale Review

Visited from out of town. Took a chance on it. The pizza was amazing. The waitress was great as well. I will return when I am in the area again

Went here for the first time on valentine's day. Was very good food and wine! Atmosphere was very relaxing as well!

Food was GREAT, mostly made onsite and our service was outstanding. Granted we came on a slow Tuesday afternoon...but this house made ranch would be worth the wait

Probably the best place I've eaten in many of the states I've traveled. Almost every menu item I tried was original and well done. The pizza, calzones, salads and definitely the appetizers were outstanding. The beer selection was one of the best I've seen as well. Will definitely be back.

Very beautiful and nice place to eat and the staff is wonderful

I love this place, the owner treat me and my family VERY well the pizza is so good. You need to come here 10/10

Super cute atmosphere, trendy, amazing food, affordable dishes. Right up the street from the heart of New Glarus

Stopped in for lunch as large group (9 adults, 6 kids). They had our order for 4 pizzas in right away (not including our gluten free pizza) and drinks on table in no time. Great pizza, great experience and couldn't recommend them more if you are looking for a great meal!

Good food, great service, good value, quaint outdoor seating in a nice spot.

The pizza was delicious and the waitstaff was very friendly and attentive.

We had a reception there last weekend and the service was great. They made room for a cake table and we were able to do pictures. The food was awesome. Atmosphere was wonderful, it felt like we had the place to ourselves but we didn't. Scott was the server and he was fantastic. He was on top of everything. We did not have to look for him he was available all the time. It is fun place and family friendly. Thanks again for the memories.

Calzone to die for, pasta dishes are superb. Portions are large, which is great (for lunch the next day too). Nice place to meet with friends. Very clean and has a friendly staff.

WOW heard this place was good, don't get up to Wisconsin often. We ate outside on the patio, the atmosphere was super. The service is great, the food is fantastic & the prices are very reasonable. What variety on the menu, can't wait to find a reason to go back to the area.

order pizza, wait 1hr 8min for 4 mile delivery, put in oven for 15 min. and yes it is tasty. nuff said.

Fantastic and flavorful food, I like the ambience the place has, and the cashiers were very kind. I will surely come back in the future.

Loved it. Perfect spot for an evening with family. I can't wait until warmer weather so we can sit outside.

Have been here several times, have taken family and friends.

Amazing beer selection with great food. Definitely gonna be my go to when i go to whenever im in New Glarus

GREAT food and cozy environment. Jenni was an awesome server. Been to Octoberfest 6x and have eaten in all the other restaurants, but just realized this was here. A GOLD mine!!!!

Pizza was amazing! Staff was friendly and hard working.

Always great service and incredible pizza and beer selection!

The pizza and salad is the best love the outdoor dining

Good pizza, service and of course great New Glarus beer.

Delicious pulled pork pizza with excellent service.

Good hand made pizza but I think can make better red sauce besides that all great!!!

Fantastic pizza. Great service (fast, efficient, cordial).

After reading reviews, decided on saturday lunch in new Belarus. The place is very loud and echos with all solid surfaces. Service was slow. pizza and calzone were both burned on the bottom. There appeared to be interesting offerings on the menu but pretty sub par expeeience.

The many different pizza options sound so delicious and ots hard to choose! We gave the BBQ Pulled Pork pizza and it was amazing!! Super tasty food and wonderfully friendly service!

Love their pizza! Pastas are great too. Can tell they use quality ingredients. Take all family and friends here when they visit.

Great food and friendly service Def should check it out

Went the Sugar River Pizza last Wednesday night. 30 minute wait and no bar, but the waitress who signed us in (very friendly and helpful) got us some beers and we waited on the patio. There were still a considerable number of people waiting for tables when we were finally seated. Odd thing was that there were many empty tables in the restaurant and patio area. We sat on the second floor, and there were two tables in the center of the dining area with the chairs up on top of them. I just found it strange that they were only using about 2/3 of the available tables that evening. Anyway, our waitress was excellent, and the pizza was very good.

I have never left a Google review, no matter how bad the place was, but this was insane. Soup was a disaster. The waitress asked if we wanted our food because it was ready.... was handed a beer glass CAKED with dish soap after trying to order 3 different beers only to be told they got rid of entire categories of the beer menu. Ordered a gluten free pizza which turned out it wasnt. When I asked about it, I garauntee the kitchen staff lied to the waiter and said it was GF. Them the bill came... 53 bucks for 2 pizza under 12 inches and a beer. What a trainwreck!!

Small spot that may be a bit expensive, but the food and service is good. Positive experience for any age range. Has more than just pizza, including pasta, cheesecakes, etc.

Great food! Fun ambience on the Sugar River Trail. Wonderful staff. We went 3 nights in a row!

Fantastic pizza joint. We've been here on numerous occasions and had most of the menu at this point. I've not had a bad meal or a bad experience. Every server is great and the place is always clean and and tidy. My suggestion would be the mac and cheese and the taco pizza. Sleepers that i don't think get ordered much, and they're delicious. All the pizzas ate great, calzones are too. Highly recommend Sugar River Pizza.

I want to try everything on the menu! The bacon ranch pizza is awesome! Friendly staff.

Pizza was amazing!!! Got the baked potato pizza and was amazing. When I saw the description I didn't even notice it said ranch.....I'm not a fan of ranch and this pizza was amazing!! Definitely recommend.

One of the best pizzas I have had in a while!!! 100% recommended!!

Loved it! My group ordered a whole bunch of different specialty pizzas, and there wasn't a bad one in the bunch! YUM!

We were passing through the area and stopped into the New Glarus Brewery and while doing tastings we were talking to the brewery staff about places to eat. They recommended a restaurant called Sugar River Pizza. This pizza place is Amazing! Their service is fantastic and our server, Karen, was very attentive to our needs. The service is also prompt which makes it a great place to stop for travelers. The food is DELISH too! :)

Food and service is always great! A bit pricey but worth it for the quality of their dishes and their welcoming and friendly staff. My family and I love coming to Sugar River pizza when in the area.

Probably best marinara sauce I have had. Pizza was great. Right on the bike trail. Good beer selection.

Now I don't give a place 5 stars neily willy this pizza rocked, service was great and priced fairly. I had bacon and beef delicious will definitely be back.

Delicious pizza and very nice staff at a really good price.

Have been here a few times and the food is always good. Staff is also attentive.

Amazing food! My favorite pizza by far. The garlic spread is really delicious, and the mac n cheese is outstanding

Nice place, service was fine, I wasn't overly impressed with the menu or the food.

Good atmosphere, good food, helpful and friendly staff, good beer selection, especially local brews.

First time there. Food was excellent and we were well taken care of.

Always a great selection of beers and the best pizza in the area. Pastas and sandwiches are great as well. On a nice afternoon, it's nice to sit at one of the flame tables on the outdoor patio and have a few drinks while watching people go by on the bike trail that runs right along the east side of the restaurant.

Always excellent. Try their steak pizza. It's amazing!

I celebrated my graduation last night in this delicious restaurant. I am glad to say that it was a brilliant evening and the venue was evidently one of the reasons for this strong event. The crew contributed in a gorgeous manner, the food was delicious and my buddies were so glad. We shall definitely visit again for more celebrations. thanks very much.

Excellent pizza, beer selection and service. Really. Not kidding. The pizza is excellent.

Food was amazing, our waitress was frazzled bit we had 20 and the next table was 8. She got little to no help from her supervisor who was more intent in finding fault with us not pre ordering food.

Chris was out waiter and was amazing! We came in with 15 people, 9 of which were kids, and he rocked it! And what s even more amazing, our food was out so fast even though we were a huge group, all correct, and all amazingly delicious! I also eat gluten free and it was delicious and no adverse reactions which is another huge win!

Having been born and raised a couple of hours from one of the pizza capitals of the United States, I hesitate to compare Sugar River Pizza to pizza from that fondly remembered time of youth...but I will (in this way that won't get any of my bones broken): if you are within a hundred miles of Sugar River and feel like pizza - come HERE!

Nice Italian joint with pizza and good pasta. Big portions for the food. We got the mushroom ravioli and it was alright, nothing to write home about. There isn't anything special to make it stand out but good place to eat out if you're looking for a bunch of food.

This place has the best pizza I have ever had. If you can stop, do it. I'd recommend the mac and cheese pizza if you're in for something different, but everything is good!

So good. Hailey was s fantastic server. Great selection for everything.

Awesome service. I ve traveled all over the world and this is one of the best pizzas I ve ever eaten. Incredible

New Glarus stop. We had the bruschetta which was very good and the mac n cheese pizza. Figured we'd try something different. Will he back when on the area