Storyville Coffee Company Review

I love coffee (make espresso drinks daily) and although I think their roasted beans are quite good, today for the first time I bought a cafe latte (for a whopping $6) and was very underwhelmed. The milk aspect was tasty but there was very little coffee flavor, which resulted in a weak tasting latte. So it may be better to order an espresso or macchiato here, rather than a cafe latte. I think that the milk drinks are vastly superior at numerous other places, including Espresso Vivace, Herkimer, Victrola, Broadcast Coffee, etc.

Great coffee and the customer service is excellent. Nice seating area.

The drinks are amazing! Also, the freshly baked food there is great!

Great for a relaxing morning. Comfy seats, great breakfast sandwiches, and great coffee.

Had the cold brew, it's fantastic. You can watch them roast at the same time.

Coffee is decent, but a larger food selection is needed.

Good coffee. Cool environment. Coffee roasted in house. Just wish they had more sweetener options, just raw sugar and honey. Oh yeah the coffee shop is up stairs and there's no obvious ada access so there is that.

Great service. They truly make you feel like you are wanted. There is nothing wrong about this place - outside, I wish it stayed open later.

So far so good! Just got the coffee beans today. It was roasted on the 14th of May so it is 2 DAYS OLD. Normally we do not grind them for about a week after roasting so will have to wait, but the aroma from the beans is great. Can't wait to try them. Thanks very much for the prompt service.

Probably the best coffee I've tried. The roastery tour was neat, freshly-baked cookies are always welcome. Eat the Tillamook bacon egg and cheese sandwich!

I do not know why so many stars from so many people. I live and often go to Storyville, and there are 2 consistent things. The condescending, I am doing you a favor by helping you the $14 for half pound of coffee beans. One guy wanted me to buy a 2 week old roast when he had a fresh batch right behind him. It is not for sale he claimed, asked him why would I pay $14 for half pound of 2 weeks old coffee he got upset and wished me a good day. The roast is good the service and employees are consistently apathetic and condescending.

The best place for coffee... period. I've been a regular customer to the roastery location on Bainbridge Island since 2016, and I can't get over how amazing the espresso, food, and people are. Every staff member wants you to have a wonderful time and a great cup of their espresso made with love (looking at you, Nick!). It is consistently wonderful, clean, warm and inviting. Plus, it's just really cool to watch them roast on weekdays. If you're there at the right time, they bring around free warm chocolate cake - just because. I can't recommend this place enough to friends, residents, or visitors looking to relax with a perfect cup.

Great place to relax and have a cup of joe... or an americano. Tasty treats - don't be surprised if a server shows up next to you offering a free slice of cake or pastry to try.
Good free internet & table games too.

Delicious coffee, and a great place to meet. The building is open and airy, and has plenty of nooks and corners to sit. The breakfast sandwiches are also delicious. I'm glad that they are open early enough to grab a coffee on the way to catching a ferry!

Storyville from Seattle is an artisan coffee company that I highly recommend. On their website they bill themselves as America s # roaster and their mission of ending human trafficking and to Love Everybody is one I can definitely support. When I made my order it was promptly packed and shipped off. I like the style of their packaging, especially the fact that my beans were literally roasted just 2 days before I ordered them. Upon grinding them and brewing my coffee I was treated to an aroma that was notably more pleasing than the competition. Their customer service is also top notch. If you are a coffee connoisseur, I think you won t be disappointed if you give them a try.

Super delicious everything! It is so awesome. Everything is freshly made and it smells so good when you walk in and smell the freshly roasted coffee and freshly baked pastry. Love It!

Wish there were more locations in Kitsap of this place, my all time favorite coffee In Kitsap. Homemade granola, great stop for breakfast or lunch.

The people here just may be the friendliest on the planet. You can tell they genuinely love what they do. Good coffee, delicious breakfast sandwich with thick bacon and pesto goat cheese on a pretzel bun, relaxing atmosphere and super cool story. A must visit when you re in Bainbridge.

Package arrived yesterday. finishing existing Coffee and with try yours soon.
I am Senior and will stay in touch as needed and not constant shipments which will drive me crazy. Thank you the packaging is impressive.

This is Storyville s homebase shop and roasting room, and it s totally worth the drive just to see it! The lofted shop sits in the middle so you can peer over and watch them roast and bake everything. Pro-tip: if you re here during cake time, they give a free slice to everyone inside! The baristas are friendly and make coffee approachable to newbies. You can expect a moderately busy shop, with about 20 seats. I always get an iced americano or cortado, and you should definitely try one of their in-house baked pastries.

Drink coffee while you watch coffee beans roast. Tasty food and friendly staff.

The employees are warm and welcoming people! We were very impressed with their kindness and care. The coffee and pastries are delicious. We will definitely be back. :)

Great presentation, but the coffee is even better!!!

Love the lattes with almond milk... Yummy... love the massaged Kale salad...love the great atmosphere... it's a super place

So nice! Great service and coffee. Bonus surprise was the delicious chocolate cake!

I love Storyville, great coffee and super cool customer service, one of the best

I LOVE the coffee here - They make the extremely smooth and delicious latte's and Mochas. You can't go wrong with their breakfast sandwich either - Probably the most delicious breakfast sandwich ever!

Remote Worker Critique - They have space to work as, but not many power outlets, the music is often loud, and since they close at 4 you can't get a full day of work in at this spot.

I have had storyville coffee at the Pike Place location before and enjoyed it, but this location really didn't hit the spot for me. I tasted both of the housemade alternative milks, date-sweetened almond and coconut-hemp, and both were really bad. The almond would have been fine without the date, but it really ruined the taste of the coffee. Coconut milk should never be used in coffee in my opinion, because the flavor also really messes with the coffee flavor. For a specialty coffee company I hoped for better.
This being said, the service here was great, which deserves them a couple of stars. Maybe go here if you don't need alternative milk?

Mars Hill Church founders will never see any of my dollars. There are plenty of other fantastic coffee places to patronage.

Fantastic coffee, environment and service! It has a great theme and comfortable chairs to enjoy your stay

Wonderful coffee and the best chai latte I've ever had. Very friendly staff and a fun cozy atmosphere. Love that they have a mission to help stop human trafficking. One of my all time favorite coffee shops.

Great cup of coffee and stellar food. The atmosphere here is awesome. The staff was amazing as well. Highly recommended.

These folks know coffee. Interesting place, you can watch the coffee being roasted from the tasting room upstairs.

Nice consistent coffee and you get the flavor of how they make coffee from beans. Its my frequent stop whenever i go to Bainbridge.

Only been drinking coffee for a year, but so far my favorite ones I've had. Excellent atmosphere and super friendly staff.

Great cappuccino, great pastries, and the best yogurt+granola I've had in ages. Sensuous, melt-in-your-mouth yogurt. You'll pay a bit more for your morning treat, but the first time you come, you'll get a (very nice) free mug to offset the cost...and after that you'll be hooked!

Excellent,delicious and the most wonderful, friendly, relaxing environment.

Espresso is of fine quality and even more remarkable are the skills of highly trained baristas. They carefully ensure everything from the detail of the grind all the way through extraction so that you enjoy a superb espresso unlike anything else.

Pastries and breakfast sandwiches are unique and incredibly flavorful, baked fresh every few minutes ensuring you get the very best experience possible. Breakfast sandwiches are made to order hot and fresh.

You won't find drip coffee waiting in thermos containers here. This is mainly an espresso bar. If you want regular coffee they will brew you a small or large pot via French press. For just a single cup they will make an Americano that is unbelievably good. They will patientlyntake good care of you, not plow you through line like others. They will explain what they do and ask what you like.

Experience it for yourself...

Storyville k-cups are bringing some luxury to working from home! They are really are SO much better than any other coffee I m glad there s the option to subscribe because after drinking these I d be disappointed with anything from the grocery store. Treat yourself and order some!

Really good food and coffee in a beautiful space. Prices are unreasonably high, though, relative to comparable places in Seattle, Portland, and Vancouver.

The cold press coffee and chocolate croissants were wonderful.

Fantastic coffee, great food, service wasn't bad at all.

This place has a very cool vibe. A mellow and relaxing atmosphere with some of the nicest employees you ll ever meet. The coffee was smooth going down. We enjoyed everything about this place plus they gave us a free coffee cup! Winner, winner.
Go try this place out. You will not be disappointed.

Really good coffee,but beware of tour buses of people coming to look at how they make their coffee beans! Also on the pricier side, but I'm willing to pay for a good Americano and a croissant that is flaky.

Nice, fresh roasted well-crafted coffee. There is a lot of attention to modern details, clean - almost too clean, mostly 'cause it's relatively new. The staff is very welcoming there are plenty of comfy spots to plunk down.

The coffee from Storeyville is excellent, even in k-cup form (seriously, if you need fast single-serve coffee at home, Storeyville's coffee will make it difficult to go back to anything else). Highly recommended.

This place makes it easy to hate. Dark, trendy and white. Doesn't love the elderly or disabled, no elevator, but one long staircase. Really? In a modern building. Prices are high too, a small latte and plain croissant will cost you $9.

Wow! You would never know that tucked away in a (really sweet) business park on Bainbridge Island is a treasure. Fresh coffee and espresso served inside a stunning roasting studio that looks and feels like a museum. They roast fresh coffee every week and mail it to your home. Thursday is now my favorite day of the week.

If you appreciate great coffee, well pulled shots, thoughtful design, and baked fresh daily pastries that would make a grown man hit his daddy...

Great experience from the service, ambience, aroma, food and of course the coffee.

The worst! The ham and cheese croissant was cold and hard, we only got one when we ordered two. When we mentioned this the kitchen girl shrugged and basically said too bad. My wife said she has had better cups of coffee at gas stations and the kids said their hot chocolates were just warmish milk.
Never going here again!

I thought Mukilteo Coffee was the best in Puget Sound. Don't get me wrong, I still love them - but Storyville has edged them out. You can literally smell the coffee through the box when it arrives. It's just perfection.

Amazing place for food & coffee! Very cool environment with tons of coffee beans and they are roasting them in house... Cool scene to see!

Wonderful staff. Let us charge a tablet behind the counter. Brought waters to us without request. Lovely.

So Happy to see that delightful brown box on my doorstep. Everything was perfect. My son in NC gets your coffee delivered, now My Husband & I will enjoy your coffee in Oregon. Thank you for making us believe that great coffee is available by mail.

Found a gift card for $5.00 off a $13.00 bag of Esther Mae's designer granola from this location's grand opening two years ago, no expiration date. Tracked the place down, and though the gal at the counter was very pleasant, they decided not to honor the voucher. In situations like this can't is simply another word for won't.

Yummiest coffee around. Not your run of the mill latte! A nice secluded spot to sip and nosh. And sometimes you get free cake, fresh from the oven :)

Super awesome places, a lot to see, great parking and super clean. The employees here are super nice. Great great experience definitely will visit again!

Been drinking this coffee ever since the day the shop opened on 1st and Madison (bribing us with free cookies and coffee each morning worked!) and still haven't found anything better. From the smell of opening a fresh bag to watching the coffee 'bloom' in my pot in the morning, I love this coffee! Some of the nicest baristas and customer support teams around too :)

Unique coffee profile, while they don t have oat milk with the cashew milk, it s pretty creamy. The staff are nice and lots of seating area in the 2nd floor.

While visiting the island we ran across this great gem! Very knowledgeable staff answered questions, made great recommendations, and made our experience awesome. Great hospitality. I can't say enough!

The barista/o? Timothy was really great. His cold brew was phenomenal! I'd give 5 stars if they sold the stuff they were using, only 1 blend for sale :(

Great espresso drinks with friendly and incredibly helpful staff.

Today was the first time my family went into Storyville. There was a man downstairs packing up coffee that seemed real crabby and he s the first person you see when you walk in. We smiled at him and he just stared at us and didn t say a word. The baristas upstairs were really nice and the coffee was excellent
But the man downstairs did NOT make us feel welcome. Walked by him again before we left to see if maybe he would be more upbeat and nope. Same grumpy stare.

Tasty fare and fun table games, but on the spendy side.

The barista with the short hair and tattoos is so awesome. Helpful but not to saccharine. Thanks!

Best coffee on the island hands down. Their baristas are excellent, consistently pulling perfect shots. If it's not perfect, they'll insist on remaking it without being asked.

The beans they sell are some of the freshest you'll find. Especially if you have a decent espresso machine at home, you'll immediately tell a difference with these beans.

Wonderful espresso quality, food options and super friendly staff. They seem to genuinely enjoy their job. Like coming to this spot once a week at least.

I love that everything about Storeyville makes me feel special.

Fantastic coffee. If you visit, the coffee shop is upstairs behind the wall. Limited selection of non-coffee drinks, but really delicious.

By far the best latte in Bainbridge Island. Never, ever disappoints. Super nice staff and baristas. They know what they are doing.