Peter Shields

4.8 · 286 reviews
Write a review
M
Mark Schroeder
Reviews 1
2020-11-25 00:25

My wife and I found PSI while on our Honeymoon two...

My wife and I found PSI while on our Honeymoon two years ago. We have been back every time we go to Cape May since because the experience, the food and the atmosphere are top notch. We just celebrated our 2nd anniversary there on Sunday night, and were particularly impressed with the scallops and th...

Read full review

E
Erin Regan
Reviews 1
2020-11-23 17:03

We ate at Peter Shields Inn Restaurant on the last...

We ate at Peter Shields Inn Restaurant on the last night of our mini-honeymoon and it blew us away! The food was absolutely incredible (seared Hudson Valley foie gras, steak tartare, lobster pasta, wagyu steak - the list goes on!) and our server Chris was so knowledgeable and welcoming. Easily compa...

Read full review

L
Louis Private
Reviews 1
2020-11-22 18:02

I'm a tough rater for restaurants but this Peter S...

I'm a tough rater for restaurants but this Peter Shields is one of the finest dining experiences I've had in quite some time.
NY strip was the best I've ever had. Better than Lugers, Homestead, Wolfgangs. I'm not kidding. The aging process, Pittsburg Medium perfect! Service & Ambiance superior! BYO...

Read full review

T
Todd Ford
Reviews 1
2020-11-15 09:30

Food is very consistently very good, with a high l...

Food is very consistently very good, with a high level of execution and a medium to low level of creativity.

Service can range from good to poor with some servers acting rude, nonchalant, and lacking details. For example, poorly pouring wine so that the table cloth was half pink by the end of ser...

Read full review

T
Tim Breen
Reviews 1
2020-11-12 07:58

Absolutely great meal in a great setting. Server w...

Absolutely great meal in a great setting. Server was the best, very professional. Hostess was pleasant and gave us details about the Inn even though we were among the last to leave after a long day. All four meals were prepared perfectly and each dessert was unique.

Read full review

M
Mike T
Reviews 1
2020-11-04 23:51

We dined here on 6/26/19. Service was excellent. T...

We dined here on 6/26/19. Service was excellent. The food was good but not on the level I would have expected with their reputation. We ordered the tuna tartare first course which was good, the diced mango complimented the tuna well but took over the dish a bit too much. We also ordered the potato g...

Read full review

M
Michael Strickland
Reviews 1
2020-10-26 06:08

Great food and atmosphere. The food is delicious h...

Great food and atmosphere. The food is delicious here. My wife and I have been here before, and we decided to come back for our 3rd anniversary dinner. We both had the duck, and absolutely loved it. Our server was great as well. We'll be back during our next visit to Cape May.

Read full review

E
edmund zelhof
Reviews 1
2020-10-10 22:15

Made reservation a week earlier and could only get...

Made reservation a week earlier and could only get a 5.30 pm reservation. Kept calling for a later time and was told they were completely booked until 9pm.

When I arrived the porch was only 25% occupied with many empty tables the same when I left.
Complained to management.

Read full review

T
Timothy Joyce
Reviews 1
2020-09-26 07:14

A really phenomenal beach front restaurant in Cape...

A really phenomenal beach front restaurant in Cape May! I have been coming here for years and years and have always had a wonderful experience. The food is absolutely top notch. The service is friendly and exceptional! You should try the Peter Shields in at least once during your Cape May stay.

Read full review

S
Sarah J. Daudelin
Reviews 1
2020-09-21 01:58

A friend recommended this place so we decided to c...

A friend recommended this place so we decided to come here during our short trip to Cape May. We were advised to make reservations so we did, though with it being a weeknight it wasn't necessary. The service was excellent, and our toddler liked the staff, too. Environment is classy, relaxed, and wi...

Read full review

K
Kathleen Fitzmaurice
Reviews 1
2020-09-17 11:35

Look no further!!! We have been staying at the Pet...

Look no further!!! We have been staying at the Peter Shields Inn the first week of August for the past five or six years and keep coming back year after year, now stretching our stay to 11 days. Danielle and staff, Sherry and Taylor are fabulous, their welcoming, warmth and service exceptional, alwa...

Read full review

T
Thomas Clark
Reviews 1
2020-09-14 08:18

Inn is lovely and food is very good. Views of the ...

Inn is lovely and food is very good. Views of the water are great. We had to enter through the basement as there was a wedding reception going on
That was fine but no one was there so we walked upstairs. We were not treated very nice since we were upstairs.
Overall a wonderful place to stay.

Read full review

P
Peter Volk
Reviews 1
2020-09-08 06:29

Pricey but delicious food. We all had seafood and ...

Pricey but delicious food. We all had seafood and it was fresh and well prepared. Service was OK, but not at the level I would expect for the reputation and price of the restaurant. Seating was uncomfortable on cushioned chairs into which we sank until we we're supported by the hard frames. We cut o...

Read full review

L
Larry Mlawski
Reviews 1
2020-09-02 02:56

A wonderful spot for an incredible meal. We were ...

A wonderful spot for an incredible meal. We were looking for a nice romantic spot in Cape May by the water. It hit the spot with incredible food and service. The Halibut was amazing. Our waiter Dylan was on point. Not inexpensive, but worth every cent.

Read full review

M
Marilyn Fischer
Reviews 1
2020-08-27 18:30

A Lovely place to have dinner. Located on Beach Av...

A Lovely place to have dinner. Located on Beach Ave. with a great outdoor porch facing the beach. Food is excellent, service very good, and wonderful atmosphere inside and out. It is a BYOB. It is a little pricey. The average plate about $30-$38, appetizers, about $12-$18. Wonderful for a special o...

Read full review

P
Paul St James
Reviews 1
2020-08-23 02:04

One of my top three favorite restaurants in South ...

One of my top three favorite restaurants in South Jersey. Although it is a BYOB, they do share a liquor license with Cape May Winery, so you can buy their local wines by the bottle, nice touch. Date pudding is a must try for desert.

Read full review

E
everything AG
Reviews 1
2020-08-16 11:14

BAD!!! We arrived at 2PM in hopes of takinga qui...

BAD!!! We arrived at 2PM in hopes of takinga quiet nap in Cape May before attending wedding down the road. Turns out the whole first floor is host to a wedding here. I mean the check in desk is literally the DJ booth. I put my bags down next to wedding parties table by the front door. Wedding ...

Read full review

K
Kate Geiger
Reviews 1
2020-08-15 09:50

Our anniversary meal was spot on for service, good...

Our anniversary meal was spot on for service, good, and ambiance. This was a relaxed, memorable meal! Salad charcuterie, 2 fish entrees (salmon and rainbow trout - both excellent!), and creme brulee created one of my favorite meals ever for a reasonable price. We will be back.

Read full review

G
Greg Whipple
Reviews 1
2020-08-11 01:19

Spent our 1 year anniversary at Peter Shields and ...

Spent our 1 year anniversary at Peter Shields and it was absolutely amazing! The steak was easily Top 3 all-time, my wife had the scallops and says they were the best she's ever had. Service was what you would expect for Michelin rated restaurant. BYOB should be allowed at all restaurants. It may se...

Read full review

F
Francis DellaVecchia
Reviews 1
2020-08-05 08:26

We went there for a afternoon wedding. Beautiful p...

We went there for a afternoon wedding. Beautiful place, very elegant and food was delicious. What more could one ask? Eventhough it was rainy outside, you wouldn't have known it. One of the best small, quaint weddings we've been to recently.

Read full review

G
Ginger Mashas
Reviews 1
2020-08-01 18:18

My husband and I had Thanksgiving dinner, a price ...

My husband and I had Thanksgiving dinner, a price fixed menu. The food was delicious and the server was courteous and friendly. After our meal and while ordering dessert, we also ordered cups of coffee. We were somewhat surprised when receiving our bill we were also charged for the coffee. The pric...

Read full review

View all reviews on Trustburn
AMP version. View on Trustburn