Mader's is a famous Milwaukee German restaurant. ...

Mader's is a famous Milwaukee German restaurant. Unfortunately, the food does not do its reputation justice. Although the appetizers which are standard simple foods were good, the main dishes were lacking flavor as well as presentation. The Crusted Almond Rainbow Trout was dry and flavorless and the pices of fish were carelessly thrown on top of a daunting pile of potatoes. The Schnitzel was equally equally flavorless and lacking a nice crust. The Shank of Lamb was tasty, yet overcooked, delivered on a daunting mount of Brussels Sprouts.
As to some of the items on the menu and their authenticity, I would question the presence of scallops over mac&cheese. German cuisine also does generally not mix seafood and meat.
Generally speaking, German food has a rustic home cooking side to it which is not devoid of some elegance. As for what it is, the food at Mader's would be just ok but for the prices which equal that of elegant beautifully presented French faire.
The venue is a piece of history of a Germany long bygone which has its charm and appeal. The service is very good.