Michele Lindstedt was our selling agent at Great Point Properties this time last year. We can not express how amazing she was to work with and how far she went to make sure all our hopes were realized! She was on point helping us to find the right price point that would ensure our home would sell quickly, but also meet our financial expectations. On top of that she went above and beyond with staging and coordinating to make sure the house showed with it's best face forward. We had multiple offers out of the gate and the sale was very fast and very smooth. If you are buying or selling on Nantucket, this agent has a great tone. She is honest, communicative and very pleasant to work with.
What reviewers say about Great Point Properties
What is Great Point Properties?
Great Point Properties is a Nantucket real estate firm founded in 2002 by Greg McKechnie and Bill Liddle, which merged with Sanford Real Estate in 2008 and purchased Sconset Real Estate in 2013. The company operates as one of the largest real estate firms on the island with 29 agents and 7 full-time administrators. They specialize in buying, selling, and renting properties across Nantucket neighborhoods from Town to Sconset.
How many transactions and sales volume did the business report for 2025?
The firm handles 47 transactions annually and generated $238 million in sales in 2025. They manage over 400 beautiful rentals and list new properties regularly. Their services cover both residential sales and vacation rentals for buyers, sellers, and renters.
Which agents are frequently praised by reviewers for their service?
Multiple reviewers highlight Tracy Cullinane, Alexa Coleman, and Liz Finley as standout agents who provide exceptional service. Clients praise their deep market knowledge, responsiveness, and ability to find perfect homes or rentals. The team is noted for going above and beyond to ensure client satisfaction throughout the process.
Where is the business located and how can clients contact them?
The business is located at 1 North Beach Street in Nantucket, MA 02554, and also has an office at 6 Main Street in Siasconset, MA 02564. They can be reached by phone at 15082282266 or 508-228-2266. Their website is greatpointproperties.com.
What core values and policies does the business claim to follow?
The website states they operate with a strict no-you-know-what policy and function as a seamless team with deep community roots. They emphasize accountability and personal service second to none, aiming to provide peace of mind alongside property solutions. Their approach focuses on navigating Nantucket real estate with confidence for all clients.
What themes do multiple reviews share regarding the client experience?
Reviewers consistently mention that the team is highly knowledgeable about Nantucket neighborhoods and market nuances. They appreciate the agents' patience, thoughtfulness, and long-term partnership approach. Many clients have worked with the firm for years, from renting to buying their first home.
What specific services and resources does the business offer to clients?
The firm offers services for both buying and selling homes, as well as vacation rentals. They provide tools like a Nantucket Rental Guide, Neighborhood Guide, and a Calendar of Events. Clients can also subscribe for new listing updates and access market insights and sold listings.
How long has the business existed and what major changes occurred in its history?
The business was founded in 2002 and has been operating for over two decades. It grew significantly after joining forces with Edward Sanford in 2008 and acquiring Sconset Real Estate in 2013. This history has allowed them to build a large team and extensive local knowledge.
What practical aspects of the booking or service process do clients appreciate?
Clients often mention that the agents are quick with responses and always available to discuss needs. They value the seamless process and the ability to find exactly what they are looking for. The team is described as hard-working, smart, and kind.
Which specific neighborhoods and areas does the business serve?
The firm serves the entire Nantucket island, including specific neighborhoods like Town, Sconset, Mid Island, West of Town, and Cliff. They cater to a wide range of clients from first-time buyers to long-term vacation renters. Their reach extends to helping clients find homes in various price points and locations.
How does the business differentiate itself from competitors?
The firm describes itself as one of the largest real estate firms on Nantucket with a proven track record spanning more than a decade and a half. They pride themselves on having an incredible depth of knowledge and a level of accountability that sets them apart. Their team believes they are only as good as their last transaction.
What should a first-time customer know before engaging with the business?
First-time clients should know that the firm offers a comprehensive guide to Nantucket, including a rental guide and neighborhood guide. They also provide a calendar of events and resources for getting around the island. Subscribing to their newsletter keeps clients updated on new listings and market insights.
What is the team structure and size of the business?
The business has a team of 29 agents and 7 full-time administrators working together. They operate as a seamless team with strong leadership and deep community roots. Their structure allows them to offer unparalleled knowledge and personalized service to every client.
What is the official website of Great Point Properties?
The official website of Great Point Properties is greatpointproperties.com.
How is Great Point Properties rated on Trustburn?
On Trustburn, Great Point Properties has a rating of 5 out of 5 based on 40 reviews.
AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.
Highly recommend Great Point Properties. We worked with Amber who went above and beyond to help us find a home. She even to helped settle us in after closing. Truly a gem.
I have scheduled vacation rentals on Nantucket through Laura Fletcher Belair for many years and through ownership of Great Point Properties prior to her joining the Brokerage. Being a Realtor myself, I understand the commitment required to serve clients and Laura continuously provides excellent service. She understands my goals each year and also keeps in touch with me throughout the year. Her dedication to her clients is unsurpassed and if I ever purchase on the island, Laura will undoubtedly be my Agent! Nantucket - My Happy Place!
Tracy sold my property for me on Seikinnow Place in January 2017. She was knowledgeable about how to get things done quickly and smoothly on the island (from surveying through getting a real estate lawyer to handle the closing). I would highly recommend her to anyone who wants to get an easy and fast sale or purchase done on Nantucket!
I just want to thank GPP and Alexa for helping my husband and I with the purchase of our island home. Alexa made the experience so enjoyable. We couldn't have asked for a better realtor! She even helped us find our caretaker! Thank you GPP and Alexa.
We started our relationship with Tracy a few years ago renting on Nantucket...we were not easy clients having three dogs, wanting central air and close to town but she made it happen. All along we said the end game was to buy a house but we had to sell our house in Connecticut first (to which she probably whispered to herself "Yeah, right. I have heard that pipe dream before"). But she never lost faith in us and we kept renting. And then we sold the house. Tracy connected with our requirements, stayed within our price range and we are closing on our Nantucket house after all. We appreciate what Tracy has done for us by reading us so well (and fully supporting us thru the purchase and closing process). Therefore, without question and without a second thought, the relationship will continue because we will engage her to rent our house .
Our experience with Great Point Properties has been outstanding. Alexa Coleman is a fantastic agent smart, hard-working, knowledgeable and kind.
Alexa Coleman with Great Point Properties has been so lovely to work with for almost 10 years! She has been incredibly helpful finding us the most amazing houses to rent on Nantucket every summer. She listens to exactly what we want/need and finds it for our family every time. She is quick with her responses and always available to discuss what we are looking for. We feel so lucky to get to work with her and look forward to doing so for many years to come!
Thank you to GPP for making our experience of buying a home so smooth. A special thank you to Sam Parsons who was fantastic to work with and had our interests at the forefront of the property search. Her knowledge and understanding of the island was amazing, and she guided us through the process of buying a home seamlessly. We couldn't be happier with the home we purchased.
We have rented through Great Point Properties for a number of years, and Tracy recently helped us make the transition from renters to owners. In fact, Tracy's market familiarity was a critical component in our successful purchase. We value her knowledge and insight, and working with her is easy as she's responsive and energetic. We're excited to work with Great Point as our exclusive rental agency.
Nothing but great things to say about GPP. Greg & Alexa both helped us find the perfect house in 2017 and GPPs follow up with great renters is very appreciated!
We've worked with Tracy Cullinane and Great Point Properties for several years, buying our first house on island, selling it several years later, and now returning for what we hope will be our long-term home on the island. Tracy and the Great Point team have always been patient, thoughtful and helpful, with unmatched market knowledge. They have been a true partner with concern and focus on our long-term happiness always at the forefront!
We worked with Liz Finley who was fantastic and just loved everyone in that office. Everyone was always willing to help and answer questions with a width and breadth of knowledge . Fantastic experience and highly recommend.
We have rented with Tracy the past two Summers and are excited to return to the same home for a third. She is very knowledgeable and easy to work with. The property is in an amazing location and very well maintained. Great Point makes the process seamless so we can have great vacation.
Liz Finley has been helping us visit Nantucket for many years. She is more than a realtor she is a friend. She has been there for us for many life changes and has always made our week there unforgettable
Rod and Shelli Jacques.
Great Point properties has rented out our home for us for over 15 years. In particular, Laura Fletcher Belair and Barbara Joyce have done a great job in finding tenants for our home, and we have never had any problems at all with any clients they have referred to us. When Great Point refers a tenant, you can feel confident that they have been properly vetted. They are very responsive to the needs of the tenants as well, and make sure they have a comfortable stay, keeping in touch throughout the rental period. I highly recommend Great Point for either buyers, sellers, tenants or landlords.
My husband and I were referred to GPP through a friend and they were FANTASTIC. They walked us through the buying process patiently and thoroughly and were incredibly friendly and hospitable. And they found us our dream home!! We could not be happier. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or rent on Nantucket. They know their stuff!!
Tracy is such a wealth of information and knowledge! Working with her year after year to find a summer rental is such a pleasure! We could not recommend Great Point Properties enough!
Tracy Cullinane is the best. My partner and I were fortunate enough to meet her as soon as we arrived on Nantucket 9 years ago. She patiently stayed in touch with us whenever a property that we might like came on the market. After 7 years, in a very competitive real estate market, we were finally ready to buy. And Tracy was right there with the perfect house for our needs and budget. We feel so fortunate that we met her and have her as a friend - not just our real estate agent.
I have referred several friends to Tracy Cullinane at Great Point Properties, and she has always handled them with the utmost professionalism and expertise. Her knowledge of the island and its nuances helped make the process of finding the right home for the right person a pleasure. I highly recommend Tracy to anyone looking for a home to rent or buy.
If you are looking to rent or own a home on Nantucket, Liz Finlay is the person to call. She is incredibly professional, responsive, and reliable and will work hard to find you exactly what you're looking for. My family recently purchased a home with Liz and we couldn't have been happier with the whole process. More than just being great at her job, Liz is a kind, friendly, and wonderful human being. I recommend her heartily to anyone!
Tracy has been an amazing resource for us on everything Nantucket. Her knowledge of the market and her responsiveness and professionalism are deeply appreciated. Thank you!
My family and I have been coming to Nantucket for the past 25 years. Through the years, Greg McKechnie and Sam Parsons, at Great Point Properties helped us find the perfect vacation rental.
In 2017, my wife and I went to see Greg to share with him our dream of one day (in 4+ years) owning a house on Nantucket. Greg s reaction--let s go out and look at houses. He spent several hours with us, knowing full well we were years away, if ever, from actually buying. And Greg doesn t just show houses, he knows the story behind each one. He is a walking Nantucket historian.
Last October we were back on Nantucket and my wife was anxious to go house hunting again. I was reluctant to ask Greg to take us out--we were still at least two years away from thinking about buying. But I did stop in to say hi to him and mentioned if he had any spare time
Greg immediately pulled out a file with his notes on all the houses we had seen two years ago and my wife s and my reaction to each one. Not only was Greg delighted to take us out again but he spent two days matching homes to what his notes told him we liked from two years prior.
The curated hunt was so well thought out that we found our perfect Nantucket home and, while a little ahead of schedule, bought it. Greg and his team--shout out to Jule Hall--were equally terrific in shepherding the deal through escrow and in answering every question and resolving every issue that we, as first time East Coast homeowners had.
It doesn't get any better than Greg and Great Point Properties.
I ve been renting in Nantucket for almost 20 summers and my experience with Great Point Properties has been excellent. Tracy goes above and beyond to make sure my stay at my rental is seamless.
I have been a client of Tracy Cullinane at Great Point for over 10 years. She has helped me and many friends create memorable vacations by putting us in the right houses. She also has kept me up-to-date and the places to eat and sights to see. I heartily recommend this broker to everyone.
I could not recommend Laura Fletcher Belair and Great Point Properties enough. My husband and I first met Laura when we were planning our wedding on Nantucket, and she has been an incredible resource for us in every aspect of real estate on Nantucket ever since. She is incredibly knowledgeable, thorough and professional as well as a great person. When searching for a home to host our wedding, Laura was so helpful and provided a sense of calm in a very stressful time time that is planning a wedding! Over the years, she has been so great in walking my husband and I through the ins and outs of Nantucket real estate and eventually helped us purchase the perfect home on the island earlier this year. She goes well above and beyond her job responsibilities and does anything that is needed to get the job done and make her clients happy and at ease. If you have any real estate needs on Nantucket, please contact Laura at Great Point Properties; you will not be disappointed!
Tracy Cullinane has been great to work with over multiple Summer stays. Always available and highly efficient.
Sam Parsons and Edward Sanford were an amazing team who managed the purchase of our dream home on Nantucket.
Sam is honest, experienced, direct and practical. She takes time to understand your likes and dislikes, your dreams and your parameters so that she can guide you toward the best options. She is deeply knowledgeable about both the rental market and the sales market, so she can help figure out the likely rental income from a property as well as the costs. She works incredibly hard at all hours to get the deal you want done. And once the deal is done, she is still working to help you find the resources and contacts you might need to keep the property in shape.
Edward has a lifetime of experience on Nantucket, giving him a deep understanding of its real estate, its personalities, and how they all fit together in the market for Nantucket real estate. The vast number of real estate transactions he has negotiated make him an incredibly valuable resource both in determining what properties to consider and in getting a deal done. Not only that, but he is just a great guy to know and talk with.
Great Point has done a great job handling my home from a rental perspective; knowledgeable staff (Tracy - and Sam - and several others) all with invaluable advice and access to a great client base. Plus, they know the island extremely well and have always advised me correctly on pricing and amenities so clients have a great stay and I stay fully booked. Couldn't ask for more from a great island realtor and staff.
We called Tracy Cullinane to list our home; a buyer was quickly found and the closing was in eleven days. So many details and so little time! With constant attention and contacts Tracy pulled it all together.
In the fifteen years we owned our home, and rented it, the entire Great Point team was outstanding! All the agents were delightful, helpful, fun to work with and I knew our home was in good hands.
Thank you for all the kindness and friendships throughout the years!
George and Mary Vournas
Five stars to Laura Fletcher Belair for helping us find the perfect summer rentals over the years! She has come to know our family and what we are looking for in a perfect Nantucket summer!
Tracy is a good listener in addressing our property search interest. She kept us informed and provided her insight, balanced with our goals. We highly recommend her.
Laura and the fantastic team at Great Point Properties have helped make our Nantucket experience absolutely wonderful for many years. We started by renting a beautiful home through them. A couple of years later, Laura helped us buy our own home on Nantucket. She couldn't be nicer and is always available to answer a question which comes in very handy since we don't live nearby. Totally recommend this great company!
Great Point, and their star agent, Michele Lindstedt did a wonderful job finding the perfect property for our family. Always patient and searching out exactly what we wanted, Michele is the best real estate agent we've ever worked with. Courteous, professional, diligent, highly recommend!
It does not get better than Laura Fletcher Belair and Great Point Properties for expertise in Nantucket real estate. We have Laura to thank for helping us purchase our dream home on Nantucket this summer. Laura is not only a highly skilled broker and an invaluable asset to have as your guide in any transaction, but she is also a truly wonderful human being. It s an unbeatable combination. It is so rare to experience personal service at the level that Laura delivers. Laura exceeded our expectations at every turn and everything that she does is impeccable. Laura goes above-and-beyond the normal course of business to help. She had nurtured and deepened our relationship over the years and had met our every need while guiding us through our search and eventual purchase. We had rented homes on Nantucket with Laura's help for many years before buying. We often referred Laura to our friends and each person was thrilled with their experience with Laura. We are so grateful to have had her expertise in pursuit of a 30-year-long dream come true. Words can t thank her enough, but we will try anyways: our deepest thanks and gratitude to Laura!
Liz Finlay has been an exceptional real estate broker for me since 2007.
Initially, she helped me with seasonal leases of my family's house. Then, she helped my family market and sell our house. For several years now she has been helping me lease someone else's home for my family's vacations. In each of these situations, and in every respect, Liz's care and service has been exemplary. She knows the market and takes every step to understand and satisfy her clients' needs. And, she is just a wonderful person.
I give Liz my highest recommendation without reservation.
Tracy patiently ushered us through many properties until we landed on 'the one.' We had summered on the island for several years and decided to put down roots. We were looking for something not too big, not too small, not too fussy, a small garden, in town, , and "reasonably priced." So many hoops to clear! After a year or two we found the perfect spot. The purchase was complicated by a fickle seller but Tracy steered us through like a pro. We now consider her a time-tested friend, and we cannot recommend her and the Great Point team enough!
Jim Garrels worked very hard for a long time to sell our property in Town. There had been litigation involving the property which made it difficult to sell until the case was resolved. Jim never gave up and continued his efforts until final closing. Thank you to Jim and Greg McKechnie for their help!
Tracy is one of the best agents my husband and I have ever used. She is professional and is always one step ahead of us. Nothing is ever too much for her to handle.
News
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
Photos
Widgets
Get the widget for your site →About Great Point Properties
Nantucket Real Estate and Nantucket rentals are Great Point Properties specialty. Find your dream Nantucket vacation house here.
Great Point Properties is a leading real estate company that specializes in Nantucket Real Estate and Nantucket rentals. The company has been in the business for many years, and it has built a reputation for providing high-quality services to its clients. Whether you are looking to buy or rent a property on Nantucket Island, Great Point Properties is the go-to company.
The company's mission is to provide exceptional customer service while helping clients find their dream homes on Nantucket Island. They have an experienced team of real estate agents who are knowledgeable about the local market and can help you navigate through the buying or renting process with ease.
One of the things that set Great Point Properties apart from other real estate companies is their commitment to excellence. They understand that buying or renting a property can be stressful, which is why they go above and beyond to ensure that their clients have a seamless experience. From start to finish, they will work with you every step of the way to make sure that your needs are met.
If you are looking for Nantucket rentals, Great Point Properties has an extensive selection of properties available for rent. Whether you are looking for a cozy cottage or a luxurious beachfront home, they have something for everyone. Their rental properties come fully furnished and equipped with all the amenities needed for an enjoyable stay on Nantucket Island.
For those interested in purchasing property on Nantucket Island, Great Point Properties has an impressive portfolio of homes available for sale. Their team of experienced agents will work closely with you to understand your needs and preferences so that they can help you find your dream home.
In addition to their exceptional customer service and extensive selection of properties, Great Point Properties also offers competitive pricing. They understand that buying or renting a property can be expensive, which is why they strive to offer affordable options without compromising quality.
Overall, if you're looking for top-notch real estate services on Nantucket Island look no further than Great Point Properties! With their commitment to excellence combined with years of experience in this industry makes them one-of-a-kind!
- Website
- greatpointproperties.com
- Phone
- 15082282266
- Address
- 1 north beach street
- Categories
- Real estate