Main Street Pizza Reviews

Easily the best pizza on Long Island, the staff has some of the most friendly people you ll ever meet, and they re with it. Any low rating reviews you ll hear are lies, probably written by miserable people spreading negativity during these hard times, that this establishment has been pushing through. Don t be shot and buy your pizza at Main Street Pizza Company

Awesome place. Best in Farmingdale. You gotta stop here

Went here a couple of times. Last time was right before Corona and food was okay. The service was terrible though. The employees were more interested in picking up girls than actually paying attention to their patrons. Had to wait an extra 10mins after my food came out to receive it, after the kids had to talk about some girl who picked up food and left. Classy. The guy who rang me up overcharged me also....

I bought a groupon for this place recently and called to see if they would honor it. Thank god I did because they said they would not. Not a big deal because I understand with Corona going on. However the guy on the phone was rude which seeing other reviews doesn't surprise me. No where on the groupon does it say call ahead so it would have been a wasted trip if I didn't check. Another example of poor management.

Fantastic food absolutely amazing must try if your in the neighborhood

This place was really a true gem that I found via my food Instagram page from others sharing there amazing pics of there food. The Big Mac Pizza was absolutely amazing it tasted just like a big mac but I was pleasantly confused if i was eating a big mac or a pizza and I was eating both it was amazing and the rice balls in vodka sauce was so good great flavor in the sauce I will definitely be coming back this is one heck of a good place!

Wouldn t give this place one star, but have to , ordered 2 pizzas for delivery, came half hour late, pizzas arrived cold and burnt ! Tasted like cardboard, will never order from them again, avoid at all cost ! Oh and when we called back to fix, owner put us on hold, never picked up .

Great buy timing was on point and food was great for a new pizzas company

Amazing variety of slices and alcoholic drinks for a great dinner with your friends

I decided to try Main Street Pizza Company on day one that they opened. They have their act together and then some! The rice balls were fantastic and reminded me of my grandmother s recipe. The grandma pie was absolutely delicious! I ate way too much in one sitting. So impressed! Highly recommend!

Some of the best Italian food around, be sure to stop in whenever your in man street

Went here last Friday with friends and had a terrible experience. Manager was very rude and arrogant. Attacked us before we even sat down because he thought we were using the rear entrance to cut through to main street. When my wife tried to explain he just ran into the kitchen. We left and will never return

I can t say enough about this place! Super clean & the staff were super friendly. The food was great. You have to try the Risotto Balls with Vodka sauce. They were amazing & they had every kind of slice you could think of.

Good pizza but wish you picked up the phone once in awhile

Charged more than posted prices on delivery found out after