Amazing steak one of the best in Atlanta. Nice atmosphere very attentive service. Appetizers were ok very expensive and not shareable. We came with a big party and had our own private room. The vegetables were very large portions very bland and asparagus and Brussel sprouts very overcooked. We still had a very nice experience but for the price point all of the menu should be impeccable. Brad was our waiter and very knowledgeable on cocktails and steak choices.
Questions about McKendrick's
What is McKendrick's?
McKendrick's is a classic American steakhouse located at 4505 Ashford Dunwoody Rd in Atlanta, Georgia. Founded in 1995, it has been consistently rated as one of the finest steakhouses in the country. The restaurant specializes in USDA Prime beef and offers South African lobster tails and daily fresh seafood.
When are the operating hours?
The restaurant is open for lunch from 11:00 am to 2:30 pm and dinner from 5:00 pm to 9:00 pm on weekdays. On Fridays, dinner service extends until 10:00 pm, while Saturday dinner runs from 5:00 pm to 10:00 pm. Sunday hours are shorter, operating from 4:00 pm to 9:00 pm.
How can I contact the restaurant?
Customers can reach the restaurant by calling (770) 512-8888. The website also provides a contact form where guests can submit their name, phone number, and email to send a message directly to the team.
What awards has the restaurant received?
The establishment holds the 2023 Experts' Choice Award, recognizing its consistent excellence despite industry challenges. It also won the 2022 Best Of Perimeter award for Best Fine Dining and was a first runner-up for Best Date Night Hotspot that same year.
What are the signature dishes?
The menu features hand-cut USDA Prime beef, which supports the establishment's commitment to quality. Other notable items include South African lobster tails, crab cakes, and lobster mashed potatoes that are frequently mentioned in reviews.
What do reviewers praise most?
Many reviewers praise the superior customer service, knowledgeable servers like Brad and Bradley, and the memorable dining environment. Guests often highlight the live pianist and the overall traditional steakhouse atmosphere as key strengths.
What are common complaints?
Some guests note that appetizers and drinks can be very expensive and difficult to share among a large party. Vegetables are sometimes described as bland or overcooked, and the dining area can get very loud due to being completely open.
What is the current rating and review volume?
The Trustburn rating is 4.4 out of 5 based on 377 reviews. The feedback includes a mix of high praise for the steaks and service, alongside critiques regarding pricing and specific food preparation issues.
Who owns and operates the business?
The owners, Claudia and Doug McKendrick, have been staples of the Atlanta food scene for close to 40 years. They opened the restaurant in 1995, and their leadership has helped cement its reputation as a timeless and sophisticated establishment.
Who are the key team members?
The executive team includes General Manager Sean Medved, Private Events Manager Sherrie Camp, and Executive Chef Branden Holte. The operating partner is Anthony Casiello, who works alongside the expert staff to ensure a superior guest experience.
How is the team structured?
The restaurant has successfully assembled an expert staff that prioritizes the needs of patrons above all else. This collaborative approach ensures that servers provide detailed attention and personality to every guest.
What specific dining features are available?
The dining experience includes traditional steakhouse offerings such as bone-in ribeye, porterhouse, and filet mignon. Guests are encouraged to specify their preferred doneness, with some noting that avoiding char on certain items like asparagus is important for the best flavor.
Where is the restaurant located?
The restaurant is situated in the Perimeter area of Atlanta, specifically in Dunwoody. It serves as a premier destination for those seeking a classic American steakhouse experience with a focus on quality beef and seafood.
What do external news sources say?
News articles from AJC have covered the restaurant, including stories about new pastry chefs and a review by critic Henri Hollis. These sources describe the establishment as offering a classic experience while navigating changes in management.
What is the official website of McKendrick's?
The official website of McKendrick's is mckendricks.com.
AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.
Brian is a wonderful manager and the team enviroment and food is extraordinary
Appetizers and drinks were good. Entrees and sides left a lot to be desired. Our server got busy and it took about 25 minutes for him to just pick up the check.
Really nice restaurant but the food was ok. The food should be excellent due to the prices.
First-class service and traditional steakhouse offerings.
The best steak in the Atlanta area. Hasn't failed yet but my first server has set a bar that hasn't been meet since. She was great.
Anyone with a problem with McKendricks is probably a food snob with a palate that couldn't distinguish flan from Frosted Flakes. The South African Lobster Tail, Crab Cakes, Med-Rare Porterhouse, Garlic Mashed Potatos, Grilled Asparagus Spears are must haves, just be sure to specify no char
Amazing restaurant. I love steak and the NY Strip was by far one of the best I ve ever had. My date had bone in filet and it was to die for!! Service was excellent. Live pianist. Highly recommend.
Best steaks and lobsters I have ever had. I always love dining here. They also have the best appetizers, sides and drinks. Three words "lobster mashed potatoes". Always professional service.
The steak changed my life. By far the greatest steak I have ever eaten. Trust me, just go there and eat a steak. And the parmesan fries... If I walked outside and got hit by a bus right after, I'd have died happy.
The restaurant is awesome! They abide by COVID-19 protocol, the staff is very friendly and personable the food is great and very reasonably priced. The ambience is very nice as well.
Awesome stone crab claws, fresh oysters and filet! Jeff, our waiter was very helpful. Great service. My husband says it is THE best steak in Atlanta. I like seafood and I have always been very happy. Highly recommended this place.
Bone-In Ribeye, Porterhouse melts in your mouth. The Lobster Bisque is divine; the portion is a little small for me but the rest of the meal makes up for that. Great fine dining atmosphere and you cannot go wrong with any of the menu choices. One of my favorite places to get great food...a great steak.
Good food but definitely overpriced. Teeny tiny restroom. And there is an old smell. Not a bad one... but an old one.
Our server Bradley was amazing and of course the food was a hit as usual.
Of the various steak houses and white-tablecloth type restaurants in the Perimeter area, this one consistently has the best food and service. They do a great job here.
Service was great food was awesome the only complain was that I got up from my table to take on a call then a lady approached me then later on I came to find out it was mrs mckendricks with a bossy tone that I needed to hand up the phone that I wasn't allowed to use my phone on the restaurant I looked at her like what are you talking about then she says oh you are a customer I said yes ma'am then she said oh kept on walking then said to someone close by oh my
Just because I looked Hispanic doesn't mean I work there and she needs to change her attitude or the way she approaches people I understand she is the owner but she needs better customer service skills
Dining area is completely open so it gets very loud, to the point where you are shouting to talk to the person beside you
This food was spot on. Definitely worth the price. Salmon was cooked PERFECTLY. WOW! Didn't realize just how high class this place was. I was a little under dressed. Will be back with tie asking for more salmon.
... Food was decent but over priced. Atmosphere was too bright
it was fine but not outstanding. two stars instead of three bc of the obnoxious wait staff.
Good quality food, and the steaks were well-seasoned and cooked. However, I am appalled by the service and the prices, and left the restaurant feeling swindled. To explain, I took a group of customers to McKendrick's for dinner. The steaks on the menu range from $30 to $60 (without sides). I think this is reasonable for a business dinner. Yet our waiter told us they had a special on tomahawk steaks that night, and gave us a really pushy sales pitch on them. Before ordering, I even clarified with him, "I've seen tomahawks be huge, expensive cuts meant to be split by 2 people. Is that what these are?" And he responded "No, ours are smaller and meant for 1 person." So, everyone orders the special. When the bill comes, I was charged $118 per steak! That's DOUBLE the price of the most expensive steak on the menu! When something is that incommensurate with the rest of the menu, I think the waiter should give you a heads up. To make matters worse, when we were leaving the restaurant, the waiter told my customers the price of the steaks: "you should thank that guy, he just bought you all $118 steaks." They felt horrible for ordering such an expensive meal, and like me, expected the special to at least be in the same range as the rest of the menu. I found it to be unfair and thought our wait staff was truly unprofessional. We also saw a waiter chug wine out of a water glass at the waiter's station! (Which was near our table). I learned my lesson to always ask the exact price of the special, and I also learned my lesson to never return to McKendrick's.
Over priced for level of service. Spoke to the manager- didn't think his response was acceptable.
Received a call from the manager and she was very concerned . I believe our experience was a rare event.
When I arrived it was 830 and I believe the restaurant closed at 9. At first, I thought we were too late. But to my surprise we were able to get a table and the service was excellent. Even though we were the last party there, we weren't rushed and the food was excellent. I will definitely be back. I love the atmosphere!
A friend and I are on a quest to find the best steak in Atlanta. We were so pleased with the quality of food at McKendrick's. I would recommend this restaurant, and will visit again myself.
Mark was an amazing waiter and the entire team was very accommodating with a last minute large table! Food was excellent as well.
I cannot imagine a better filet than I had tonight.
Overpriced for the quality of food, ok service but it was busy. Also too dark, needs better lighting.
Great food. Great service. Highly recommend the Turtle Gelato pie.
I just had one of the best New York Strips and Key Lime Pies. Very professional service and the food is superior.
First time here and it was top notch. From NY where there are steak houses everywhere and this place is up there in flavor, quality, service!!
Solid steak house choice. Good, but not great. Emphasis on decor more than food.
Words can't even express the overall satisfaction i was with this place! I'll just say 5star everything. I'll most definitely be back.
We Had An Excellent Time And The Food Was Awesome And The Service Was Perfect!!
Not many places can top the excellent service at McKendrick's!! The food is always perfect.
Made a reservation for 830 and upon arrival given a wait time of 50 minutes. What's the point of reservations?????? Staff look confused and overwhelmed.
My steak was very salty it was overbearing and my girlfriends steak was undercooked she asked for medium well it came out medium rare. We came to celebrate my sisters birthday and I was not pleased and will not come back
Absolutely love this place. Service and food was amazing!
One of the best steaks I have EVER had.
Very elegant. The service was outstanding. It is on the pricey side (~$44-$68 just for a steak, ~$9 for a side, ~$12 for a salad), but WOW what a great steak. This is a casual business or better atmosphere...upscale.
I can just had the best brussel sprouts I have ever had my life... Everything I've had here has been outstanding... I highly recommend the Bone In Ribeye, Scallops, and Lobster Mashed Potatoes. The service is superb...our waitress stopped by our table to say hi and church on us even though we were not at her table. Love this place...
McKendrick's is by far the best steakhouse I've been to in Atlanta. The food is amazing and you get what you pay. The steaks were cooked perfectly and the sides were absolutely delicious. The service was also outstanding and friendly...a fun environment that's not stuffy! Definitely going back!
My husband and I visited this establishment for the first time tonight because we wanted to try a new steakhouse in the area. The manager was extremely nice when came in the door so we thought we were in for a great night ; however, that was ruined by our waiter amber. She walked passed us on 5 different occasions and did not acknowledge that we were even there. I had to get up to get the correct drink and even after that, she still continued to attend to all of the tables around us without saying a word to us. After continuing to be ignored we decided to leave. We will continue to go to Capital Grill from now on where they treat EVERYONE with equal respect.
The food was amazing and the service was wonderful!
Wow. Everything was top notch. Amazing old school service. Perfect food.
From the moment I picked up the phone to make a reservation to the end of dinner, everything was just perfect. It's not everyday you have an experience that meets all your expectations. From the host to the waiters, everyone was very friendly and attentive. As for the steaks, we got the NY Strip and Bone in Ribeye paired with red wine. Both were flavorful and had their own distinct taste which surprised me. My guest and I thoroughly enjoyed this exquisite dining experience. Thanks!
I had the bone in ribeye, the crab and lobster bisque, with the wild mushroom risotto.
The lobster and crab bisque was creamy, elegant, and perfectly seasoned tableside with black pepper by my extremely polite and knowledgeable waiter.
The risotto was one of the richest foods I've ever eaten in my life. I am surprised I didn't slip into a coma after 3 bites. Absolutely excellent but definitely something to share with a large group.
The ribeye was cooked perfectly and absolutely delicious. Everything was as expected and I was more than satisfied. Definitely recommend.
I take my customers here because it's the best steak house in Atlanta. Do yourself a favor and give it a try.
This has to be one of the top 10 steakhouses I have ever been too. The mac and cheese with lobster is amazing too.
I ordered the chefs cut bone in ribeye which is a prime cut. I ordered it med. because their standards call for a warm red center. It came well done destroyed. The offered to cook me another but my GFs steak was acceptable not perfect. So I settled because it s awkward for one person to eat while another waits. I did not want to make her feel bad. They offered desserts on the house which we ordered their version of apple pie to share. When they brought it to us they apologized for being out of vanilla ice cream which they replaced with a very minty chocolate chip that did not pair at all with the pie.
Great Steak everytime! I ordered the fillet and it was like cutting butter. I also want to try the bone in rib eye. The wait staff was very friendly. I mentioned the steaks but the sides are wonderful too. They come on a separate dish and are ideal to pass around and share because portions are so big. The mushrooms are cooked to perfection and large. I don't normally like corn but the corn dish was quite tasty. My fav side was the grilled asparagus. Can't go wrong there.
Had a good dinner meeting here. Accommodated my vegetarian needs.
The McKendrick's 12oz filet is the best steak I have found. I have eaten steak all over the world but in my opinion nothing compares. Best steak in Atlanta and I have yet to find a better one anywhere else.
Nobody likes to be taken advantage off. Their 8 oz petite filet is 48 bucks. A side at least 8 bucks. So the waiter offered their " Special". A 6 oz filet with a side. Sure, sounded great we thought....what you think, 39 bucks or 45? He never mentioned a price. My bad I should have asked...when the bill came he charged us $75.00 each! What a ripp off! And I was hungry after the small meal...add the fact their wine by the glass list was limited. I let the waiter choose my Cab. The 20 bucks glass was no good. U think he offered a new glass or anything? Nope...blamed me for wanting a Cab....One knows these places are expensive. I get that. But it's these reasons they go out of business....avoid when you can. Spend your 220 bucks for two somewhere else....
I like how the side are so big it feeds 3 or 4 people . The ribeye was very tender and the shrimp were jumbo
If you have resd one of my reviews before, you would know I am not a big fan of wet aged meat. I just think dry aged meat yeild better tasting steaks. However, this place porterhouse was very good and grilled to near perfection. And, they took care of us. S o, if you do not have that aged budget then this is the place for you.
Great food and service, but I'm not really interested in paying $50/+ for a steak (plus sides are sold a la carte.) I understand that you pay for the service and the experience, which is why if I spend $$$ (that doesn't even include the wine!) to treat someone I'd like more than steak and sides in a dimly lit restaurant. Plenty of other steakhouses that are more "enjoyable" (i.e., fogo de chao).
Side note: I will be honest and admit that I have had dreams about their lobster mac and cheese!
Absolutely one of the best porterhouse steaks that I have EVER had. Staff is friendly and attentive. Parking can be problematic, so get there early.
Pretty good steakhouse and a staple of Atlanta for many years. It is a bit pricey for the quality, but I definitely recommend it for the occasional treat.
The steak is cooked well and the sides are delicious. You will not regret going here.
We were treated great and seated at a nice booth for two. The servers and manager were very attentive. The food, drinks and dessert were all spectacular. Highly recommend!!!
Great food as always. Marcus took care of us like we are family. I look forward to my next visit.
I told my friends about this restaurant with my highest recommendations. I go their often. This recommendation is always successful. The dishes they serve are great and the team is very friendly and cooperative. always when we eat in this place we pass a splendid time. I warmly recommend this restaurant.
5 star steakhouse dining with all the trimming. Great atmosphere, attentive white tablecloth service and food that meets all expectations. Must be experienced to be appreciated.
This was highly recommended by local family and it didn't disappoint! We had the filet and it was melt it your mouth good. I would also agree with a previous comment that the servers are very helpful and polite. Will definitely go back again whenever we're back in the area!
First time for my husband's birthday and what a treat it was. The steaks were cooked perfectly, juicy and slightly crispy. The sides were flavorful and filling. We are adding this restaurant to our favorites list. The service is 5 start with as well. Genuine and considerate.
I dined yesterday with my party of three,my experience was not as good as used to be,the noise is about the same, but my wife steak was terrible, it did not look nor taste a file minion.
Cozy, Personal Attention, Clean, Professional Staff, and Excellent Food.
Good food and ambiance. Probably 5 stars but need room for the "top"
Great wait staff and meat was prepared perfect. Good time.
Great food love the service Mical was awesome very nice person
News
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
Photos
Widgets
Get the widget for your site →About McKendrick's
- Website
- mckendricks.com
- Address
- 4505 ashford dunwoody road northeast
- Categories
- Food & beverages