Cathy Houde

Review of Hog Penny Pub

We went to dinner here with 2 other couples after ...

We went to dinner here with 2 other couples after reading great online reviews. Maybe it was an off night but our experience was just meh. Service was friendly but drinks and food were slow. To me this was average Irish pub fare. 3 of us had fish and chips which were tasty. My husband has a gluten allergy and there are no gluten free options so he went with lamb chops. They were more like loli-chops as they were tiny. Chicken pot pie looked amazing. Those that had shepherd's pie swore it was identical to what was served at Flannigan's, I can't confirm nor deny those rumors. Several tried the recommended toffee pudding, no one in the group liked it. Overall average experience and with so many other options in Hamilton we didn't return and most likely wouldn't elect to.