Sonny and Tony’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant Reviews

Well done respectful establishment.
Pizza viva siempre

You can Never go wrong with anything you order from here. Great food, amazing service, and delicious left overs to take home too!

My delivery order had gotten mixed up this evening, I called them to just give them the heads up, and within 1/2 hour, there was a knock on my door, and a delicious meal was handed to me. They truly care about the meals they make and the people they are serving it to... and that s obvious as soon as you take your 1st bite.

John and his team are absolutely amazing! Best pizza in the area. Being a vegan, they told me that I can bring in my own vegan cheese to enjoy my pizza to the fullest. After finding out the garlic knots had parmigiana cheese, the team here offered to make us a fresh batch without in order to meet our dietary needs. Overall extremely amazing experience with great food and a great team!

Excellent food, huge portions very clean and great staff! Very accommodating with special requests as well. Pizza is phenomenal as well as the pasta dishes. We've eaten here many times and we have enjoyed everything so far. Sonny and Tony's is worth a try...

Absolutely amazing restaurant. Servers are great and the food is awesome. I've been going here for more than 5 years now and I'm satisfied every single time. Their grandma pizza and calamari are the best.

Great pizza; loved the pepperoni roll with side of fantastic marina sauce. For 3 years in a row we have stayed at nearby hotel on road trips south just to get dinner here. They are consistently delicious (unlike the Mahwah Homewood Suites that gets more run down and less maintained every year).

Family style dining and pricing without the fancy ambience. Try their zuppa di pesci.

Fabulous fresh salads with beautiful greens (steak, chicken and salmon to top). Staff attentive to allergens. Of course, good pizza.

Antipasto salad with creamy Italian was awesome. Prepared and presented perfectly. The pizza however seemed rushed. Toppings were in huge chunks, not diced or chopped. Outer edge of pizza was nice and crisp, everywhere else was overly soggy. Pizza could have certainly been better with more attention to prep.