The Red Store

4.6 · 155 reviews
capemaypointredstore.com Write a review
D
Domenic Filingeri
Reviews 1
2020-12-18 05:24

The only thing that was okay was the empanadas. We...

The only thing that was okay was the empanadas. We really did not like the other food choices. I feel like the last time we were there about a year ago in September 2016 had more offering in form of how flavorful and put together than whole menu was. Now the menu is disconnected and the flavors did ...

Read full review

N
Noreen Caldas
Reviews 1
2020-12-09 07:22

8 course prefix change and food was really disappo...

8 course prefix change and food was really disappointing. Waited 45 min before anything came to the table. All the courses were off. They tried to bring dessert before the entrees. We loved this place for years. I hope they can bring it back to what it used to be.

Read full review

V
Vivian Sterste
Reviews 1
2020-12-07 00:47

A blend of general store ambiance coupled with an ...

A blend of general store ambiance coupled with an evening long presentation of many courses of varied delicious foods makes for a celebratory experience at the Red Store. From the charcuterie board, replete with home made butter, delicious cheeses, meats, fig spread and gluten free rolls to the fabu...

Read full review

S
Sara Irick
Reviews 1
2020-12-05 23:16

There was a moment during our dinner here last nig...

There was a moment during our dinner here last night that we thought we had been teleported to a cozy restaurant in Napa or Vetri's kitchen in Philadelphia. The dishes that came out of the kitchen were creative and delicious. Everything was made with attention to detail and you could tell they were ...

Read full review

J
Joanne Manidis
Reviews 1
2020-12-02 17:34

Had an amazing dinner there July 1, 2018. The bes...

Had an amazing dinner there July 1, 2018. The best part is that they give you four choices of a main course but the rest is served one by one- by the time you get to your main course you are totally full and totally satisfied! The food is amazing and the service is exceptional. It is fine dining ...

Read full review

T
Tim Breen
Reviews 1
2020-11-27 23:42

Found this place two years ago and now make it par...

Found this place two years ago and now make it part of the annual visit. Of the beaten path which just serves to make it nicer. Relaxed and pleasant environment. Would be 5 stars except our server seemed annoyed to be working and unattentive. That is not the norm.

Read full review

M
Michael Magro Jr
Reviews 1
2020-11-19 09:47

Been meaning to try this place for years, and fina...

Been meaning to try this place for years, and finally made our way to the Point to have brunch. The food was quite delicious: each one of us thoroughly enjoyed our meal. I would recommend the egg and bacon steak! And I highly recommend the house-made gelato as it was the best gelato I've had in a ve...

Read full review

K
klosschr
Reviews 1
2020-11-09 23:21

After thinking every place has snarky young staff,...

After thinking every place has snarky young staff, this place proved me wrong. Twice they served meat to a Pesca, but they instantly corrected it and had two waitresses tell us it would not happen again. Amazing food, amazing atmosphere, the staff knows every detail of the dishes. Only complaint cou...

Read full review

B
Brian Carroll
Reviews 1
2020-10-25 05:19

We had huevos rancheros, pancakes, a sandwich and ...

We had huevos rancheros, pancakes, a sandwich and various blended vegetable drinks. The huevos rancheros compared favorably to some of the best that I had in Mexico. The blended vegetable drinks were also very well done. Parking is a bit strange, and it can get crowded here. There seems to be a ...

Read full review

P
Paul Manidis
Reviews 1
2020-10-17 05:11

Tonight was our fourth trip to this one of a kind ...

Tonight was our fourth trip to this one of a kind restaurant. I went in thinking that it couldn t have been any better than our previous visits and guess what? It was the best meal we have had there yet. My hats off to the chef.
For those folks who are nervous about going to a restaurant that you c...

Read full review

D
Daniel Acosta
Reviews 1
2020-10-09 22:42

Visited here on a Monday afternoon to see why it's...

Visited here on a Monday afternoon to see why it's got the best burger in Cape May county. Wow, I totally understand now. The toppings-to-patty ratio is perfect. Can't go wrong with the sharp cheddar cheese. The beef patty was the perfect portion size; didn't have that "oh I need to slow down" feeli...

Read full review

A
Avram Granett
Reviews 1
2020-09-12 05:47

Wow! So delicious! Freshly made pastries and bre...

Wow! So delicious! Freshly made pastries and breads. Local farm veggies. Airy screened-in patio. Friendly and attentive service. We had the Avacado BLT on a croissant with some of the best home potatoes ever. Wife had the crab pancake which she loved. We'll be back!

Read full review

E
Ed Johnson
Reviews 1
2020-09-09 06:09

Cozy - but not too cozy - general store with a soc...

Cozy - but not too cozy - general store with a socially distant eating area. Tasty empanadas and baked goods and an eclectic selection of beverages. A few quirky knickknacks for sale along with a few beachy items. A nice respite from a day of birding, especially nice in the off-season.

Read full review

D
Dan W Kirby
Reviews 1
2020-08-08 15:44

We decided to try the Red Store for their brunch. ...

We decided to try the Red Store for their brunch. Very interesting selects on their menu. Food was terrific, and with good portions. Pricing might be a little high, but that seems to be the norm along the shore. Staff was friendly too. Has a nice local feel to it. We will definitely be back.

Read full review

M
Matthew Ercolino
Reviews 1
2020-07-24 18:31

A true standout! Fantastic!

A true standout! Fantastic!

This place is in the "hidden" Cape May Point section of Cape May and as such, is a little out of the way, kind of destination place.

This has a nice little "General Store" area out front and seating outside and in the back of the store.

The fresh juice blends are...

Read full review

D
Dolly Buchanan
Reviews 1
2020-07-19 15:24

A cute little gift shop and general store in this ...

A cute little gift shop and general store in this out of the way location. The big draw is the foodie level restaurant, expensive with high cuisine menu. In the gift shop, they offer some custom spices created by the chef team of the restaurant.

Read full review

M
Mary Ellen Murray
Reviews 1
2020-07-05 21:16

The menu states they will gladly accommodate veget...

The menu states they will gladly accommodate vegetarians, vegans or gluten free. I asked for the shrimp & crab salad. Asked to take off the shrimp and crab and if any other veggies where available to put on, please do so. Waiter said sorry NO. I asked not even cucumbers? Waiter said NO. They char...

Read full review

R
Rebecca Rentoul
Reviews 1
2020-06-13 17:19

From the moment you arrive, the beautiful gardens ...

From the moment you arrive, the beautiful gardens in which the Red Store - the original general store for 75 years and the only commercial property on the point- raises the bar. The grounds are beautiful, lush, full of flowers, and the Store itself maintains the historic character. Now to the food, ...

Read full review

A
Allie Ruiz
Reviews 1
2020-06-13 00:36

Found this place this year and are super stoked ab...

Found this place this year and are super stoked about it. They serve empanadas (amazing), pastries, and some breakfast toasts to-go (COVID) and you can eat on their back patio.

I would highly recommend checking this place out and I can t wait to eat a full meal here soon

Read full review

W
Will Morales
Reviews 1
2020-06-12 16:54

If you are ever in Cape May and are looking for a ...

If you are ever in Cape May and are looking for a great brunch, lunch, etc.. stop by, you will not be disappointed. The menu is very practical but the items on it are full in flavor. I would highly recommended. My second time here and I'm already looking forward to the third time.

Read full review

T
Theo Smyk
Reviews 1
2020-05-28 06:41

Had an incredible experience at The Red Store for ...

Had an incredible experience at The Red Store for dinner. My girlfriend and I have spent time and dined in some of the "best" food scenes across the country. The Red Store truly blew us away. Every course, the ambiance and the staff - all perfect. We will be back and would HIGHLY recommended to ...

Read full review

K
Ken Brahl
Reviews 1
2020-05-23 18:57

Fantastic. Went there for an anniversary. 7 course...

Fantastic. Went there for an anniversary. 7 course dinner. Choice of 4 entrees but the rest of the meal is chefs choice. Incredible unique tastes. Favorite was the potato gnocchi with crab and roasted squash as one of the courses. Expensive but we'll worth it for a special occasion.

Read full review

B
brian deal
Reviews 1
2020-05-20 20:45

Outstanding 2016-2017 NY Eve dinner 1st seating. ...

Outstanding 2016-2017 NY Eve dinner 1st seating. Standouts were the smoked love beets and then the grits with thumbelina carrot, along with the main course. I had the local scallops which may have seemed small, but packed an amazing sweet ocean taste. Way better than those massive (probably synt...

Read full review

View all reviews on Trustburn
AMP version. View on Trustburn