It probably deserves five stars for NOT being the ...

It probably deserves five stars for NOT being the Four Seasons (which looks like an ant farm - too many people). Great staff, gorgeous location, perfect beach. The rooms were being redone when we were there, and the renovation is pretty luxe. Loved the way time slowed down while we were there. Insanely good food at Nick's Fishmarket, which is almost certainly the best restaurant on the island. There's also a great little convenience store and deli, for mid day snacks, tanning lotion, sodas, et al. Big balconies on some of the ocean facing rooms - worth it! The lobby is open aired, with the ocean as a backdrop, with a wonderful shaded bar that has great drinks and the perfect view. Our friends go back every year - we'll certainly be back soon.