Login or sign up
For business
Average ratingGreat
4.1/ 5

Based on 35 reviews

574%
43%
30%
20%
123%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Premier Coins

Based on 35 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 9 days ago

Customers generally speak very positively about Premier Coins, with 74% of the 35 reviews giving it 5 stars and describing the sales people as kind, knowledgeable, and helpful, praising the friendly staff such as John and Joe, and highlighting good prices and a secure, safety-focused environment, though a sizable share of 1-star reviews reflect serious dissatisfaction with pricing and sales practices.
What is the Trustburn rating and review history for Premier Coins?

Premier Coins holds a Trustburn rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars based on 35 reviews. The rating split includes a significant number of 5-star reviews praising knowledge and security, alongside several 1-star reviews from customers who felt they were overcharged or harassed by phone calls.

How do reviewers describe the pricing and deals offered by Premier Coins?

Many reviewers claim that Premier Coins offers better prices on silver and gold bullion than online competitors, with one customer stating they would beat any online price by a buck or two before shipping. However, some negative reviews allege the business sells overpriced coins and that customers may get ripped off on antique coins due to dishonest claims about cleaning.

What specific staff members are mentioned in the reviews?

Several reviewers specifically name employees, including John and Joe, who sit in the front showroom and are the subject of multiple complaints about being smarmy or dishonest. Other staff members mentioned include Shawn, Tyrone Roy, Siobhan, Rob the manager, and a young man named Ty who called a customer to sell coins.

What is the physical location and area served by Premier Coins?

Premier Coins is located on Long Island, NY, and serves customers along the east coast. The business has a physical showroom where customers can visit in person, and the website premiercoingalleries.com is used for their online presence.

What security features does Premier Coins offer for customers?

The business provides a secure environment where customers are buzzed in and locked in until they are buzzed out. This feature is highlighted by multiple reviewers as a top priority for safety, especially when dealing with large amounts of cash or gold.

What types of coins and products does Premier Coins handle?

The business handles silver, gold, and precious metal bullion, as well as antique coins such as 1911 $5.00 Indian head half eagles and state park quarters. They also accept gold jewelry for sale and assist customers with coin books and collecting.

What specific customer service experiences are praised in the reviews?

Reviewers frequently praise the knowledge and helpfulness of the sales staff, with some describing the experience as pleasurable or amazing. Specific interactions with employees like Tyrone Roy and Siobhan are highlighted for their unrushed approach and ability to address customer concerns about prices and needs.

What are the main themes of the negative reviews?

Negative reviews focus on dishonest practices regarding coin cleaning, where only a few coins were actually cleaned out of a large batch. Other complaints involve aggressive phone call tactics and feeling ripped off on the value of antique coins purchased.

What is the process for getting started or visiting Premier Coins?

Customers can visit the physical showroom on Long Island, NY, where they are buzzed in and locked in for security. For those who prefer not to visit, the business can be contacted via the phone number 1-800-820-5006 or through their website premiercoingalleries.com.

What is the reputation of Premier Coins among first-time customers?

First-time customers are advised to be aware that the business may use aggressive phone call tactics, as some users reported feeling harassed. However, those who speak with knowledgeable staff like Tyrone Roy or Siobhan often report a very positive and pleasurable experience.

What are the contact methods available for Premier Coins?

The business can be reached via the phone number 1-800-820-5006 or by visiting their website at premiercoingalleries.com. They also maintain a LinkedIn profile for professional connections.

What is the official website of Premier Coins?

The official website of Premier Coins is premiercoingalleries.com.

Is Premier Coins on social media?

Premier Coins has official profiles on Linkedin.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

William Willis
Reviews 1

I have looked far and wide for the best deals on silver. You will not find a better price on bullion anywhere. Check around online, find the best price per ounce, then call these guys. I promise you they'll beat the price you find online by a buck or two, and that's before shipping! I would give them a six star review if I could.

Cheryl Ann
Reviews 1

Smarmy salesmen that sell over priced coins and prey on you like jackals on a carcass. Do not do business with them. I am sorry that I did! I told Shawn not to ever call again and he said "yeah, yeah." As soon as the government shutdown is over, I am reporting them to the FTC for harassing sales phone calls. This has been on-going for 3-years!

James Capodiferro
Reviews 1

I have bought precious metal bull in on line, and at stores up and down the east coast. They charged .70 over spot when silver was on its way down and 16.10 at that point. I don't know what they charge now, but I haven't seen anywhere close to that little above spot. I bought a lot and look forward to visiting again when I'm back on Long Island

Gene Mohr
Reviews 1

Everything sounded great when I bought $40000 of coins 7 years ago, but as I am starting to sell I am finding out I got screwed.
Gold is down 25% from when I bought it. But a
1911 $5.00 indian head half eagle choice bu I paid $995.00 today is worth $300.00.
Buyer beware. All of the coins I bought from them are worth 1/3 of what I paid for them.

Papabear Sciuti
Reviews 1

My grandson started a state park quarter book.
We stopped in and they help him with no problem. They had all the park coins that are out.
Thank you for helping my 8 year old grandson.
You made him so happy he cant wait to go back for more park coins..

Tara Baldwin
Reviews 1

This place offers a safe environment for anyone carrying gold, coins and anything valuable. Your buzzed in and locked in until they buzz you out. I like this feature especially when dealing with large amounts of cash or gold. This place offers good prices best I've seen. Very

Robin Messina
Reviews 1

Have been wanting to invest in coins for some time now but wasn t crazy about buying them on line. When I went there, Siobhan greeted me and we talked extensively about my concerns and needs and prices. Rob, the manager spent some unrushed time with me as well. They put together an amazing package for me and i was confident I got a good deal. I also brought some gold jewelry and coins I wanted to sell.... again, I know I was treated fairly. Highly recommend this place... ask for Siobhan... sweet lady!

Cache s
Reviews 1

I ve been coin collecting for years , it s a family thing. I don t normally do these reviews but a young man named Ty. Called my phone offering to sell coins to me, not only was his energy friendly and polite but he was very admit about what he was selling. So I gave it a shot , what s there to lose ? Overall great experience would definitely recommend, my friends and family to give it a shot and speak with Ty.

kelly larson
Reviews 1

HORRIBLE COIN DEALER! THERE ARE TWO FAT GUYS NAMED JOHN AND JOE THAT SIT IN THE FRONT SHOWROOM! THIS GUY JOE IS NOT A HAPPY INDIVIDUAL IN LIFE IN MY OPINION! RIPPED US OFF FOR A BUNCH OF ANTIQUE COINS BY TELLING US HALF OF THE COINS WERE CLEANED,LATER FOUND OUT THAT MAYBE JUST 2 OT OF LIKE 34 COINS ,EXPENSIVE ONE,S TO WERE INFACT THE ONLY ONES CLEANED!VERY DISHONEST CALL CONSUMER AFFAIRS MANY COMPLAINTS ABOUT THESE LOWLIFES!

kenny delski
Reviews 1

ABSOLUTE CROOKS HERE!!!!!! JOHN AND JOE THE 2 GUYS THAT WORK IN THE SHOWROOM OF THIS PLACE WELL LETS SAY THEY DONT MAKE YOU FELL WELCOME AT ALL. I DONT KNOW IF ITS BECAUSE I WAS SELLING LOADS OF SILVER AND GOLD TO THEM I FELT AS IF THEY WERE JEALOUS IT WAS ALMOST COMICAL BUT WHAT WASN, T COMICAL IS THAT THEY RIPPED US OFF ON LIKE 4 MORGAN DOLLARS THEY PURCHASED FROM US AFTER LIEING ABOUT GREYSHEET NUMBERS, WE TRUSTED THEM ONLY TO HAVE NOT RETURN NOT ONE CALL BACK TO US REGAURDING THIS SERIOUS MATTER! CONSUMER AFFAIRS WILL BE THE NEXT STOP!

Dale Velte
Reviews 1

Premier Coin Galleries solicited a purchase from my father who has Alzheimer's and Charged $2,000 to his credit card for 50 Morgan Silver Dollars. When I realized that this order was placed I promptly repackaged the coins (2 1/2 sleeves of coins in the same packaging) and shipped them UPS to them. His card was credited $800 and when I called I was told that I only returned 20 coins. This is absolutely OUTRAGEOUS!!!! The entire order was returned to them. The package weight was 4 lbs. which would reflect the weight of 50 not 20 silver dollars. I expect a FULL and complete refund.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Premier Coins