For what it is (for the price and location) the ho...

For what it is (for the price and location) the hotel room itself is pretty basic when compared to the cost. 3.5 stars
The pool, beach, and local cliff jumping are all amazing. 5 stars
The lack of reasonably priced (for Maui) food and drink is highly disappointing. $8-$14 beers. Typically $18+ for food. Don't gouge your guests for something they can walk down the street and get for half that. 2.5 stars only because it's somewhat expected.

Maybe my wife and I were spoiled because we were coming from a private villa in Bali, but the service overall was average to sub par. Example: we called ahead to request a late checkout (for noon). We returned to our room at 11:25am and our key was shut off. Frustrating. 2.5 stars.