Cafe Fiori Review

went for holiday lunch with the co workers, one of our co workers who is notoriously cheap suggested this restaurant. I made a reservation for 10 people on 12/13/17; when we arrived, Cesar (host? owner? head waiter?) insisted the reservation was for 13 people. I didn't see why it mattered until we were seated...we were the only people there, until a group of senior citizens came in. I guess Cesar was hoping to get a real paying crowd and 10 people instead of 13 ruined his mental profit margin.

this is in a strip mall by county college of Morris and it is obvious that the college crowd doesn't come here.

this place is byob but oddly has a display case of empty wine bottles. apparently they collect them from guests just to display? not a smart move--it just gives the impression that alcohol is available when it isnt.

the decor is totally dated. dark walls, dimly lit, and ugly paintings of food adorn the walls.

I have to say the best part of the lunch was the warm, crispy and plentiful Italian bread
with flavored olive oil. now I don't know how long those decanters of oil were out--they could be freshly filled or 2 years old--but went well with the bread. the fore mentioned cheap co worker ate half a basket of bread by himself and we still had plenty for everyone else.

all lunch orders come with a mixed green salad with mustard balsamic. yes, mustard. it was odd but good. could have used some tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, something more than mixed greens.

I ordered penne alle arrabbiata and it kind of smelled like it was cooked next to or sat alongside someone's fish long enough to absorb the odor. I don't eat meat or fish so I was a little put off. however it didn't taste fishy and the portion was generous.

honestly I wouldn't go back because Italian restaurants are a dime a dozen in NJ and there was nothing other than the bread to make this place stand out.

Always the best! Excellent service. Excellent food. Decent prices. And BYOB.

The wait for service was extraordinary... The food was not. Not bad, but just not extraordinary. Certainly not worth the wait for average food and service.

Food and atmosphere were just right. Wait staff was very attentive.

Terrific service, great food can't say enough wonderful things about it...don't miss eating here !

Absolutely delicious every time, every dish! My favorite Italian spot in the Morristown area!

Great Italian food, awesome service. The owner frequently walks around to every table making sure everything is going well.

Nice atmosphere and excellent food. Service is amazing!

Real good place. The place very busy. The service was great. The food was outstanding. We had zuppa di clams and escarole and bean soup to start. Very good. My pasta dish was old school cavatelli con broccoli. Real good. My wife had eggplant parm with vodka sauce. She liked it. And a double expresso to top off the night. No complaints. Will definitely go back.

Nice atmosphere, on the pricy side but excellent service and a wide array of Italian specialties!

close to home, but not worth it...there are too many good Italian places to bother with this one

Love the food. Especially the baby spinach salad with warm bacon and goat cheese. Never had a bad meal. Service is super nice. I have recommended this restaurant to numerous people and they all have said they loved it.

Quiet ambience, Superior Service delicious food.... quite a value for the money. A BYOB restaurant be sure to make reservations before stopping by.

Great byob Italian restaurant, food always excellent

Quality food and service. Be sure to dress nice and byob. I recommend making reservations.

We love byob's..food and service was good. Will return to dine again.

I AM A VERY DISCRIMINATING CUSTOMER. I GOT THE TABLE I WANTED (WENT EARLY), THE SERVICE WAS GREAT (DID NOT RUSH MY MEAL), AND THE SELECTION INCLUDED UNUSAL DISHES SUCH AS TRIPE (WHICH WAS SUPERB). I CAN NOT WAIT TO GO BACK. YOU CAN ALSO BRING YOUROWN WINE WHICH CAN SAVE YOU $50 OR ALOT MORE ON YOUR BILL..

JOHN PECORARO

One of the best Italian restaurants around they have been open for a little while post covid 19 and they have a few outside seats we have been getting takeout through the pandemic and I want to tell you the owner is very gracious and a very nice guy he has great food and I would definitely give it a try we have eaten there several times with our family and every time we go it s always a great experience hopefully he opens up again soon

Very nice BYOB, solid food and service. I had cream corn crab chowder which was very good.

This is an excellent restaurant. The food is always good, the owner is very nice and everyone who works there is friendly.

This was my first time here and my dish was delicious. I chose a meal off the three course menu. The mussels appetizer were outstanding! I met with a few of my friends and the waiters were very attentive. I will definitely be going again.

Hidden gem. Food was excellent, portions were large and service was attentive. Will definitely be back.

Simply put, Cafe Fiori is our favorite restaurant in Randolph.

Their Prix Fixe menu is a great deal. Tasty entries, fresh and perfectly cooked vegetable sides and a chocolate souffle that melts in your mouth.

Food is good but not a steak place. My steak was rare and veiny

Food is good and substantial. Staff is fast and efficient. Price Fix menu is great.

Excellent mussels fra diablo. Angus tripe soup a delight. Attentive but unobtrusive wait staff. Owner friendly.

What was once a northern Italian, slightly French influenced menu has now turned to Guinea slop. You want meat? You want red sauce on it? How about some mashed potatoes and vegetables? You got it. You want cream sauces, escargot, and delicate dishes that pair beautifully with a crisp white wine? Go elsewhere. This place has lost its authenticity and creativity. Disappointed to say the least.

Great food and service. BYOB so very affordable. Love the fact that you can get half portion on pasta dishes.

Nice portions. Kinda hidden in the strip mall nothing really makes it stand out but not a bad place for a small event

Delicious food, generous portions, attentive staff! BYOB.

My friends and I went early on a Wednesday. The place got busy pretty quick after arriving but service was excellent. I mention this because it's safer to make a reservation. We went with the pre fixed menu. My friend ordered the mussels and goat cheese ravioli both were delicious. I went with the Angus Tripe which was out of this world! The Veal Parmigiana was definitely one of the best I've had in the area and the portions did not disappoint. I ended with the chocolate souffle which was the perfect sweetness. The ambience was family friendly and the service was outstanding. We never felt rushed or forgotten.

I celebrated my nomination today in this great place. Well we had a brilliant evening and the venue was unquestionably one of the reasons for that outstanding gathering. The stuff collaborated in a sweet way, the cooking was extremely good and my friends were so joyful. We shall absolutely come back again for more events. thanks very much.

My absolute favorite! My husband and I have been dining here every week for the past several years. Love the food, the atmosphere, the owner Ceasar and the waiters!

Good Italian food small place service a little slow

Cafe Fiori seems to me to be a well-kept secret in Randolph, NJ. Offers delicious Italian cuisine and the portions are large and reasonably priced. Owner and servers were great. They were very attentive and made our evening a wonderful experience. I had the bronzini on the specials list and my wife ordered the Osso Bucco. Bronzini was so fresh and amazing. Osso Bucco was by far the best we have ever had. Everything was great! We'll definitely be back!

Love this place...cozy, great service and great food!

For this town where several Italian restaurants reside - this is by far the best. We have been going there almost since it opened. The owners are friendly and the service is very good. You are NEVER rushed out of the restaurant and they make you feel right at home there. It is a BYOB and the food is great. I often ask for something a little different than the menu reads, for instance, substitutes of pasta or veggies, or even sauce-- and they always accommodate me -- never even a question. The meal sizes are generous and you always walk away happy you went. Kudos to Cafe Fiori

First dinner out in almost 4 months and glad they were able to accommodate us. We sat outside at 1 of the 4 appropriately distanced tables. The staff is courteous, knowledgeable of the menu and appeared to take all necessary precautions to keep patrons safe. The food is fresh and delicious. Thank you for a great dinner!

Excellent Italian Cuisine Every Time. Total Italian Fare, that's So Delicious, it brings me back to Trips to Italy! Professional, Warm & Friendly Staff who always make you feel so Welcome! Plus... it's a BYO!

Been going to this restaurant for years. Spent an EXUBERANT amount of money here, not only dining in, but also for many parties & engagements. We were Always very generous in taking care of the staff with gratuity, even when it wasn t necessary, like for takeout.
We have a son with autism, which Cesar & staff were aware of, so unfortunately, we re on his schedule to be able to dine out in between the breakdowns he has. We had made a few reservations, but unfortunately unable to make it & had to cancel. We recently called to make a reservation & was told THEY NO LONGER HAD A TABLE FOR US. Hard to imagine a restaurant EVER saying that, especially, being in the restaurant business myself for over 20 years. This TRULY is pathetic. Karma will run it s course, as it always does.

Food was excellent and also the service. I will go back and see if they pull it off twice. If so, it may become a regular stop.

Great bread. Excellent food. Fair price. BYO.

Love this place, never disappoint. BYOB and fantastic food. Even better service, but call for reservations

Great Italian restaurant with friendly servers. Amazing food!

The food is excellent the service is great i had the veal and it just melted in your mouth.

Wonderful restaurant, great food and great service. In addition the place is immaculate. It was worth the very long drive.

Excellent Italian restaurant - small and intimate - rather busy - reservations recommended. The osso buco is fabulous as was the chicken florentine. Service is very good. Good parking

Always very good. The pork chops are fabulous. Everything is great.

Okay. Locals love it. I think it's average. BYOB which is positive.

A+ pleasant setting, plenty of parking, not rushed, like I was back in Firenza.

Very tasty food that's slightly more expensive than I would have expected for a BYOB

I absolutely enjoy their food and customer service, great location close to my house. The employees are always welcoming. Will come back again.

fantastic food and service! Cafe Fiori is a gastronomic gem in Morris county. Our always go to restaurant. So happy they are open again as we missed our favorite dining venue.
John and Jane D....

Excellent food from the evoo to the main entree, pork chops, everything was impeccable!

Excellent gem tucked away in an lovely mini outdoor mall. The food was excellent. I highly suggest the Ossobuco!

Delicious food, consistently. The prix fixed is a great value!

Absolutely a fantastic, top notch restaurant. Always a pleasant atmosphere and extremely polite and attentive staff. It has become a regular for me.

Tried charging us for 3 dinners, how do yo know it's a mistake or trying to pull a fast one on the elderly women I drive, luck I caught it. Foods good.

This restaurant offers many interesting dishes, all freshly prepared. The desserts were terrific too. A small place so there could be a wait. Would recommend it as have been there several times and the food is consistently good.