Login or sign up
For business

Gaslight Grill

4.5· 532 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.5/ 5

Based on 532 reviews

565%
419%
38%
23%
15%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Gaslight Grill

Based on 532 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 2 days ago

Customers generally describe Gaslight Grill very positively, with most highlighting the food, service, and atmosphere for occasions like anniversaries and birthdays, while a small number of reviewers felt the food or service did not live up to the price.
What is Gaslight Grill?

Gaslight Grill is a restaurant located in Overland Park, Kansas City, known for its live jazz music, prime rib, and prime scallops. The establishment offers a large wine list and a short list of affordable cocktails, providing a cozy atmosphere for dates, birthdays, and holiday parties. Reviewers frequently praise the food quality and the attentive service, while some note that the venue can be noisy near the dance floor.

What are the common complaints regarding the environment?

Some reviewers mention that the restaurant can be somewhat noisy, particularly near the dance floor where families might make it a playground. The bar area with jazz music is also described as being way too loud for conversation at times. Despite these noise factors, the atmosphere is generally considered cozy and cool, making it suitable for hot dates or family gatherings.

What should customers know about the pricing structure?

The establishment is described as upper mid-tier in terms of both quality and price, with some reviewers noting that everything felt 8-10% higher in cost than expected. While the food is considered delicious, the pricing is a factor that some guests take into account when deciding to visit. The restaurant accommodates various party sizes, though it is noted that prices and availability should be filtered with single-person parties in mind.

What beverage options are available beyond the main wine list?

The restaurant has a large wine list and an affordable short list that is also very good, offering options for those who prefer cocktails. Bartenders are frequently described as friendly and doing a great job, contributing to a well-trained crew experience. The short list is highlighted as being very good, providing a balanced option for diners looking for something lighter than a full meal.

What live entertainment features does the restaurant offer?

The venue hosts live jazz music, which is described as romantic and a major draw for jazz lovers. The music is a key feature of the atmosphere, with some reviewers specifically mentioning the 4 pc orchestra that performs during events like Valentine's Day. The live music is considered a top-notch element that enhances the dining experience significantly.

What specific service failures have been reported?

Some reviewers mention that the service can be poor at best, with instances of waiters taking over 20 minutes to return after dropping off checks. There are also reports of steaks being severely undercooked and bake potatoes being so burnt they were inedible. These specific service failures led to a 1-star rating from one customer who felt like an inconvenience.

How does the restaurant handle special occasions?

The restaurant accommodates special occasions such as anniversaries, birthdays, and holiday parties with extra attention. Owners and staff have been noted for stopping by tables to make the experience feel personal, and servers take pictures for couples celebrating milestones. The establishment goes out of its way to treat guests extra special when they mention significant events.

What types of events is the restaurant best suited for?

The venue is described as perfect for a hot date or a birthday dinner with family, offering a cozy and cool atmosphere. It is also suitable for large groups, as evidenced by the successful hosting of holiday parties and Christmas dinners. The environment is designed to feel personal and welcoming for both intimate gatherings and larger celebrations.

Where is the restaurant located and how accessible is it?

The restaurant is located in Overland Park, which is part of the Kansas City area, making it accessible for visitors traveling to the region. It is a must-see destination for anyone visiting Kansas City, according to one enthusiastic reviewer. The location supports its reputation as a top-notch restaurant in the area.

How does the size of the restaurant affect the experience?

The establishment is described as huge, which can contribute to the somewhat noisy environment mentioned in reviews. The size of the restaurant allows for a large wine list and a spacious dance floor, but it can also lead to seating near the dance floor where children play. The physical layout impacts the overall dining experience for some guests.

What is the overall reputation of the kitchen and service team?

The restaurant is described as top-notch with excellent food and attentive wait staff, according to one reviewer who had been there years ago. The establishment has a distinguished chef and a well-trained crew that provides a beautiful experience for guests. The quality of the service and food is consistently highlighted as a major strength.

How is Gaslight Grill rated on Trustburn?

On Trustburn, Gaslight Grill has a rating of 4.5 out of 5 based on 532 reviews.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Birdie Bolin
Reviews 1

Food is amazing. Took my Mother-in-law and she said they had the "Best scallops" she ever had. Side dishes are extraordinary and the desserts are the perfect ending to a perfect dinner. The atmosphere is cozy and cool. It's perfect for a hot date or for a birthday dinner with family. The owner stopped by our table which made it feel personal. This is a must-see for anyone visiting Kansas City. My family will keep coming back often. It's always a beautiful evening. I can't wait to try the brunch! (Hint: Be sure to make a reservation.)

Taylor L. Moore
Reviews 1

Fantastic service! We were treated extra special when we told them it was our anniversary. The server took great care of us, took pictures and had several insightful menu recommendations. The food was amazing- my husband had the prime rib which was cooked perfectly. The mixed berry sorbet is definitely a must have for dessert! We will be coming back.

Charles Johnson
Reviews 1

Not a good experience. The service was poor at best. We also had to send a steak back that was severly undercooked and one of the bake potatoes was so burnt it was inedible. Finally, we waited for over 20 minutes for our server to come back after he dropped the checks off. Just felt like we were an inconvenience instead of a customer.

Carla Harold
Reviews 1

My husband took me to the Gaslight Grill Sept 1st, to celebrate our anniversary and my birthday. Evidently I have the same birthday as their belated owner (Aug 31st). I had been there a few years ago at a pharmacist s dinner hosted by one of our drug companies. I had no idea how top notch the restaurant was! The food was excellent and the wait staff was very attentive. When I suggested it to my husband he was intrigued by the live music. (We are jazz lovers). It was such a nice experience! Romantic and fun. We can t wait to come back again.

Zachary Belcher
Reviews 1

I enjoy exploring around and finding new places to relax and enjoy some fantastic meals. The Gaslight fits that perfectly. My reviews are always centered around a one person party, so prices, availability, and critiques should be filtered with this in mind. Is upper mid-tier, in terms of quality and price. The wait staff are prompt, my glass was refilled every two minutes if it needs it. The food was delicious, if not slightly overpriced. Everything felt 8 - 10% higher in cost than what I would consider fair for the meal. Alright, so that's food and wait staff out of the way. Finally, atmosphere: which is going to be a toss up for everyone individually. I lucked out and was placed into a back room which was other wise closed for an event. I arrived at 6:30 pm, and as I was seated, a private band began to play. It was jazz, and very nice for the atmosphere. Overall, the building was loud. Although my snug corner was quieter than most, the noise level did exceed expectations. This was caused by the people, not the band. Overall, a fantastic of not expensive experience. My single ticket was 80$, including an 11$ tip. The only critique I have is that the the back rooms need a paint and flooring job. The carpet is clean but out of date. Great place, please enjoy.

Haywood Jenkins
Reviews 1

We enjoy going out. Last night we visited this excellent restaurant which we didn t know before. We enjoyed a beautiful experience there with great meal and a well-trained crew and a distinguished chef. We put this place in our phone list and we will surely return soon. We highly recommend.

Tammy Cochran
Reviews 1

Love this place! Service, atmosphere, food, cocktails - everything here is superb - almost makes you forget the price tag. We usually go for steak but I decided to try a chicken dish this time - oh my! It was just as wonderful as the steak my husband had...but I still found myself looking at his steak longingly - they really are the best!

Kimmy kimmy
Reviews 1

I only gave a star to respond. There is a fine line when you order a steak rare than raw! Steak had no taste! My wife cooks a better steak in the oven for 6.00 than ordering a 49.00 steak from this place that should have been roadkill. Never again! Gaslights grill has ran out of gas!

Andy Gabbert
Reviews 1

The food was good but not for the amount paid. The service was terrible and the restaurant was not busy. The waiter did not know the menu. When the food came out, he put the plates down in front of the wrong person. At the end of the meal he charged us almost 50 dollars to much. I ordered a glass of wine, when it was finished he never asked if I wanted another. For two people, the total was 120 dollars with tip. At that price point I expect better service. I will probably not go back. Happy hour is only in the bar. We might try that.

Josh Perlinger
Reviews 1

My Wife and I went here for our anniversary, we ordered an appetizer and some wine. The waiter was incredible, very patient with my Wife, she always reads the menu twice and asks a lot of questions. He was genuinely interested in making sure we were happy and taken care of. The live Jazz is incredible! I can't recommend this place enough.

Hannah Mathews
Reviews 1

I had such a great experience here! The food was fantastic and the staff was incredible! There was a small issue, where one of the members of the party I was in, had an over-cooked steak. The server and manager promptly corrected the issue and went above and beyond to make our dinner wonderful!!!!!!! I WILL recommend Gaslight Grill and will be back!!!

Shirley Phillips
Reviews 1

So enjoyed the attention to detail and the personal service of our servers - Katie and Erin. They really made us feel at ease as we had not dined there previously. The owner, Dick Hawk came and introduced himself and he was a delight. The live jazz music was perfect background music to a lovely evening.

David Lane
Reviews 1

Quiet on a late Tuesday evening and I am a solo diner. Still treated well and not relegated to the back table. Great wine list. I like the 8 for $28 hook and the wines in the deal are good quality. Steak was tasty with a reduction demi-glaze. The garlic mash was subtle with skins and chunks. Presentation was excellent and Whitney was delightful. A lovely spot for date night. 40s big band music in the background.

Karin Leacox
Reviews 1

Good food. Great service. BUT we went to have live music with my birthday dinner and the Back Room where the band plays was closed with a private party. There was no way for us to have known ahead of time. We tried to make a phone reservation, but only got recorded messages, so we had to reserve online. Very disappointed.

kira casey
Reviews 1

I really wanted to like this place, we went yesterday evening. My dad and his girlfriend highly recommended it and frequent the restaurant. It attracts an older crowd, which was great, I loved it, but our service was awful. Our server (Justin?) took ages to check on us, didn't really seem to care about anything, and the restaurant wasn't even busy. Several servers walked by noticing our empty glasses and failed to do anything about it. My friends and I are servers at another restaurant in the area, so we try to be understanding, but these servers (especially ours) really just didn't care. The Pretty in Pink is basically Robitussin in a martini glass, everything about it is daunting. The texture is so thick, it's not even pink, it's just not good. Chocolatini and spicy calamari were okay. Definitely not spicy, like the name insinuates, but I didn't hate it. I realize that our bad experience could probably be corrected with a second visit and different server, but I don't think we'll be back.

Robbie Bledsoe
Reviews 1

Great experience at the Gaslight Grill. Our waiter Juan was fantastic and eager to please. In addition to great food my wife and I enjoyed listening to the jazz band. Towards the end of our meal the owner came to each table and introduced himself and made small conversation.

Alex Makin
Reviews 1

Been here three times total. Always a great experience. Their happy hour outside is fun in the summer. Dinner is always top quality. The staff are all great. Nothing is pushed on you. Live music is fantastic. The owner makes a point to stop and greet everyone at each table.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Gaslight Grill

No details yet.