New Yorker Pizza & Pasta Review

Great food and people! Spoke with assistant manager and she was very friendly :)

OMG....so I ordered the New Yorker Murphy Pasta with shrimp.. ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!!!

No delivery after 9, even though they don t close for at least an hour after that. Pizza was ok, like mall pizza

Pizza is great, slices are huge, fair prices. Highly recommend to pizza and pasta lovers!

9:34pm: I called and got a "new York pizza and pasta the kitchen is closed at the time", so you guys don't close at 10pm anymore?!

Went there a couple of days ago (Tuesday) with my daughter and bestfriend. We was not impressed. The calzones was discussing. It was under cook and lack of favor. It had so much cheese that it was difficult to swallow. The dipping sauce was not fresh. It taste like it was store bought. The tea lack of flavor. I had an unidentified object flowing in my tea. I cannot forget about the stale bread. I would never eat hear again.

Been coming here multiple times a month for a while now. The staff are all very friendly and you get amazing food for the price. Would highly recommend.

Delicious pizza and awesome staff. Whenever I call to ask questions they are helpful.

Great quality pizza, thick dough and big slices. Lunch special is a great deal

Courteous, fast service, but it's not the best pizza.

This was the first time I have been to this restaurant, and let me tell you something - it was amazing. I had friends from work and we all loved this place. Their pizza is fresh, delicious and always make it the way you want it. I highly recommend this joint if you live in Arlington or north Forth Worth.

Just traveling through from out of state. Closely located to AT&T stadium, and family wanted pizza. I was wary due to location, BUT food was surprisingly good. Had a calzone (which is way more food than 1 person could eat lol), wings, cheese pizza (kids), and calamari. Only complaint was the calamari. BUT it's not a seafood joint, so didn't expect greatness. I just wouldnt order it again. Pizza, wings, and calzone were tasty!

One of the best places I ve been to. The staff is super friendly and quick to deal with any problems you might have. Always a good experience.

It's what we wanted at the time. Good enough to pass for the real thing in the real town.

After talking to my relatives in New York I had a taste for some authentic New York Pizza. So I Googled NY Pizza in my area and found this 4-star gem! I ordered a pizza brought it home it was delicious! hot crispy crust cheesy - my twelve-year-old loved it my 70 year old grand loved it! This is our new go-to spot for good New York thin pizza. First try was a charm!

Unassuming place, but friendly folks and excellent food. The table breads are outstanding and the pizza was great.

Food is great. The prices on the nicer items are good too. Atmosphere is a bit lacking but I'm more interested in taste and price.

My Dang!!! 18" Pizza cooked to perfection and served old school style at the table on a pastry stand. So Neapolitan that it had me second guessing myself and just enough New York to steal your cab and cuss you for it. My new go to when I'm in Arlington to say the least.
P.S. the wings are good too.
Overall - Location was find able. Cant say I liked the storefront much but don't let it throw you. Its pure gold on the inside. Staff is friendly (the Texas way) and seating is casual. Service is fast for a set down meal and apps are good. Clean serving area and semi-open kitchen gives that nothing hidden honesty about their quality. Only ding to the visit was the bathroom facilities which were somewhat bar like in the ambiance. But hey... Buccees has clean restrooms, but they aint got Pizza like this! I can stop on the way home.

Really good pizza! Love their pastas & cheesecakes as well. Can't go wrong choosing this place!

Awesome customer service! The twins are sweet and not your typical acting teenagers. There was a mistake on my order, no big deal, but they were really kind and checked with their manager and offered a free pizza on my next visit. They were very accommodating, kind, and cheerful. It was so refreshing to see such well mannered girls. I definitely will continue to use this place in the future!!

Good food at a great price. Especially the lunch specials

Why did they close down though. Best ex large pizza ever

Amazing pizza, and cheesecake! totally recommend it for those pizza lovers out there!

Very unprofessional. Called and ordered pizza and wings an employee guy got on the phone as i was placing my order out of nowhere stating he was the manager saying the delivery drivers dont want to deliver at my adress anymore cause i dont tip 1$ 2$ 3$ 4$ 5$ never have i ever heard of this before just trying to eat is all... Also my hubby payed for the 2 medium pizzas and wings just now which was $42.plustax was not a problem at all paying but the girl stating she was the pre-manager or manager charged us $50.plustax doesn't seem like there is any professional managers seems like a bunch of teenagers playing with us smh will never order from here agian!!!!

The Spaghetti was perfect and the Meat Sauce excellent and the bread was the best. The bad part was the Salad, the bread and the Spaghetti and Meat Sauce was so good I had to eat all of it a one sitting.
The only way you can leave here unsatisfied would if you don't eat.
Box in the picture is a medium pizza box stuffed full of excellent food!

Not the best Italian youll ever have, but for the price its very good. The bread is always hot and the calzones are great. Baked ziti is a big favorite at our office. Their pizzas are good as well (I like the white pizza).

I'm a Bronx native who's been searching for that NEW YORK taste and I found it here at NEW YORK !!!! Big shout to the staff!!

I m in love! I ve been going here since high school. I recently graduated college and moved back to Arlington and realized my love for pizza from only here. Although I m lactose intolerant, this is my once every two month pizza place of choice.

Good pizza....from Boston/NY. Great service and clean bathrooms!

This quaint restaurant in Arlington, New Yorker Pizza &Pasta, is very good! The food is superb! The Pizza is like back up North and is quality! And the price is on point. Service is wonderful. I would definitely recommend and cant wait to make the trip over there again to try it again.

Just had the spaghetti and meatballs. Meatballs were raw, not cooked. Must of been frozen, microwaved and just placed over the dish. Spaghetti was covered in marinara sauce. Ruined the spaghetti completely. Gave it to the dogs.You never serve spaghetti and meatballs covered in marinara sauce .

If your craving pizza and looking for quality this is definitely the place to come ! From pizza to pastas and wings you cant go wrong with anything on this menu . Wev been to several pizza joints and always leave thinking wev had better but New Yorker Pizza left us full and satisfied with every bite. We will positively be back and I recommend this location and chain to anyone who's wanting great tasting food .

Pizza had no sauce and under cooked maybe the worst I've ever had.

My go to local pizza fav!!! Always delicious and fresh! You've gotta try a slice or whole pie :)

It was s great place to come and eat we will be bacc

Great prices for slices and pizza is very greasy but that's what makes it great our only complaint would b that we heard one of the employee cough and sneeze and watched as he didn't wash his mouth let alone cover his mouth . We were disgusted but so hungry we just ate it . Staff is friendly and the wait time wasn't that long.

delicious delicious food. my colleagues and I always order from here. I enjoy just their pepperoni pizza the best, but time to time I get their ziti or lasagna. glad to see they are still open for business..

The taste of the food is great and the pizza is so huge in size, it s larger than a lot of pizza places. The customer service is great.

Excellent pizza and pasta! Family owned and operated. They treat their customers great and they have a nice reward system for those who dine often with them.

Nice pizza and pasta place near Lincoln square. Pizza slices are humongous. Pasta portions are plenty. They have a tomato based salad dressing that's really good (for some reason the server called the dressing catalina). Definitely will be going back.

I've been going to this place for over 10 years. They have the most consistent and best pizza in the metroplex. Extremely friendly staff. I make it a point to visit 2 or 3 times a month.

Was very loud when we were there. Party of 12 making much noise. We got our meals to go. It the food was good. We got home and in our loft we had some wonderful pizza.

The service was exceptional but the food was atrocious. The mozzarella sticks were frozen the chicken was hard and pink. Over priced for the quality of the food.

I hope this place never goes away, it has become my sanctuary!
I come here every single week and I tend to stick to the same order, but I love everything on the menu!
the New Yorker Murphy pasta is a DELICACY, especially with both chicken and shrimp!
And their pizzas are AMAZING!
The prices are EPIC It doesn t get any better than this , trust me I ve tried plenty of pizza and pasta places none compared !

I ve been coming here for four years now and I would literally cry if they close down
COME CHECK IT OUT I tell all my friends and family about this place!

Great pizza here. Also ordered shrimp alfredo, which was also fresh.

The lunch pizza special is amazing. Can't go wrong with new York style pizza!

FYI- come for the pizza not for the salad. I came in here again and decided to try something from the menu. The salad is literally a bed of (wet)lettuce and a couple of tomato slices. I have enclosed a picture.

Good food. Restaurant is a little rough and needs a redo. Perfect hole in the wall local pizza place.

Closest to New York Pizza that I've been to in Texas

I used to love this place but since they change the waitress is a mess , today i got a hair in my plate of bread, she took the plate with the bread came back with a empty one never said nothing , i had to ask her for new piece of bread that i was starving for lol this is the 3rd time that i come and be disappointed very sad this been my favorite place for pizza

This is a great place with really good food. The pizza was great. My family had pasta and other dishes and everything was very good. It wasn't expensive and was casual. We came from ballpark is shorts and Ts and felt comfortable. The wait staff work together to take care of everyone so you don't have to wait for "your" server.

Best pizza around, prices are very reasonable, staff very friendly and helpful

Seriously, best pizza in Arlington. I love getting a side of the alfredo sauce to dip the complimentary bread in. The salad is good, the pasta is good, the wings are good, the pizza is great! I have had a couple birthdays here! Love this place, really!

Favorite Pizza place! Fresh pizza and best lasagna. Our go to place when we can't agree on food because everyone loves it.

I always come here for the meat lovers pizza and the sweet and spicy wings. I don't know what's in the sauce for the wings, but it's ridiculously good! Has the perfect kick if you like spicy food! The paizza dough always comes out crisp and never undercooked. The ladies working the cashier are always really nice as well.

Got a 18" pizza with sausage and bell peppers and grandad the price was only 15$ it was flavorless. I wont buy from here again. At least their pizza

We came after the Cowboys game at the AT&T stadium. Trying to find a place to eat without an hour (or 2) wait seemed impossible, then we stumbled across New Yorker after some Googling. The young lady that was working at the counter had INCREDIBLE customer service!! She had a table waiting for us after we called asking about the wait, cake and took our order when she noticed we were ready, and had someone get refills for us when she noticed we needed more drinks (and she wasn t even our server). She went out of her way to make sure the customers were happy all while manning the front counter. The food was GREAT! Pizza is awesome, Chicken Francese hit the spot and the Chicken Carcoifi was so creamy and a huge portion!! Will come back if we come back into town. :)

Delicious pizzas!!!!!!!! Best I have EVER had. Quality is superb and at great prices. Our new pizza place :)

Super tasty pizza, doesn't matter which one you get...every topping-laden bite is gonna be delicious!

Best as you can get to REAL New York pizza in Texas. Yes!! Wish we lived closer.... I'd eat there way more.

One of the best! The white pizza they serve is so unique! Also the house dressing is so good! Like a mix of marinara & Italian that is just right with the rolls they serve. Also they do a great lasagne & salad for catering to company parties or house get together we have used multiple times. We go back once a week!

Very Good Tasting Local Pizza!!

All there staff is so Friendly and Kind... went with me several times to see if we were ok!

Awesome Place to Eat!!

Really good quality pizza. Possibly one of the best in Arlington. I will be returning.

Average as far as spaghetti goes, big helpings & decently priced I suppose.

Tasty late lunch with my dear friend LL.. food was superb.. will be coming back.

Best pizza in Arlington. Family night every Thursday.

The best mouth watering pizza around! The atmosphere is fantastic and they do have takeout!!!