Login or sign up
For business

Hog Penny Pub

4.4· 157 reviews
Average ratingGreat
4.4/ 5

Based on 157 reviews

559%
428%
311%
21%
11%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Hog Penny Pub

Based on 157 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 5 days ago

Customers generally praise the friendly, attentive service, hearty food and generous portions, welcoming atmosphere, vintage decor, and chill vibe. Many also mention good beer and drink selection, while a few note that prices are a little pricey.
What is Hog Penny Pub?

Hog Penny Pub is a historic British-style pub located in Hamilton, Bermuda, operating since 1957. It is part of the Island Restaurant Group and is known for its vintage decor, including mirrors and benches dating back to the early 1900s. The establishment features a classic pub atmosphere with live music and friendly staff, making it a local favorite for both residents and visitors.

Where is Hog Penny Pub located and what is its building history?

The pub is situated at 5 Burnaby Hill, in a building that was formerly a bicycle shop and later a meat slaughterhouse before becoming the Hog Penny. Its ground floor history includes serving as a fishmonger's shop, while the upstairs area once housed offices and bed lets before evolving into the Guinea Discotheque in the early 1970s. This unique architectural history contributes to its enduring character as one of the oldest licensed premises in Hamilton.

How long has Hog Penny Pub been in business?

The establishment has been in continuous operation since 1957, making it one of the most enduring institutions in Bermuda. It is recognized as the oldest licensed premises in Hamilton and is noted for being the original inspiration for the Cheers Pub in Boston. The venue has maintained its status as a classic neighborhood brasserie for over six decades.

What do reviewers most frequently praise about Hog Penny Pub?

Reviewers frequently praise the pub's hearty pub grub, which includes dishes like fish and chips, poutine, and Shepard pie. Many guests highlight the excellent service, particularly noting the knowledgeable and friendly bartenders who share information about Bermuda. The vintage decor and chill vibe are also consistently mentioned as key attractions for diners.

What are the most common complaints or criticisms in the reviews?

Some reviewers mention that the food can be just 'ok' or 'mediocre' for certain dishes, such as chowder or Maui sandwiches, with one guest describing the food as 'at best mediocre'. Additionally, some find the atmosphere dark and cozy, which may not appeal to everyone seeking a brighter dining experience. A few patrons also noted that the food smells could be an issue for those with specific sensitivities.

What specific food and drink items are highlighted in the reviews?

The pub offers a variety of British-style dishes and drinks, including rum swizzles and a selection of beers. Some visitors specifically recommend the onion soup and calamari, while others enjoy the fish and chips. The menu reflects a classic British pub menu with a focus on hearty portions and traditional preparation methods.

Who is the ideal customer for Hog Penny Pub and what is the typical dining experience?

The establishment is described as a must-visit for those in Hamilton, offering a classic pub atmosphere with a mix of locals, guest workers, and tourists. It is often recommended for a quick bite or a more extended stay, especially when live entertainment is scheduled. The pub is noted for its ability to cater to diverse dietary needs, including vegan options.

How does the service at Hog Penny Pub compare to other local establishments?

The pub is known for its quick and attentive service, with staff described as fun and very helpful. Some guests have noted that the service is particularly good when the establishment is hosting Harbor nights or other special events. The bartenders are often praised for their cool demeanor and willingness to share local knowledge.

What does the location and layout of Hog Penny Pub imply for visitors?

The pub is located in a narrow alleyway off Front Street in Hamilton, giving it a sense of secrecy and a place that feels like it is known only to locals. This tucked-away location adds to its charm and makes it a hidden gem for those exploring the city. The intimate size and lighting contribute to its cozy and inviting atmosphere.

How does Hog Penny Pub compare to other restaurants in the Island Restaurant Group?

The pub is part of the Island Restaurant Group, which also owns other establishments such as Barracuda Grill, Bolero, and Brew. Barracuda Grill has been voted 'excellent' by 472 travelers and is perennially rated one of the best restaurants in Bermuda. The group's reputation for consistency and local accolades extends across its various venues.

What are the specific features and services offered at Hog Penny Pub?

The pub is a quick service hangout that offers grab-and-go bites as well as gourmet breakfast items and hearty lunches. It is also known for its nitro coffee and a selection of Dockyard Brewing Co. beers, ales, and Bermuda's only wine bar on tap. The counter service model allows for a fast and efficient dining experience.

What historical changes has Hog Penny Pub undergone?

The pub has a history of being a significant landmark in Hamilton, with its building having seen various uses over the years. It was converted from a bicycle shop and meat slaughterhouse into a restaurant, and later became the Guinea Discotheque. The establishment's evolution reflects the changing needs of the community while maintaining its core identity as a local favorite.

How does the British pub style of Hog Penny Pub appeal to visitors?

The pub is known for its British influence, which is pervasive in Bermuda. It is a great place for those looking for a traditional British pub experience on a tropical island. The establishment is often recommended for its classic pub atmosphere and the ability to provide a familiar and comforting dining environment.

What is the official website of Hog Penny Pub?

The official website of Hog Penny Pub is irg.bm.

How is Hog Penny Pub rated on Trustburn?

On Trustburn, Hog Penny Pub has a rating of 4.4 out of 5 based on 157 reviews.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Denis Desrosiers
Reviews 1

This is a must visit, if you are in Hamilton. The decor is vintage and the vibe is definitely chill. The beer selection is good and the prices are pretty much on par with the rest of Bermuda. Service was quick and attentive. The food is hearty pub grub with good size portions.

Dianne Farrington
Reviews 1

This is one of the older places on the island. The rum Swizzle was absolutely delicious and it was one of my first. The staff was helpful as I learned how to maneuver in my extended stay. It just happened to be Harbor nights when we were there so they recommended we stay and enjoy the continued entertainment.

Justin Raab
Reviews 1

Though a British Pub is not what you're probably looking for on a tropical island, the British influence in Bermuda is obviously pervasive and the Hog Penny is a great place. the waitstaff was fun and very helpful with the demands of my vegan girl friend and the food was above average.

Melanie Caracciolo
Reviews 1

Being a foodie and spoiled with excellent food at home I searched high and low for the best places in Bermuda. This place having some of the best ratings I gave it a shot and I was not disappointed. If you want delicious food cooked to perfection then look no further. Dined here twice in one day, brunch and dinner, and both times was extremely satisifed with the food AND service. Highly recommend

IrixGuy's Adventure Channel
Reviews 1

We rode our moped to Hamilton and asked a local (guy wearing Burmuda shorts, knee socks and dress shoes) where the best place to eat Bermudian Fish Chowder was. He recommended this place. We ordered onion rings (Bermuda's local export) and Bermudian Fish Chowder. Both were excellent and the service was super friendly and helpful. Our waiter explained that we should add sherry and rum to the fish chowder. We did and it made it even better! Like most places in Bermuda, the prices are higher than comparable places in the United States. The atmosphere is pub simple but the food and service were both amazing!

Alexandra Track Agramonte
Reviews 1

Absolutely delicious food! This was a great place to stop after a long day-- comfort food and friendly and attentive service. The fish chowder was incredible and my husband said the fish & chips were perfect. Our only small complaint: we found the cocktails to be a little pricey compared to other similar places in town.

Johnnie Bankston
Reviews 1

Great place to stop in for a drink or a bite to eat. Friendly patrons and staff. Drafts and bottles are available. Plenty of seating but bar seats are usually full. Not difficult to get a drink. Live music at night and lots of TVs for watching matches and sporting events. Half a block from Front street, walking distance from any place in Hamilton and just up the street from the flag pole.

Richard Norris
Reviews 1

Went due to being on Food Network.......There on a Sunday evening during Quiz night so ate at the bar and conversed with Dwight . Did not get Rachel Rays pick but after a Dark and Stormy drink, Beef Wellington along with great conversation and some laughing. I recommend it too !!!

Cathy Houde
Reviews 1

We went to dinner here with 2 other couples after reading great online reviews. Maybe it was an off night but our experience was just meh. Service was friendly but drinks and food were slow. To me this was average Irish pub fare. 3 of us had fish and chips which were tasty. My husband has a gluten allergy and there are no gluten free options so he went with lamb chops. They were more like loli-chops as they were tiny. Chicken pot pie looked amazing. Those that had shepherd's pie swore it was identical to what was served at Flannigan's, I can't confirm nor deny those rumors. Several tried the recommended toffee pudding, no one in the group liked it. Overall average experience and with so many other options in Hamilton we didn't return and most likely wouldn't elect to.

Darshana Shah
Reviews 1

The food was bar food. We order a few items that were different then bar food and they were not goos. We ordered the cheddar and apple salad and the chicken bhumi tikka. Both were average. We also did drinks which were bermuda coffee it was average and a flight of beer, which was great. We did order beer fries and those were amazing. We also tried escargot and it was great. So recommend sticking to bar food here. Customer service was poor. The gentlemen was the least friendliest waiter we have had un bermuda and not attentive at all. They were busy as it was trivia night on a sunday night around 7pm. The trivia was fun.

Lee Blackwood
Reviews 1

You can't come to Hamilton Bermuda and not stop in The Hog Penny for some local ambiance. Great Pub atmosphere, several beers on draft. They pour us pints not Imperial pints, FYI. Interesting Decor on the walls, and have a chat with your bartender... Lots of great recommendations and local info.

Came here over 30 years ago on honeymoon, the place has barely changed, except now they have WiFi LOL. Definitely can recommend the shepherd's pie and the excellent fish and chips. Good place to try the local seafood chowder, make sure to add some of the local Sherry pepper vinegar.

Susan G
Reviews 1

Came here on our cruise and stopped by for a drink. Great place for a drink - and the bartender was terrific! We didn't eat, but the food looked and smelled delicious. Street is fairly steep, if you have mobility challenges it can be tough, but it's not far up the road (about the shops in).

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Hog Penny Pub

Website
irg.bm
Categories
Restaurants