Enrico's Pizza Review

The service was horrible and the food was so salty I couldn't swallow it.

We've been eating here for years and enjoyed it every time. Delicious Italian food. We often get a side salad with standard Italian dressing. Servers hustle to get to everyone and it's often very busy at dinnertime. Carry-out line is usually long but moves quickly. Pizza with their homemade sausage is very good, as are their other Italian dishes, especially the lasagna. Get there early for a good seat.

Hands down the best, authentic pizza in Central OH! Hidden gem in Dublin worth the trip, every time! Cappacola and Hot Pepper pizza is our standard order!

Delicious pizza, friendly service and reasonable prices! Will be returning anytime I'm in the area!

awesome AWESOME pizza--crunchy crust edges n crisp pepperoni with perfect sauce n cheese.
STILL mourning loss of Rotolos but ENRICOs pizza today is even better

By far the best Dublin staple for pizza, local family owned pizza place! I will be going here for as long as they are around!

The most authentic and mouthwatering pizza you will EVER have! Has me coming back from Phoenix once a month or so!!! THANK YOU ENRICO S FOR YOUR SERVICES, YOU ARE TRULY APPRECIATED!!!

Without a doubt the best pizza & pastas anywhere!! Lots of love goes into that food and service! Pizza oven instead of conveyer belts is your first hint that fantastic food is on its way!!

We all choose where to spend our time and money, but the owners and staff of Enrico's act as if they are entitled to our business just because they have good pizza. We will no longer go to this restaurant after our recent experience. We (two of us) choose to eat there and upon our arrival were second in line to be seated. There were 2 waitresses working the very small seating area, and they waited over 20 minutes to clear 3 empty tables, despite a line that was nearly out the door. When they came to the line to seat people at those now empty and cleared tables, they asked how many were in each party, but still did not seat anyone. The older of the two waitresses acted so arrogant and careless that we decided to leave 10 minutes later. We will spend our time and money at establishments that respect their customers and appreciate that we choose to eat there. Do yourself a favor and don't reward this arrogant, selfish and entitled restaurant staff with your valuable time and hard earned money. See other ratings - most agree service is awful.

Best family pizzeria in central Ohio! It's been our family's favorite for decades!

First time here... Had pizza and italian sub... Pizza was fantastic, sub was good - that's it. Would be nice if they had fountain drinks instead of cans for dine-in. I will return.

Best pizza in Columbus, by far. Do yourself a favor and stop in try the sausage pizza.

Delicious! We have been getting their pizza for 15 years. Great, friendly customer service.

Awesome food. Decent to slightly expensive pricing, but worth it!

Family owned and opperated. You can always see the whole family in the back hard at work. Food is good and true to Italian style cuisine. Always very friendly.

Currently my favorite Columbus pizza. Warning to East Coasters: Square cut pies. Homemade sausage topping is a must-have.

This family-owned restaurant has been a staple in the Dublin area for a long time and continues to provide amazing food. , outstanding Pizza and excellent customer service. Once you go there a few times, the family members will remember your name and you will know theirs. Make it one of your favorites.

Ordered from Doordash. It was delivered early and is a great pizza. Will order again.

A good, family Friendly restaurant. The food extremely good. Some of the dinners aren't cheap, but they are not a massive expense.

I go here almost every Friday... great pizza...friendly staff!!!

They are by far my favorite pizza place anywhere in the world. I have had a lot of pizza, and this is the best.

Great Pizza. Never dined in, but plan on it. Highly recommend

A real mom and pop Italian pizza shop. A well kept secret.

Couple visiting from Colorado and wanted a family owned pizza place-found Enrico s and very pleased with the service and food. We had garlic cheese bread and medium 3 topping pizza. The food was served hot, the pizza sauce was tangy and unique and the toppings were fresh. We visit Columbus every few months and will return. Tiziana was our waitress and very polite. In addition, the carry out customers never stopped coming in and the tables were full-Saturday night.

One of the best pizzas outside of Chicago (nod to Giordano's), and I've eaten more than my fair share of pizza over the years. Order it for take-out, though. The atmosphere of the restaurant is like a small cafe and the service is average. But the pizza is excellent. Pepperoni, garlic, and tomato is our go-to.

There is no better pepperoni pizza. Their supreme and other pizzas are really good (but not great). Their pepperoni pizza, though, is second to none. The crust is aged with a slightly sourdough taste. And after all these years, it's still run by authentic, first-generation Italians. Simply amazing.

Went for lunch today and the owner s daughter was everything but nice. She even argued with me at my table about her own attitude. Food was great, but she was nasty!

The food was AMAZING! Very authentic! Service is always on point!

This is the best pizza available on the upper west side of Columbus. The crust has a great crunch to it, and the sauce has just the right amount of kick. The service is always friendly, and you can tell it's family run since the same dozen people seem to be working there every day. Great place.

Top notch pizza, well seasoned ovens. Entrees are great too, their sauce is the key - Oh, and the meatballs. Excellent family owned and run. Love it!

We were really excited to try this pizza. What a complete disappointment. Hardly any toppings, very bland. We won't be back.

A staple of my diet... absolutely love the food as well as the people.

I'm part Sicilian and from NE Ohio where we have Little Italy, Mama Santa's my favorite five star pizza. I've been trying to find a good family owned pizza here for years. This place is very good. Nice sauce, crispy crust, fresh toppings and oven baked pizza how it ought to be.

I called at 930pm on Saturday night to order a pizza for dinner after work. Phone rang over 20 times with no answer. Was totally looking forward to mot cooking dinner after work. But, alas, i had to cook after all. super disappointed.

Finally a pizza in Columbus. ..but wait is long. This is great pizza. Thick crust but crunchy. We had basic cheese and a white pizza with sasuage. Pizza is cut into squares, not pie cut. We actually went around 7 pm but couldn't get a seat. After looking for a mom and pop place we ended up back there at 8 pm. No waiting for a seat. Pizza did take a good 30 min. Was well worth the wait, especially it you are of Italian decent and are picky about your pizza! Next time we are here for Zoo and Waterpark we will order it for pick up. I did take a star do to the wait.

Enricos is a hands-down family favorite. We love their pizza and their service. We went on our first date here over twelve years ago and celebrated an early Valentine s Day with them just now- with many visits in between. We have introduced many friends to Enricos and all are returning customers. Food is delicious and the price is perfect. Familiarity and friendliness are priceless!

The best pizza I have had in this area. The crust on this pizza is perfection. It's well worth having to go pick this up.

Really good pizza! And the staff is also really quick and nice

Without a doubt the best pizza & pastas anywhere!! Lots of love goes into that food and service! Pizza oven instead of conveyer belts is your first hint that fantastic food is on its way!!

Love their pizzas. The place is always busy and for a great reason. You can dine-in or carry out.

Absolutely wonderful homemade, mom and pop pizza shop. Offering more than just pizza, with pasta options and other Italian favorites. This is a well kept secret that continues to please patrons week in and week out! A thin and crispy crust with plenty of cheese and toppings, if you like thin and crispy, this is a place to try!

Found this pizza shop while on way to Springfield.
My wife ordered spaghetti and meatball. It came with a small salad that she liked. The spaghetti was very salty and couldn t eat it.
I got a small pizza that was called all the above. It was definitely a good pizza!! My only complaint that I have is I wish it was a large one. This was one of the best I ve had.
We will come back, but for the pizza only. I will give a big -0-star because of the spaghetti. Five plus stars for the pizza!!!!

Best Dublin homemade pizza with incredibly fresh ingredients ... for the past 50 years

Great food, quick service and well priced fir what you get

This place is guaranteed good food and service. Pizza is fantastic.

My boyfriend decided to try this due to common man's ratings on 97.1 The Fan. I highly recommend their pizza. It might be the best pizza I have ever had. By far the best in Columbus!

A great authentic Italian pizza place. They have pizza sizes ranging from personal to extra large as well as salads, subs, and pasta. A friendly family owned business that had been in the area for many years.

Pizza perfection! Pepperoni mushroom pizza with perfect crust. Yummy deep fried mushrooms. Impeccable friendly and efficient staff!

A real mom and pop Italian pizza shop. A well kept secret.

Best pizza anywhere! Get capicola and garlic. Best crust anywhere too. Yum yum.

Pizza was terrible. Crust was hard and had no flavor.

Great pizza and a good beer selection. One of the few places can get Strohs. Have been going here for over 200 years. The salad dressing is addictive.

Terrific food. Great prices. Wonderful family provide terrific service!

Pizza is great. Restroom is disgusting!! They need to upgrade a little bit.

I've been a loyal customer for 25 years. Best pizza in town and an always friendly staff. You can have the restaurant chains! Family owned is the best of the best.

Always great, old school pizza.....our favorite pizza in the Columbus area!

My wife and I had pizza today. It's been 25 years since we here last and it still the best pizza in Ohio