4 years ago
I know this place receives a lot of praise, but I ...
I know this place receives a lot of praise, but I unfortunately have to say that I was disappointed and am left to think that Bar Isabel may be overrated. The restaurant itself is dark and damp feeling. Maybe it s not so bad in the winter, maybe it s cozy even when it s cold outside, but in the summer it felt like we were in a wet, cold, humid basement. It also got incredibly loud throughout the evening - and maybe we re getting old, but I really could barely hear my husband across the table. The service was off - our waitress was incredibly soft spoken and made no effort to speak up, so after saying we couldn t hear her a few times we did the awkward nod along and smile just to not have her repeat it a third time. She also was not attentive - it took a long time to place drink orders and then food orders, she didn t check on us except when bringing us our orders, and just didn t seem to care l that much about what she was doing. We ordered the shishito peppers for example and another waiter brought them to us and said I know your server already told you this, but today our shishito peppers are all incredibly hot so approach with caution - nope, we weren t told that in advance and he wasn t lying when he said approach with caution. Then the rest of the food was mediocre, with the exception of the olive oil that came with the bread - that might have been the best olive oil I ve ever had, but everything else was fine but certainly not impressive. Presentation was beautiful but the food did not stand up. Overall, disappointed by what is such a raved about Toronto heavy-hitter; maybe we went on an off night but I won t be back.