The dough was absolutely delicious, thank you! I’m planning a short trip and want to make sure I do this right: would it work to freeze the ball inside a ziplock bag before shaping it? I’d keep it on ice during transit and then shape and bake it once I arrive.
What reviewers say about Make It Dough
What is Make It Dough?
Make It Dough is a food & beverages listed on Trustburn. Make It Dough is a website focused on sourdough baking. It provides sourdough baking recipes, starter and discard tutorials, and related baking content.
What is the official website of Make It Dough?
The official website of Make It Dough is makeitdough.com.
How is Make It Dough rated on Trustburn?
On Trustburn, Make It Dough has a rating of 4.8 out of 5 based on 65 reviews.
Is Make It Dough on social media?
Make It Dough has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram.
Post your question publicly — other visitors, and whoever manages this page, can answer. It will be visible on this page.
Want to hear about this company again? Follow it and we’ll email you when a new review appears.
Based on reviews, listing data and the company's website. Verify anything important with the company directly.
I just baked my first loaf from Make It Dough yesterday, and I couldn’t wait for it to cool down to slice into it. The result was fantastic—plain and simple, though a bit of Kerry Gold would have been a nice touch. Big thanks to the team for sharing such a detailed technique and recipe; this bread is not only tasty but also a joy to work with. I’m already planning to bake more loaves over the coming months to share with friends and family.
I am absolutely thrilled with this cookie recipe from Make It Dough! The cookies turned out perfectly baked, exactly as I hoped. I made a few small tweaks—substituting avocado oil for vegetable oil, reducing the white sugar slightly, and using chopped dark chocolate with pecans. I’m planning to add unsweetened coconut flakes next time. Thanks for such a fantastic recipe!
The dough from Make It Dough is absolutely fantastic. I stumbled a bit with the measurements at first, but it became second nature quickly. Coming from Pennsylvania’s Amish region, I can confidently say these are authentic and delicious. I actually baked eight larger ones instead of ten to make them extra hearty. The aroma alone confirmed they were going to be perfect. The real challenge now is resisting the urge to devour the entire batch!
I tried Make It Dough and was blown away. Since I was out of parchment paper, I just used foil and baked them at 425° for 8 minutes. The result? Super soft, chewy cookies that are packed with probiotics. It was a fantastic, gut-friendly treat that the kids absolutely loved!
I made these at Make It Dough and they turned out absolutely delightful. I tried a mix of cinnamon nutmeg sugar coating on half and left the other half plain. The instructions were spot on, though I needed a bit more time for the dough to rise because of the temperature here. Super quick, easy, and tasty.
Make It Dough recipes are a game-changer. They taste great, are super simple to follow, and the final product looks just like something you’d buy from a professional bakery. As someone who usually throws away their sourdough discard, I really appreciate having so many useful options. I’m already wondering which recipe to tackle next—I’ll definitely be making more of them!
Make It Dough delivered an absolutely delicious treat that surpassed anything you’d find in the grocery store. I split the batch between salt and cinnamon sugar, and the whole family kept coming back for seconds. The instructions are clear and straightforward, making it a breeze to follow even if you’re not a seasoned baker.
Make It Dough made my first attempt at baking pretzels a breeze. It’s such a straightforward recipe that I know I’ll be returning to it again and again. 🥨
I pulled this recipe from Make It Dough specifically to use up my excess sourdough discard, and the result was outstanding. The aroma and taste were truly incredible. While the visual presentation wasn't quite as polished as the photos on makeitdough.com—mine came out flatter with a denser crumb—the flavor more than made up for it.
Using the stand mixer for this recipe at Make It Dough was a breeze. It made the whole process much simpler than kneading by hand.
Great quality! Quick question: can I swap milk for water in the recipe?
Make It Dough’s pretzel bites are hands-down the best I’ve ever turned out. After testing numerous recipes, I can confidently say this is by far the simplest and most reliable method for making pretzels. If you’re looking for a foolproof treat, I highly recommend giving these a try!
Make It Dough’s focaccia recipe is a genuine winner—flavorful yet incredibly straightforward. I made a happy accident by using Tuscan herb-infused olive oil, which elevated the dish to a whole new level of tastiness. My family loved it so much that I’ve already shared the recipe with them.
The baking instructions worked out flawlessly for me. After setting the timer for 25 minutes, the results were exactly what I hoped for. Great quality!
I’ve tweaked the Make It Dough recipe to create the most incredible rolls, perfect for pulled pork sandwiches or simply enjoyed for breakfast with butter and jam. Instead of whole wheat flour, I use quick oats, and I shape the dough into a rectangle cut into eight pieces. After letting them rise for about half an hour, I bake them at 450F for 15 minutes. I’m making them multiple times a week now! Thanks for such a fantastic recipe.
Great recipe! I noticed the option to freeze it—could you clarify at which step I should freeze it and how to finish baking it later?
Hannah, your baking skills are truly impressive. The sourdough discard brownie recipe you shared is a standout—easy to follow and absolutely delicious. It has been a wonderful comfort during my pregnancy. Thanks for sharing your talent with us!
I’ve cooked this up a few times at home, and it’s a total hit. As someone who’s been trying to bake sourdough on and off for ages, my starter usually struggles to rise properly, and I was tired of tossing out all that leftover discard. Deciding to give this recipe a shot to use it up was a game-changer. The loaf looked professional, almost bakery-quality, and rose beautifully—so pretty I almost didn’t want to eat it! The taste was excellent, too. It’s turned out perfect every single time I’ve made it. I stick to the instructions, just starting with a KitchenAid mixer on the dough hook. Thanks to Make It Dough for this gem; I can’t wait to test out more of your sourdough discard recipes.
I baked those brownies once more, substituting half the fat with blood orange oil and keeping the other half as vegetable oil since I was out of the orange stuff. The result was absolutely delicious. Next up on my list is giving the butterscotch chips a try. Thanks for the inspiration, Hannah!
I’m really enjoying the taste of these brownies from Make It Dough. I’ve baked them twice now, but I keep running into the same issue: the edges rise higher than the center. I’m aiming for a flatter top to make them easier to serve to guests. Does anyone have tips for fixing this?
I’m having trouble tracking down the pan dimensions for the Pullman loaf in your recipes. The link seems to be broken, which is frustrating since knowing the exact pan size is crucial for getting the bake right.
Make It Dough delivered exactly what I needed for those extra sourdough discard leftovers. The cookies turned out incredible—my son actually claimed they were the best he’s ever tasted, and our friends practically cleaned the plate! Even without any add-ins, the base flavor was pure perfection.
Make It Dough really nailed the texture with these rolls—perfectly light, flavorful, and chewy. The portion size is quite generous when you split the dough into eight pieces, so I might stick to smaller sizes next time to get the right bite.
The hot dog buns I baked with Make It Dough were absolutely delicious. It got me thinking—can I adapt that same recipe for hamburger buns? I noticed you already have a version made with an active starter, but I’m really hoping to find a way to use up a bit more of my sourdough discard.
Make It Dough delivers exactly what you hope for: a satisfying crunch on the outside with a tender, soft center. The flavor is spot on.
Make It Dough’s brownie recipe is truly outstanding. It’s now my go-to choice for hosting guests, using up starter discard, or just satisfying a sweet craving. The feedback is always positive, and I’ve baked it so many times that I’m starting to get creative. Currently, I’m swapping in a mix of white and semi-sweet chocolate chips. I’m considering replacing some of the oil with a flavored oil, like blood orange, to add a unique twist, but I want to make sure it won't ruin the established perfect texture.
I absolutely adore Make It Dough! It’s such a thoughtful touch to see the ingredients listed both on the recipe card and within the step-by-step instructions—it’s a small detail that makes a huge difference in the kitchen. One feature I’d love to see added is a “cooking mode” button to prevent the screen from sleeping while you’re baking. Keep up the great work!
I tried the treats from Make It Dough, and they were incredibly rich and flavorful—definitely exceeded my expectations. I did notice some minor inconsistencies with the texture and baking timing, but the overall taste is just fantastic.
I was really looking forward to trying these from Make It Dough, but while the flavor was there, the texture just wasn't right for me. Even though I weighed every ingredient on my scale, the dough struggled to hold together. I followed the advice to use a parchment sling to lift them out, but that actually made them crumble more. I tried adjusting the bake time, cranking the heat to 335 and then up to 350 after half an hour, but even after nearly 40 minutes, they still looked underdone. I was worried they’d burn if I left them in any longer. The crust had a nice bit of crunch, though nothing over the top. I did swap in bits of semi-sweet chocolate bar instead of chips, so maybe that played a role, but I suspect my oven temp was the real culprit. They also felt a bit dense and oily. Regardless of the baking hiccups, I think my daughter will still love them!
The Make It Dough biscotti kit was good, but the recipe card felt a bit misleading. The photos clearly show chocolate dough, yet there is no mention of adding cocoa powder anywhere on the packaging or instructions. I only realized this after finishing the final mix, leaving me with plain vanilla biscotti instead. It’s still tasty, but I was disappointed I couldn’t spot the missing ingredient sooner.
I was thrilled with the result from Make It Dough! Although it required a bit of patience, the dough turned out incredibly soft, airy, and full of flavor. It’s a great solution for using up sourdough discard. Highly recommend!
Make It Dough has truly perfected their recipe. I’ve started sharing it with friends as a gift and the feedback has been fantastic. Highly recommend!
Thanks for sorting out the olive oil details! I’m loving how versatile Make It Dough is—it’s become my go-to base for everything from pizzas and sandwiches to sweet treats.
The results from Make It Dough were fantastic! I loved them so much that I decided to repurpose the scraps, toss them with cinnamon sugar, and bake them up for a little extra treat.
I rely on Make It Dough to minimize waste from my sourdough starter. The dough holds up beautifully in the freezer; I portion it out using an ice cream scoop and store the discs in a ziplock bag. They bake up perfectly straight from frozen.
Make It Dough delivered some fantastic cookies! I accidentally used large flake oats since that’s all I had on hand, but the result was still delicious. They have the perfect chewy texture with crispy edges. My husband and I are already going back for more.
This is my fourth time making these in just two months, and my husband is absolutely obsessed with them! I’ve stuck to the recipe every single time, and it has never let me down.
I recently discovered Make It Dough and this recipe truly exceeded my expectations. I had some leftover Guinness bottles and was searching for a creative way to use them up. This loaf turned out to be slightly sweeter than the traditional Irish Brown Bread I’m used to, but I really enjoyed that rich flavor profile. I’m already planning to bake it again soon. Kudos to the team for sharing such a great recipe!
Is it a good idea to freeze the tart crust prior to baking when using products from Make It Dough?
Make It Dough delivered a solid product that proved resilient through my kitchen experiments. I tweaked the dough using baked potatoes and adjusted the consistency with potato flakes and extra water, yet it still came out soft and tasty. I am confident I will order again, this time sticking strictly to the instructions for a perfect result.
I’m really impressed by how flexible the Make It Dough recipe is regarding both ingredients and timing. I baked it this morning and the aroma filling my kitchen was absolutely incredible. It was my first time baking sourdough with add-ins, and I was pleasantly surprised by how straightforward the process was. The result was a delicious loaf that would definitely win over a crowd. Kudos to the team at Make It Dough for sharing such a reliable recipe!
The cookies from Make It Dough are absolutely delicious! I made a few tweaks to the recipe: swapped vegetable oil for coconut oil, used only 100g of dark brown sugar, and substituted white sugar with honey. I also added raisins and walnuts instead of chocolate chips. These turned out to be the best oatmeal cookies I’ve ever had. Big thanks to the team!
The dough from Make It Dough was quite parched, requiring an extra quarter cup of olive oil just to bind the ingredients. Even after the first bake, the texture remained crumbly and dry, though it finally held its shape. The final biscuits turned out tasty, despite being on the drier side and yielding fewer whole pieces than expected.
Make It Dough’s buns have quickly become a staple in my kitchen. The recipe is simply the best I’ve tried, and I use them as my go-to choice now.
Make It Dough really nailed the flavor profile with this one. I added walnuts and they were a great touch.
I baked the oatmeal cookies from Make It Dough today and they are absolutely incredible. The brown butter cinnamon topping is to die for—my whole family, including my husband and kids, devoured them. I took the liberty of adding some walnuts, cranberries, and dark chocolate chunks to the mix. Definitely making these again!
I recently baked the Discard Banana Nut Bread from Make It Dough for the second time, and the results were fantastic. My wife, who is based in Costa Rica, has a sensitive digestive system, so I’m on a mission to help her transition to healthier whole wheat options without sacrificing taste. Since sourdough isn't always an option for her right now, I decided to modify the recipe this time by swapping 60 grams of the all-purpose flour for whole wheat. The outcome was incredibly moist and delicious. For baking, I skipped the parchment paper, opting instead to grease the loaf pan and use a silicone mat on a flat baking sheet.
Hello again! I’ve used this recipe twice now—once for a loaf and another time for burger buns—and both turned out great. Quick question: how should I tweak the main dough ingredients if I want to leave out the egg?
I’m baking the sourdough zucchini bread from Make It Dough and was wondering how much lemon zest or juice would complement the loaf? Thanks for the recipe inspiration!
I’m not usually one to write reviews, but I had to share how much my family loved these. I swapped whole milk for evaporated since that’s what I had on hand, and opted for pretzel bites instead of the classic shape, baking them for just about six minutes. They turned out great!
This looks incredible, and the sweet stiff starter concept is a game-changer! I’m planning to use this for burger buns—do you recommend keeping the exact same recipe and just cutting the bake time?
I can honestly say these cookies turned out even better than the standard boxed mix instructions suggest. I skipped the brown butter step and just added a bit of vanilla to the dough from Make It Dough. The result was fantastic. My husband devoured three of them before I could even store them, and he took the rest to share at his office. I was a little nervous about how stiff the dough seemed initially, but I shouldn’t have worried. They baked up with minimal spread, offering a crispy edge and a soft, chewy center. Totally worth the effort—definitely give them a try!
I ran into a similar problem with Make It Dough where the dough felt dry and crumbly. I think the issue was relying on US Customary measurements, which can be tricky with starter variations. Switching to weight measurements is much more reliable. I just added a bit of milk while kneading to achieve that classic bread dough consistency, and the results were fantastic.
The family really enjoyed the baking experience with Make It Dough. Their kits are straightforward and deliver professional-looking results every time.
I haven’t had a chance to try the bread from Make It Dough just yet, but the aroma filling my kitchen is absolutely incredible. I was genuinely surprised by the incredible oven spring—the loaf burst open to form a beautiful, rustic ear. It’s a shame I didn’t think to snap a photo before digging in, but the result looks fantastic.
Make It Dough really nailed it with this one. The loaf has such a tender, soft texture that everyone absolutely adored. Highly recommended!
Hey Hannah! I’m really looking forward to trying this recipe and just popped my loaf into the oven at Make It Dough. Quick question: should I take the lid off after 30 minutes? As someone who is fairly new to sourdough, I’ve noticed most instructions suggest removing the cover once the initial baking phase is done. Thanks!
Just tried the biscotti mix from Make It Dough and I’m blown away. I opted for organic dried cranberries without added sugar, which gave a lovely tartness that pairs perfectly with the dough base and white chocolate. Since I was out of orange extract, I cranked up the orange zest by about three extra teaspoons, and it worked wonderfully. Has anyone here attempted this recipe using coconut sugar and gluten-free flour instead?
I am still convinced that I created the best pretzel bites I’ve ever had, even though my technique was a bit off. My dough ended up really tough and completely flat, looking nothing like the beautiful photos from Make It Dough during the baking process. It was so stubborn that I had to just roll it into small bites, but the taste was absolutely worth it. I’d love to know what went wrong with the texture and volume so I can get it right next time!
Make It Dough never disappoints. I found the dough super easy to work with and the results were spot on. Highly recommended!
The sourdough cornmeal muffins from Make It Dough were a hit with everyone. Thanks for sharing such a wonderful recipe!
Make It Dough nailed it with their soft pretzel recipe. I was initially hesitant about the zero salt in the dry mix, but the flavor is spot on once you add your own seasoning and those toppings. I grabbed the Everything But the Bagel blend and it’s a game-changer. The pretzels turned out gorgeous, both in texture and taste. Definitely worth trying out from makeitdough.com
The pretzels from Make It Dough in Portland are incredibly soft and delicious, truly some of the best I have ever tasted. I really appreciate that you shared your recipe with the community.
I followed the instructions on Make It Dough’s recipe exactly, but the result was a crumbly, dry dough. I suspected it might be a normal stage in the process, so I spent quite a while kneading it, but it still refused to come together into a ball. It really seems like the ratio of milk to flour needs tweaking.
Questions & Answers
No questions yet — be the first to ask.
Sign in to post
Your text is saved — you'll come right back to post.
Don't have an account? Create one
News & Press
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
Photos
No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.
About Make It Dough
Make It Dough is a website focused on sourdough baking. It provides sourdough baking recipes, starter and discard tutorials, and related baking content. The site's tagline indicates it offers "Sourdough Baking Recipes, Starter & Discard Tutorials, and More!" The site is operated under the name Make It Dough and serves as a resource for home bakers interested in sourdough techniques.
- Website
- makeitdough.com
- Categories
- Food & beverages, Publishing
