Fireside Theatre Review

Very good dinner buffet.The Christmas Story play was great.

Loved the food, the service and the entertainment was wonderful.

Very fun place. Amazing staff. Entertainment is top notch.

Excellent performances and surprisingly good food, considering the number of people eating at once.

Excellent food
Great show.

The menu was deliciously unexpected. We were a group of nine with five children and the kids meals were perfect as were the adult. The show as always was wonderful. Thanks to you all for an incredible family evening.
The Roger's and Hussin's

My husband and I just saw South Pacific. I have seen the play a few times at different dinner theatres, but this was by far the best production. Our food was delightful and our waitress was extremely attentive. Voices and dancing were wonderful. I can't wait for the next production. One word - AMAZING.

Just an overall great experience. The shows are always very good with what is probably much more talent than some would expect. The food is really good and usually familiar yet unique!

very well organized!! amazing food & drinks. outstanding servers. Loved all the shops & show of course!!

Fantastic time spent here. Food was delicious and the show was amazing. Price was worth it. Will diefinately be back.

AMAZING experience every time! Great food, great shows, great staff!!

Food was excellent! Show was very good and they have some nice gift shops for shopping.

Had to send the shrimp back as it was not cooked thoroughly.

The food is excellent, with a wide variety of items, and they have a staggering array of drink options. The servers I have dealt with have been very pleasant to deal with. The theater itself is cozy, and with the open floor plan, there is no such thing as a bad seat.

This is a great place. You get a 4 course incredible meal & a wonderful play all for the price of the ticket. I've been here 3 times & have never been disappointed.

Great food and service. Good prices too. Stage plays also where people come from far away to experience. Shops also

We love the show and Steve Watt's concerts everything was great except when it came to exiting the theater. You were very cautious letting back row people enter first filling the theater like an airplane back to front seating assignments were separated to be safe but when the show was over it was the whole theater exiting at once, why not have us exit front rows first to stop the congestion?

We LOVE Fireside Dinner Theater! They have amazing food and the shows are awesome! We've never seen a bad one yet, and highly doubt we ever will! I highly recommend going to Fireside!

Great theater in the round not a bad seat in the house.

I found the fireside awesome, its theater in the round. The experience was enhanced because my niece, Laura Cable was starring as Eliza Doolittle. A flower gril transformed into a Duchess.

Please support live theater its quite literally alive. Love it.

Why was Travis Maze removed from the Wall of Flame?

Great show! Great food! Would be more comfortable without the religious tones, but won't keep me away.

Exceptional performance. Great vocalists and band. Nice meal.

Never a dull experience here, food is good and the place is so big we've never sat in the same area.

Awesome place to celebrate our anniversary. Thank you for a great time!

Food was awesome:) service in restaurant was very good. Their performances are always good. We'll worth the money! !!

Always a fun experience. Food was delicious. Play was entertaining. Company was the best.

What a fantastic show! I wanted to just get up and dance! The singing was incredible....Norrell-hope to see her more! The band....outstanding! And of course, the dinner was superb. Always a fun time at the Fireside!

First time here. The price had kept us from committing to go before as we don't typically spend alot on our entertainment. It was a date night before our baby is born. Overall, my wife and I had a fun time together. Great meal and surprising atmosphere. Quality show.

Outstanding dinner theater; very special and unique experience. Expensive, but worth it for a once a year special family activity.

Overall DELIGHTFUL! From start to finish, highly recommend! The play had me laughing to the point of tears, kudos to the actors!! Thank you to the Fireside for a most pleasant experience.

Fantastic food and performance Thanks for the wonderful day!!!!!

The Fireside is my favorite place to go to for a great meal and entertainment. I have been going there more than 20 years. It is always an excellent experience, and the Broadway plays and live performances are the best in Wisconsin.

This is my second time to the Fireside I love the shows the first time I went with my brother and sister-in-law I love the food and the show in January of the country music impersonators however this last show of the 50 60s and 70s the show was fantastic however I cannot Rave about the buffet there was not enough food and they started shutting down one of the buffets before I felt it was necessary. They were not equiped to handle the crowd they had that night. The food was gone before I even had a chance to get a second plate I was very disappointed in the buffet but love the show hopefully next time the buffet will be a little bit better or not in such a hurry to shut it down

The staff is very pleasant and attentive. The place is typically busy so that is an accomplishment. I upgraded my dinner to the Sea Bass and really enjoyed it. The flavor was good and it was cooked appropriately. We also thought the show was well executed. The singing was great and the costumes for Phantom of the Opera were beautiful.

I love this place! I haven't been here in several years and forgot how awesome the experience is.

Always fun to see what kind of special drinks they have.

A place with outstanding entertainment and the shops are fill of unique items that you won't find anywhere else. It truly is an experience destination. I'm planning on coming back for other great shows in the future. It was so much fun.

The food and entertainment are good, but very pricey.

My wife and I have purchased season tickets for the last 5 years. We agree that the pass is for each others Christmas, Anniversary, Birthday etc. We get seven special evenings each year that we really enjoy. We prefer the Thursday evening shows that offer the famous Fireside buffet. We eat what we want and as much as we want. The food and desert is exceptional. We find the waiters and waitresses very friendly as well as the employees. The shows are always so enjoyable. We live in Fort Atkinson and feel blessed to have such a top notch, professional, big time entertainment facility literally less than a mile from our home. I'm wheelchair bound and have a lovely energetic wife. Lord knows what we would do for entertainment if we weren't blessed with such a wonderful dinner theater. Go to the big city for dinner, parking, movie, drinks and tips, I defy anyone to find a better value.

We hadn't visited the Fireside for more than 20 years, but have been back three times in the last two years, and hardly recognized it. The food is terrific, and the entertainment is Las Vegas quality! We're not sure how they manage to feed nearly a thousand people in an hour with hot, delicious food, but they've got it down to a science. And although the stage isn't Las Vegas-sized, the entertainment is every bit as good. Well worth the drive to Ft. Atkinson.

Drinks shopping lunch and a show great way to spend a day

I was brought here for a little birthday celebration with just my girlfriend. We arrived for the Sunday matinee of My Fair Lady.

First our evening here started with a meal and some drinks, all of which were fantastic. I had ordered the VOLCANO, which waitress informed me that this drink was meant for four people. (Whatever, birthday weekend) after she brought out the drinks and I finally witness this monstrosity for the first time, it made sense why was meant for four people. Needless to say I had a great time with this beverage and my food. My fresh baked bread was amazing, the soup was fantastic, the main course was very flavorful and Hardy and wholesome.

The entire building is really a pretty building, but the absolute best part of this place would have to be the actual play. I've always been a fan of the arts I've always enjoyed watching those who can perform their various talents do so. Everything from music, singing, lighting, sounds, costumes, and general performance of the crew was phenomenal. Hands down absolutely incredible.

So yes you may spend a pretty penny or two coming here to enjoy an afternoon or evening but you won't be disappointed oh, and if you are that's your own fault.

We have been going to the Fireside for the last several years for dinner & plays. We just saw Sister Act on 5/26 & it was fabulous, but the dinner was the worst I have ever had. The pork loin as they so called it was as hard as a rock, the food they served with it was so small that after the show we all had to go out to eat again, there was four of us & none of us could say anything good about the main entree. The desert was also horrible. The only good thing was the salad & even that you just got a scoop of. Very disappointed to say the least.

Always have such a great time but christmas story this year was by far my favorite!

Family tradition. We go every year instead of doing Thanksgiving dinner since we have a small family. They do a great production and dinner is always wonderful. Cute shops line the hallways for novelty and souvenir buys.

Great food, wonderful little shops and fun plays! Friday fish fry is great, too!

My daughter and I brought my five year old grandson to guys first play. He loved it, as did we. And the food was excellent.

Unbelievably talented people for their performances. Food offerings are well thought out to relate to the shows. Great atmosphere and a memorable experience every time.

Been here 4 times in the past couple years. I would go more often if I didn't live 4 hours away haha. The shows have all been fantastic, and the dinners they offer are always very amazing. It's a great place to share memories with as a family, and to simply have a great time. I can't recommend this place enough! :)

THIS WAS MY FIRST TIME THERE & THE SERVICE & FOOD IS AWESOME....WILL DEFINITELY BE BACK!!!

Awesome time! Small theater, great performances. Very reasonable price for dinner and a show. Food and restaurant were impressive. My family will be back

Great show this year.could use more wait staff in dining room.

Great food shows are spectacular staff is wonderful

It certainly wasn't a Broadway show and too religious for my taste.

This week has been my first time at the Fireside Theatre, and at a theatre-in-the-round. Both the concept, and Fireside's take on it were fantastic.
The friend I attended the show with was running late, and the manager had the good judgement to have our table set with the salads and drinks so we could start our dinner as soon as we entered. Well thought!

I loved the Thursday's buffet, especially the salmon, which I considered outstanding.
In relation to the show, I think the performance was remarkable, taking into consideration the characteristics of the theatre. To put it into perspective, I saw "The Book of Mormon" a few weeks ago at the Cadillac Theatre in Chicago, and the fanfare was certainly greater, but did not leave such a good impression as the production of "Once upon a Mattress." I guess it is not always about getting the biggest bang for the buck.

In comparison with previous productions of OUAM, I truly enjoyed this one a ton (exclusively based on listening to previous productions.) In my opinion, better than Sarah Jessica Parker's in the 90's. I think Carol Burnett would surely approve this production. :)

Things that could be improved:
1. I think soda should be included in the price of the supper.
2. It would be wise to have somebody at the Front Desk at all times. I understand I arrived 40 minutes before the start of the show when everybody is having supper, but I was feeling a bit anxious to pick up my tickets. Luckily, one of the staff members took care of me after a few minutes.

Overall, a great night. I will certainly come back.

What a wonderful fun place to go. The meal was very good, maybe a little pricey. The play was fantastic, what a fun place to go to celebrate a birthday Anniversay of any milestone. I highly recommend The Fireside.

I love the Norwegian cod with "awesome" sauce on Friday nights.

Great food, fun atmosphere and Top of the Line entertainment! You won't be disappointed.