Login or sign up
For business
Average ratingExcellent
4.5/ 5

Based on 492 reviews

571%
417%
34%
24%
14%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about La Tiendita

Based on 492 reviews on Trustburn · updated 100 days ago

Customers generally praise the fresh, authentic, delicious food, good selection, reasonable prices, pleasant service, and clean, casual setting, though some mention small portions, harsh lighting, bathroom lines, or order delays.
What does La Tiendita do?

La Tiendita is an authentic Mexican and Brazilian food spot in Tallahassee, with a small market attached.

What are the most common complaints about La Tiendita?

The critical reviewers most often described poor service, time-management or order problems, food-quality or preparation concerns, small portions, and an issue involving previously served food.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Traci Leibley
Reviews 1

Uh everything is made fresh and you can tell, why wouldn't you eat here!? Great food, authentic and delicious! The carne asada has great flavor and so does everything else! Highly recommend! Great service and great staff...go and see for yourself, you will be happy you Did!!

lisa h
Reviews 1

We ordered takeout. Arrived 5 minutes after pick up time. We noticed they missed one of the entrees by the total. Decided to wait for it. It was the first meal up. Had to wait an additional 30 minutes for the rest of the order that. Just an overall bad experience for us. Food was okay. Better the second day.

Alexander
Reviews 1

Nice little place one of the most authentic Mexican restaurants I've been to outside of California and Texas. The meat and rice was delicious as well as the fresh house guacamole. The flan was good, a little dense, but I think this is the restaurant's style. Overall a nice fine, will definitely come back again. So far best Mexican food I've had since moving to Tallahassee.

Luke Momjian
Reviews 1

Very authentic Mexican restaurant, food was good and prices were reasonable. The portions were a little smaller than we expected, so we got some more food. La Tiendita serves variety of Mexican dishes which were all pretty well executed. Our servers were pleasant and responsive. The restaurant interior could be improved on, the lighting in the evening is harsh and not romantic by any means. Decorations could be more tastefully done. Additionally, having only one bathroom meant that there was sometimes a line. As far as dishes, I would recommend the tacos, churros (best I've had), or Picanha (an excellent, large steak for only $16).

Clara J
Reviews 1

I'm only giving 2 stars to this review because the staff was pleasant. The food took well over an hour to reach our table. The party that I was with felt awkward about the situation as well but tried to make the best of it, hoping it would get better. I ordered the Carne Asada, which are strips of roasted steak, with rice and beans. Half of my plate consisted of tasteless refried beans, with the remaining being a few strips of unseasoned steak with only a few small pieces of sauteed onions, no rice. The only food slightly hot was the tortillas, which arrived several minutes later after I asked about them. By then, it was time to leave soon after. It was NOT a positive or impressive experience.

Daniel Hoge
Reviews 1

The food is incredibly good. It takes like what I imaginw other Mexican restaurants aspire to make. Parking in front of the restaurant is difficult to both find and leave. If recommend parking at the Barnacle Bill's next door. Unfortunately, the portions of the food, compared to the price, don't quite do it for me.

Claire Smith
Reviews 1

Finally got over to try this place and was not disappointed. Chicken fajitas were solid: seasoned well and hot! (Some places bring them and they aren't sizzling.) Rice was fine, beans were great! Wonderful flavor and consistency. Husband had chicken enchiladas and felt like the red sauce was more like a mole than what he's used to but he enjoyed them. The best part was the salsa though. Hands down, best. It was my fault for not double checking my total before I paid but after walking out, I felt like I overpaid somewhere. The downfall of not getting a paper bill, I guess. All in all, that is not enough of a detractor to keep me from returning. Excited to try the tacos next time!

Emiliano Mendoza - Sundar
Reviews 1

I'm surprised, I ordered Plato Don Luis, which is refried beans, thin sliced steak, rice, and Verde salsa I believe. It felt like i was 10 years old again. The smell and taste was exactly like my dad's cooking back in Oaxaca. I highly recommend it if you don't mind a little spiciness to your food.

Jessica Watson
Reviews 1

The one waitress was busy but sweet and the food was to die for! I'm a Tallahassee native and can't believe I've passed over this place so many times. Best (and only) authentic Mexican sit down restaurant in Tallahassee, good prices and the sweetest, most perfect avocado I've ever tasted. Get the Mexican guacamole!! I'll be back for sure.

*Edit
I've been back many, many times and will continue to. The food never fails to be delicious.

*2nd Edit
Has new owners: Brazilian and Mexican couple, and is now a fusion restaurant with 2 separate sides for seating. The scrumptiousness and authenticity have not changed.

Elle
Reviews 1

Popped into this restaurant while driving on Monroe. All of the staff were incredibly personable and showed me the different items they have in their own separate market after the coffee had caught my eye. As a small family of three, we ordered our food to go and even upon getting home, all of the food was still fresh and delicious.

Side note: after finishing our meal and trying to look up the hours online for a future visit, we realized we stepped into the store after they had closed! Talk about exceptional service! We were not rushed, turned away, or informed of the operation hours and we were handled every way a customer would like to be. We will definitely be coming back for more!

Grimibis
Reviews 1

I have been coming here over the course of 5 years. THIS PLACE NEVER DISAPPOINTS. La Tiendita should be the standard that many Mexican restaurants should follow as well as Tex Mex.

The food is authentic. Mexican food should be easy to prepare, bold in flavors, and visually stunning. La Tiendita has hit this mark EVERY single time. I ve ordered just about everything from Tacos de Lengua (Beef tongue tacos) to their Menudo (Cow stomach soup). The drinks such as their sangria and even their Horchata is phenomenal too. If you haven t been here or have chosen to ignore this restaurant, you are missing out. IN FACT, as in writing this review, I m about to head out and go eat here pretty soon.

La Tiendita is a place a magic. The service is great and the people here, including the owner, has made me smile every time.

There are many Mexican as well as Tex-mex restaurants in Tallahassee. If you think this place is not up to your standards, you re wrong and I m sorry for you having the wrong opinion. Good luck enjoying your choice of bland and generic food elsewhere.

I can go on and on about this place, but I think you get the point as to where I stand. Come here and eat, it s one of the best experiences you ll never forget.

- Dillard s Polikarpov

amber payne
Reviews 1

This is an honest review. No one was rude and my food was ready on time. This is simply based off the food.

"It's not bad." Nothing more, nothing less.

The carne asada was tough and bland , the rice and beans as well. The fried yuca was just ok. But my 2 year old dipped them in chick fil a sauce and ate almost half of them! Lol

My sons quesadilla, was also very tasteless . My husband ordered the taco barria and he enjoyed those.

If i could describe the food, it would be very mediocre. Nothing tasted marinated, or salted. The tres leches cake,however, was good.

I'd like to mention that the portions are very small. Quesadilla is half the size that you would get anywhere else, the gordita can fit in the palm of your hand....

I say, Try it for yourself. You might find something you like.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About La Tiendita

Welcome to Tallahassee's Authentic Mexican and Brazillian Food Spot! Each bite of our food will take you on an impromptu journey. Are you ready?

La Tiendita: Tallahassee's Authentic Mexican and Brazilian Food Spot

Are you looking for a place to satisfy your cravings for authentic Mexican and Brazilian food? Look no further than La Tiendita, located in the heart of Tallahassee. Our restaurant offers a unique dining experience that will take your taste buds on an impromptu journey.

At La Tiendita, we pride ourselves on using only the freshest ingredients to create our dishes. Our menu features a wide variety of options, from classic Mexican favorites like tacos and burritos to Brazilian specialties like feijoada and churrasco. We also offer vegetarian and gluten-free options so that everyone can enjoy our delicious food.

One of the things that sets us apart from other restaurants is our commitment to authenticity. We use traditional cooking methods and recipes passed down through generations to create dishes that are true to their origins. Whether you're in the mood for spicy salsa or sweet dulce de leche, you'll find it at La Tiendita.

In addition to our delicious food, we also offer a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Our restaurant is decorated with colorful murals depicting scenes from Mexico and Brazil, creating a vibrant ambiance that will transport you straight to Latin America. We also have outdoor seating available so that you can enjoy your meal al fresco.

At La Tiendita, we believe in providing excellent customer service as well as great food. Our staff is friendly and knowledgeable about our menu items, so if you have any questions or special requests they will be happy to assist you.

If you're looking for an authentic dining experience in Tallahassee, look no further than La Tiendita. Come visit us today and let us take your taste buds on a journey they won't forget!

Address
1840 N Monroe St
Categories
Restaurants