New Yorker Pizza & Pasta Review

The service was a bit slow for no one being there, but they were very friendly and the food was great!
I ordered the luncheon lasagna, salad and bread.

Great Pizza, wonderful atmosphere to dine in or take out!!! You'll Love it

Pretty decent pizza, server was friendly and attentive

This was a place with nice atmosphere. The staff were kind with quick service. The pizza was AWESOME! But I ate too much of the fresh bread, so I could only eat one slice of the large pizza pie...

Love this place. Service is decent. Pasta is delicious as is pizza

Great environment, friendly staff, and awesome pizza!

I m from New Jersey & this place reminds me of home. Even the hoagie rolls are the right consistency. Great food and great prices!

Super nice staff. Great food. I will make this a regular spot

Usually great food and great service. Not so tonight....spaghetti and chicken alfredo took over 30 minutes to get to the table. Manager on duty said she was discounting 40% discounted atound 4%. GRRRRR.

This was my first time going so I ordered the safe pizza. Pepperoni and sausage. I've never had authentic NY style pizza so I cant compare but this pizza was fire....the small was 18in I believe. The crust was flakey, not gooey like Papa Johns and not cracker consistency like Pizza hut thin crust. Best sausage I've tasted in a while too...going to try supreme next time.

Really good. Straight up ninja turtle pizza. Super greasy. Also you get A LOT for what you pay for there small is probably some peoples large.

Great pizza! Always generous with the toppings. The service was great and accommodating. Will definitely come back time and time again and recommend to everyone!

Great food, great service. Luv their garlic bread with marinara, calamari, and pepperoni pizza. Their small is like a Lil Caesar's large

Food here is fantastic with good portions. Excellent value for money. & management very helpful and friendly and all the waiters are so awesome and friendly. Would highly recommend this place for everyone.

I'm from NY so was willing to try ... nothing like NY pizza ... just sayin

Best "NY style" pizza I've found in Arlington. Close to the stadium. Fast, friendly service and excellent prices.

Some of the best pizza in the DFW. It has the flavor of the east coast pizza I ate as a kid. Wish I lived closer, I'd go more often.

Great authentic (fold over) New York style pizza. We are from out of town and ordered delivery to our hotel. The girl that took our order was very friendly. The pizza arrived hot, fast and delicious. The driver brought it strait to our room on the 3rd floor. The wings were good too.

The customer service is the best I've seen at a Resturant. The waitors and waitresses are so friendly I highly recommend this place to anyone!

The fact that you reached out says something Thank you for your time Jennifer.

First Time i order from here.. best pizza... i will order from here from now on. :)

Food tastes great but they are always very very slow.

We love this place. Food is really good, and the owner is always nice and makes you feel welcomed dining in or just picking up a togo order.

Antipasta Salad with house dressing is off the charts!

This is by far one of my favorite restaurants. Best pizza and good service.

Nice place. But prices are not competitive. Very small sub sandwiches compared to fire house sub. Very dark in dining area. No light hardly.

Love this place. Clean. Authentically Italian. Great service and food. We had spaghetti and pizza.

They gave us spaghetti out of a bag or something he was trying to be slick about it was two Spanish guys in the kitchen being lazy never again will we eat here

My wife and I had our first date here 12 years ago, we try to come back every year on the same day to get a meal. I think next year we will need to find something else. The calamari was very bland, so was my shrimp alfredo. It tasted like there was no salt in any of it at all. The red sauce to dip my calamari in tasted burnt. I had to go grab some ranch from the fridge to make it better. The shrimp were tough, probably cooked too long. I'm kind of sad that this was the outcome.

I will say that the pizza smelled amazing when I went to pick my order up. I had regrets for not ordering at least a small pizza for a Saturday lunch... Hopefully the pizza tastes as good as it smells?

I gotta say, this place makes the best pepperoni cheese pizza. I'm from queens New York the pizza made me feel like I was back home and now that I know about this place when I am craving pizza or a chicken Parmigiana, I am so ordering from here.

Arlington TX??? If I never left my hotel room, I would think I was really in NYC. I travel for a living, this is one of my top 3 Italian joints outside NY, NJ.

My order, Baked Pasta combo & Veal Parm Sandwhich.

Delivered to Lamar & Brookhollow Plaza Drive in 34 Minutes

One complaint I called them about. they need better silverware for delivery & take out.

Worst customer service and food wasn't like NYC unfortunately

one of the worst pizzas in Dallas, I seriously think they buy them frozen and then bake them, I wouldn't be surprised if that s true.

WHY? paint, clean and make fresh pizzas. It's easy and cheaper.

Awesome food and great service recommend this location

Good prices on single slices. I've always had good service. Arlingtons finest frequent the establishment.

Ordered Ubereats from here. Packaging not sealed properly so half of the sauce from my lobster ravioli spilled. The lobster ravioli itself was doughy and obviously premade frozen... Just not good at all. Sauce tasted like it was a few days old

The food here is fantastic. Have been here many many times, and everyone always greets you with a smile on their face. Service is usually fast, and their rewards programs have saved me a ton of money! They can also tackle large carry-out orders with ease, and my company has ordered from them for many of our employee events.

Great food! After ordering a medium pizza (Alfredo w/ chicken and bacon) we received bread rolls and butter. After filling up on those we received the pizza and it seemed more like a large than a medium! We asked for a box immediately because we knew we wouldn't be able to eat it all. Definitely recommend, there are tons of other great choices as well!

We are by no means expert Italian food critics but this place was a slight disappointment. I ordered the meat lovers pizza and my wife the baked ziti. The staff was great, friendly and they actually waited on us. However the pizza wasn't that great. The crust was very crunchy which isn't how I thought New York style pizza was suppose to be. There was tons of cheese which I did like and a lot of meat but the crust made it taste like I was eating pizza on toast. The baked Ziti had a different sauce than we were use to, it wasn't horrible but didn't taste like normal sauce found in baked Ziti. Plus there wasn't a whole lot of cheese in it. Overall it was an OK place, but then again this could be very authentic Italian food, we just didn't care for it that much.

This is one of the best pizza places in Arlington! Super friendly staff, fresh made to order food and overall excellent experience. You actually get a Large pizza when you order a large! No some small thing like other places do... You can even get it delivered with Doordash!

I always get the Meat Lovers Pizza and it s spot on! For pasta I usually get the chicken parm. Perfect portion, saucy, and cheesy.

First time ordering from here but it definitely won t be my last. I m flabbergasted on how freaking delicious this pizza and chicken Marsala taste! This will be my only pizza place from now on. My tastebuds are doing somersaults right now. Wow!

I being living here for 3 months and since then I only get pizza from here they are awesome and the costumer service is great!! Keep your good job

Good food. Nice little place. Really enjoyed the lasagna this time. Always good, but better last night.

Great place to eat! Foods awesome and the waitresses are very friendly!

So good, reminds me when i lived in NY. Ive only had the pizza, reasonable price. It fills u up good, real cheese.

Great chicken fettuccine Alfredo. Food always arrives perfect. The chicken wings are the biggest a juiciest out there. Lots of meat on them bones. Love it. Pizza on Uber Eats, mixed bag. This crust just doesn't travel well.

Best pizza and italian dishes in the metroplex. I love their daily lunch specials and the canneloni and lasagna are my hand down favorites. I have found the service to be great and the prices are even better. I rate this place among my 3 favorite eating places in the City of Arlington (Cheddars and Mercado Juarez are the other two).

Amazing deliciosa pizza!!! Spaghetti is good as well

Good food but using third party apps (DoorDash or UberEats) they say the food is ready when it isn t. Food has been Ready for Pickup for 15 minutes and was just told it would be an additional 10.

I really liked it. We order it at work a lot. Not just your average pizza place. Large, fold-over slices, like you'd expect with the name.

When i lived in Arlington this was my spot for some pizza!! Its well managed and very well taken care of!!! Love the atmosphere provided by the decorating!!!

The food, in my opinion is good. Service decent. Their lunchtime deals are totally worth it. All in all for a small hole in the wall not bad at all. Definitely recommend!

Delicious! My guests loved the pizza and I loved the service!!!

Great pizza, cannot disappoint! Simple place, but the pizza is outstanding. Pepperoni, Spinach Alfredo, and Canadian Bacon/Pineapple, all were a huge success with the family. This was the only slice left... for now. Huge pizzas...

I worked here for a year or so and I can say it has been the best choice I ever made for myself. The owner is the sweetest person I have ever encountered and so is her family. This business has not only brought joy to my heart but also to my taste buds! I still dream about their pink sauce chicken parmesan, I love it so much!
If you are looking for a family friendly place that has amazing service with amazing pizza/food please don t look any further and buy from them. It is definitely worth your money and your taste buds will thank you very much!!

Best pizza we have had! Took us 4 years to find a place that compared to home. My brother comes in town and has to have this pizza. Going later today for more. Delicious, hot out of their oven and even better cold.

I have been eating here for years they have always had wonderful food!

My wife and I lived close to New Yorker Pizza and went there 2-3 times a week. Now we live far away from them but anytime we are anywhere nearby we will go and eat a slice of GREAT PIZZA OR PASTA DISH. Great food and reasonably priced.
We've it.

The Best New york pizza in Texas periodt!!!
I'm a Brooklyn native and this pizzza is the truth!! ..It's the real thing

Absolutely loved the pizza and pasta here!will be coming back whenever we are in Arlington

By far the Absolute best food in the are Arlington area

Was good to eat here. Different pizza and was surprised

Good pizza, good service, nice cost ... worth knowing.

The pizza was amazing and they delivered to the parking lot 15 to all us truck drivers transporting the band around thank you so much