Fat Witch Bakery Reviews

The pb and jelly brownie was underwhelming in flavor. Texture wasn t great, too crumbly like it was overbaked.

Good varieties of yummy brownie and with friendly service. Fat witch brownie is my favorite flavor.

Amazing brownies - my favorites are the brownie ends. The people who work here are also super nice. A must try if you're visiting Chelsea Market or in the neighborhood.

Really like their brownies with different favor.
You can buy single brownie, cookie to taste or buy some cute packages as gifts.

Always the best Brownies in the city. Been going for year.

Being from out of state, it was tricky to find. But boy the brownies were worth it! I tried the Raspberry and Turtle brownies and they we re both equally good. The edges were the perfect amount of crisp and the inside was so moist. Freshly baked that day! Definitely worth the calories!

Great brownies - the Fat Witch Babies are just the right size to get your brownie fix with minimal guilt. Cute packaging. Take a dozen to the next party as a host/hostess gift.

Great brownie. Lots of great looking baked goodies. Simple and attractive decor. Visited there recently and was surprised to see just how empty the Market was on a late Wednesday afternoon. I mean the Market was a ghost town except for a small line at Los Tacos No. 1. Spoke with the staff there who told me just how bad its been with the pandemic. I would hope as pandemic stabilizes and the warm weather emerges, business for all small business like this one will pick up.

As a Canadian visiting, seemed like the "owner(?)" was just a little rude, cause she was on the phone while we were cashing out and asking some questions - Sort of treated me as a person that didn't know anything. Aside from that, this place is one of those over hyped shops in my opinion, as 2 packs of small brownie baking mix will run you 20 bucks, while a bag of brownies would run you around 13 bucks. Steep. But regardless, the brownies are pretty good. I would give 3.5 if I could.