Fratello's Pizza Reviews

The pizza was great!! The wings were awesome and the service was great!! Don't change anything. They even delivered to our house in Erin.

Nice touch on dropping off free pizza to the car dealerships in the area. We enjoyed the food and will definitely order from you in the future!

I lived in buffalo where the food is nearly impossible to beat. Fratellos barks with the big dogs when it comes to pizza pie. I love it and it's very filling with quality ingredients..like the pros

Food is excellent. Service is great. Why in God's name they're not there later on Saturday and closed on Sunday I'll never understand. The area is devoid of great pizza. This is great pizza. Late night cravings end up stuck with subpar offerings.

We eat and order from there a couple times a week the food is great they are a friendly family just all around good place

The pizza is the BEST!! The staff are friendly. Clean dinning!

On a Wednesday it took them 40 minutes for an eggplant parm sub and order of zucchini sticks! One couple at a table and 3 people in back..... Food was not great, very greasy, prices were on high side, and service was TERRIBLE. Too bad because Horseheads needs pizza/fast food places in town. Wont go again

Great tasting pizza..... whole family enjoyed
Very welcoming staff.....keep up the great work

Had a really good pizza tonight. Mushrooms tasted fresh. Friendly staff.

This is the best pizza that I have ever had and the chicken wings are plump and delious. The delivery is outstanding

We've tried many things on their menu and they are consistently excellent.

Food has great. Prices were normal pizza parlor prizes. Service has bad. Ordered take out. Was told 30 minutes. Arrived in 25 minutes. Told another 10 minutes. 20 minutes later was told it would be another 20 minutes. In all total I was waiting there for an hour and an half while they took orders and we're picked up while I was waiting.

They have a good product they need to expand the delivery area.

Our office has ordered from you several times since you've opened and we love it! Pizza was good, wings were even better!!! Huge chicken wings! We order out a lot and you have never let us down!

The pizza is really good, the staff is friendly, place is clean.

The outside of the building is deceptively abandoned looking even when open though.

Best real NYC pizza in the area!
Very thin crust, great sauce!

I ordered pizza for an office party everyone loved it. This pizza place is quickly becoming my absolute favorite the pizza is delicious the wings are great and the prices are outstanding.

Great food and enjoyed my interaction with several very nice patrons.

From Mansfield pa stopped in and glad I did Great Service And Great Pizza ....I will be stopping in again when I pass thru

The pizza and garlic knots are awesome and so are the people that work there. Very fair pricing as well.

Thin crisp crust, not a soup on a bread circle. good ingredients, I'll stop again.

While the food was good, the front counter experience was enough to kill my appetite. One girl behind the counter offered me a menu which I had requested and gave me time to overlook it. When it came time to order the girl at the register made it a point to look through me. I waited a few minutes and then another couple came in behind me. She talked around me to take their order. I was wearing no camouflage, and I take up enough space to be easily noticed. Not until she pointedly ignore me and made sure I knew I was with eye contact did the initial girl finish her task and come help me. The food was good which earned 2 stars instead of one. The chances of returning or suggesting to friends or family is slim though.

Pizza was great, friendly service. Will be going there again

We have ordered pizza here many times. We all love it!

Liked their pizza very much. Recently called them to aske a question. The person who answered was very friendly & helpful.

Terrific wings! Try the garlic ones with Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing. Pizza is very good as well.

I don't like rating and restaurant after only one visit. You never know if you caught them on a good day or a bad day. I ordered pizza and wings. The pizza was good, not great but good enough for me to order again. The wings were very good, but like most places these day, their HOT wings are more like medium. Next time I'll ask for extra hot and see what happens. Prices were average for this style pizza shop. PS: place was nice and clean.

Tried the pasta this time, fettuccini Alfredo with chicken. Possibly the best Alfredo sauce I've had! Homemade from a real-deal Sicilian family recipe. Had some garlic knots with it, made for the best meal I've had all week I think. Love finding this much variety from a small pizza shop. If they had steaks I'd never need to go anywhere else!

Our first time at the pizzeria today and it was a great experience! Amazing, friendly service and the food was awesome!!

Or go-to place for pizza, wings, stuffed shells, some times subs, etc. That sauce they have, it makes all the difference. They are friendly, and accurate, they make sure your order is right before you leave if you're picking it up, which we always do. And if something is ever wrong, immediate fixing it with no arguments. They want to make you happy, and serve great food so it's easy. They deliver too, average delivery times for the area, possibly a little bit shorter.

Was my first time there but it won't be the last.
This is authentic Italian Pizza. I would say it's the best in the area.
Give it a try.

Good pizza, quick service, average pricing. Will be back.

BEWARE OF DRIVERS! The drivers do not know how to drive. They will block any drive way and drive ridiculously. Talk to the manager and all he had to say was he was new. Didn't know new was a defense for not knowing how to drive

Great Pizza! Outstanding subs, everything fresh! The food quality was excellent.

Pizza is absolutely delicious! Also, they have the best meatball subs I have ever had! I will definitely go back again and I highly recommend it to anyone else.

We love Fratellos!! Generous portions and great food. A family business with friendly people.

Pizza was excellent and didn't have to wait very long at all for two large pizzas!

Huge meal was very good and great price very friendly staff. I would highly recommend.

Best Supreme Pizza ever, cant wait to try there other item .

First time only because I saw the delivery truck last night walking my dog. Buffalo chicken salad was delicious and the Jack Daniels wings were great
We will be ordering again

Excellent service, excellent price, excellent pizza

What sort of pizza place closes at 9pm on Saturday?!

Second time of trying to order, both times they re closed. Well done. Previous owners were preferable.

I would avoid this place. Never again!

We ordered the Mediterranean pizza for the first time .It was delicious and wholly reccomend it.
Service was excellent !