New Yorker Deli Review

I've been going here to eat for about 34 yrs their subs are awesome!! Reasonably priced to.

The New Yorker is a true delicatessen it has been around for ever. Great Sub's and my wife says the Reubens are the best she ever had. Come with a big appetite because the portions are huge. They have kid's menu. They have beer and wine too. Any time we are in Roanoke you will find us there.

Been going for years. Order the Vagabon usually the bun is butter toasted but eas cold. Took away from a great sandwich. Disapointed. Sevice was good though.

Great price for the huge sub you get! If you are in a hurry be sure to order before you go, if not you will be waiting at least 20 minutes, especially around lunchtime. And bring cash!

Great place to get a sandwich, still has that old time feel. I usually eat here on every visit to town. I highly recommend the Onion Wheel sandwich

Wow! You can't beat the New Yorker Deli on Williamson in Roanoke, VA. The food is excellent, but you can tell that for yourself as the parking lot is usually packed. I personally get the Torpedo sandwich and ask them to, "burn the bologna," but you'll find the menu is quite extensive. They're always closed on Mondays. They do not accept credit cards - CASH ONLY! Enjoy!

The only place worth eating in Roanoke. I eat there everytime I'm in town.

This is a place my family has frequented for many years. I'm third generation,and adult children also frequent. Service is usually good,food quality is usually good ! The comrodery is always that of ages 18-80. Really good family owned!

Love it the new yorker sub is the best I would go back and I have

Worst food poisoning I've ever had. My friend and I met there for lunch Friday and we both became sick shortly after. It's been days and I'm still not back to normal. I am going through the proper channels to make a formal complaint with the health department. Nothing in the restaurant seems clean. I used to go to the New Yorker often and enjoyed it but haven't been in a few years. I was excited to go back but I never will again.

Still the best in Roenocke If you haven't been you are missing out

Always good and great service! Enjoy eating here always.

The ceiling was filthy. Outdated decor and menu. Also, staff was unfriendly. When I ordered, it was like I was speaking another language, because I thought that you could order somerhing off the menu. I was just met with a dumbfounded stare. My sandwhich's bread was stale and tasted like it was mivrowaved, and it was a steak roll, not sandwich bread. The cheese was stale also. As I was leaving, I looked in the dessert case, and the "amazing" cheescake had an orangish tinge. I definitley breathed a sigh of relief when I got out of there. Please, if you ever plan on going here, reconsider!!!

I love the New Yorker! Their only downfall is that they ONLY accept cash...what's up with that? Who even carries cash nowadays? At least put an ATM in the lobby to get cash out, that would really help out!! Best subs in the valley by far.

This place is AMAZING!!! The best sandwiches around if you are in the area you must STOP trust me its well worth it! If you ever want a delicious extremely hearty Ruben or Sub this place has you covered. I grew up in Philadelphia and can attest to what I believe is a quality and delicious hoagie and this place ranks high for me. Great great deli, great prices, excellent mouthwatering cheesecakes.....you hungry yet? TRY THIS PLACE OUT YOU WONT REGRET IT

Best Bets:

Rubens, Subs/Hoagies, German Potato Salad, Deserts (especially Cheesecake)

Excellent service, the waitresses are extremely polite and helpful. Amazing for take out, and even better dining in. They have great food, staff, and service.

The submarine is amazing. I have been going here for years.

If you was beer this is the place to go but for food not so much

Very big subs with lots of meat. I wish I lived closer, I would eat there a lot. You can't beat the prices.

Delicious I don't have a photo but we had the torpedo and the submarine

Best place in Roanoke to get a Italian Sub! Love it! Also their deli meats!

Inexpensive, good food, nice staff. They take only cash

Best subs in Roanoke, only down side it's cash only

Located on Williamson road the New Yorker, is a landmark of Roanoke. From a great meal in a sandwich, the New Yorker sub, to great New York style cheese cake, this place has excellent food. My family has enjoyed this establishment, for four generations. And it is family owned and operated. The New Yorker also does take out, call up, place your order and it is ready in 20 minutes or less.
It is cash and carry only, no checks or credit/deblt cards.

Best Deli in Southwestern Virginia, love this place.

CLOSED ON SATURDAYS? I understand B&M Sheet Metal being closed on Saturdays, I even dig the cash only policy, but damnit man the family wanted to go consume some tasty homemade subs right now and hell if you guys are closed on Saturdays... sad.

Still have good food, but not like it use to be, at least sub wise.

They don't take debit card. Like come TF on man, it's 2019

Good local place in Roanoke. You cannot get a sub anywhere in the city that has more value. Lots of meat and cheese at a very good price. Remember to bring cash. No cards or checks accepted.

Every single time we have gotten take out (last 4 to 5 times), it has been wrong.

Large portions, old style restaurant. Service can very from very good to poor. Generally crowded. Meats are always fresh.

Consistently good food. Some of the best subs in Roanoke.

This place was a recommendation from a local, I just moved to the area from Florida. Wow, try the signature "Submarine" if you like coleslaw and peppers with a little bit of spicy peppers this sub is for you!!!

A must visit while in Roanoke. Been eating here for the past 40 years.

I love the torpedoes. Can only eat half of the subs. Customer for 40+ years.

I live in VA Beach now. When people ask me where to get a good sandwich, I tell them to take 460 to Roanoke and turn right on Williamson Road for about a mile to the New Yorker Deli. There are a few bigger, a lot fancier, a few cheaper, but none better.

I love this place it's the boom great food and service

Love this place, great food at reasonable prices,,, just remember (CASH ONLY)

Amazing subs and sandwiches! Just make sure to have cash with you because they do not accept credit card

They have lots of great sandwiches been around for several several years.

The worse service I have ever received. I will never return or recommend. I waited several minutes (this was a call in order) for service and one employee walked right past me and didn't acknowledge me and then there were 3 more employees chatting it up at the meat slicer who also ignored me. BAD BAD SERVICE.

Classic deli, Good food, Good service, Good prices. Love it. Make sure you bring cash as they don't take checks or credit cards.

Best service, absolutely everyone is friendly, excellent food and great portion sizes for a great value.

My all-time favorite sandwich is served here! I will drive an hour to get one ....but coming here 30 years!!!!!