I’ve been a repeat customer of Tulsa Christian Bros Painting in Broken Arrow, hiring them for renovations four times and even recommending them for exterior work. Unfortunately, this latest project has been a major disappointment, and it likely marks the end of our relationship. The main issue was that they subcontracted everything out and failed to manage the crew effectively. During the job, the subcontractor’s priority shifted to other jobs, leaving a relatively inexperienced employee—who was mainly hired for caulking—to tackle the exterior siding alone. This worker applied two full gallons of paint and primer to cover just 1,800 square feet, which is incredibly inefficient. The damage to my brand-new vinyl windows, exterior doors, and sliding glass doors was unacceptable. The subcontractor painted over the frames and clogged the weep holes, which are essential for water drainage. When I complained, the project manager sent the sub back to fix it. However, the sub and his wife used razor blades on the vinyl, ripping out several weep holes completely and scratching the frames. Some holes were left blocked inside the window frames, and the bronze paint in the corners couldn’t be fully removed, leaving the windows looking worn rather than new. Even Mike McCarty, TCBP’s in-house process manager, acknowledged the issues when he came out to inspect the damage. Other oversights included the sub tracking white paint from the backyard through the garage and carport area. Despite my permission to store the paint rig inside overnight, the wet paint door swept white residue onto the threshold. Additionally, after power washing, several spots with flaked old paint weren’t scraped as required by the contract, creating new problems I now have to fix. I proposed a fair settlement to cover the damage to the windows and sliders rather than forcing a full replacement, but TCBP has not responded. I offered to accept half the replacement cost, a significant portion of which could be offset against the labor costs they billed me, since I supplied the materials. Since they ignored this reasonable offer, I’m left with no choice but to file a claim with their insurance.
Ask Trustburn about Tulsa Christian Bros Painting
Post your question publicly — other visitors, and whoever manages this page, can answer. It will be visible on this page.
Want to hear about this company again? Follow it and we’ll email you when a new review appears.
Based on reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.
If you need someone to handle the interior painting of your home in Broken Arrow, Tulsa Christian Bros Painting is an excellent choice. They are a reliable team, and I would gladly recommend their services for any painting project you might have.
I was initially impressed with David from Tulsa Christian Bros Painting during the sales process; his proposal was the best among the three I received. However, the execution was a letdown. The on-site management was disorganized from the start. On day one, the project manager failed to notify us of the start time, meaning the crew didn't arrive until 10 AM. They then left to retrieve equipment that should have been ready, claiming they would return in an hour, but Mark didn't appear until two hours later. To make matters worse, they lacked a hose long enough for the back of the house and had to borrow mine. They barely made any progress before leaving at 3:30 PM. Communication remained poor the next day due to rain; I had to reach out to Mark for an update by 11 AM, only to be told the team wouldn't work for two days. While weather delays are understandable, the lack of proactive communication from the team in Broken Arrow was frustrating enough that I would not recommend them.
I initially chose Tulsa Christian Bros Painting for their strong reputation and the confidence our salesman projected regarding their capabilities in Broken Arrow. However, the reality didn't match the promise once we signed the contract. The removal of the chair rail and the subsequent drywall work were particularly disappointing. Even after multiple touch-ups, I’m still correcting errors a month later. The main issue was a lack of follow-through; despite my repeated calls to the project manager about these issues, there was little to no resolution. We even left with four large bags of trash and old molding sitting in the front yard for two days after they claimed the job was finished. It feels like we got a subpar crew and project manager, which turned what could have been a good experience into a frustrating one due to poor communication and substandard quality.
The team at Tulsa Christian Bros Painting did a fantastic job on our home’s exterior, even while dealing with a wasp problem. The finish looks crisp and clean, and they were careful to leave the yard free of debris. I really appreciated how quickly they got the job done.
I hired Tulsa Christian Bros Painting for an exterior paint job on my house in Broken Arrow, and I regret the decision. Just two years after they finished, the paint is already peeling badly enough that the siding looks completely bare. When I reached out, they claimed the 15-year warranty paint failed because of the rain hitting that specific side of the house, which seems like a weak excuse. Since then, I’ve tried calling and emailing multiple times, but they’ve largely ignored my requests to fix the issue. It’s clear they don’t stand behind their workmanship, materials, or warranty. Their service felt very unprofessional, and I would give zero stars if that were an option.
I really appreciated the professionalism at Tulsa Christian Bros Painting in Broken Arrow. The team took the time to clearly explain the entire process, and their pricing was very fair.
The crew at Tulsa Christian Bros Painting did a fantastic job, and I’ll gladly recommend them to anyone in the Broken Arrow area.
Managing contractors at Tulsa Christian Bros Painting in Broken Arrow, OK, feels like a gamble. We were quoted $2000 for siding repairs and painting two sides of our house, and we triple-checked that price before work began. The experience was a mess. On day one, the crew left after an hour and vanished. I couldn’t reach the project manager because his phone was broken. On day two, after chasing down four different numbers, they appeared, painted over rotted wood, and left early again. Day three brought late starts and excuses about the 55-degree weather, until the crew leader finally stepped in and asked for clarification on the scope. The result? Contract items were missed, while unnecessary extras were added. We were promised a discount on additional siding but didn’t get it. Even after the project ended, the project manager was “sick” and unreachable, forcing us to constantly nag to finish the contracted work. Then came the shock bill: an extra $2000 on top of the agreed price. Despite confirming the $2000 figure three times, the account manager claimed it was wrong and that he was losing money. They also charge $995 for a whole-house paint job, yet painting just two sides of our house cost $1500. If they are Christian Brothers, their business practices don’t reflect those values. It feels like a bait-and-switch from the start.
😊 I am extremely satisfied with Tulsa Christian Bros Painting. The painters did an excellent job painting the interior of my house. They were punctual, courteous, and professional. The attention to detail was impressive, and they left my home clean and tidy after completing the project. I will definitely be using their services again in the future.
👌 Tulsa Christian Bros Painting did a fantastic job painting the exterior of my house. The team was professional and completed the project in a timely manner. Their attention to detail and quality of workmanship were remarkable. I am extremely satisfied with the outcome and would highly recommend their services to anyone in need of a painting contractor.
I recently had my living room painted by a team of professional painters from tulsaokpainters.com. The whole process was smooth and hassle-free. The painters arrived on time, worked efficiently, and left my living room looking beautiful. I am very pleased with the outcome and would definitely hire them again for future painting projects. Highly recommended!
I recently used the services of tulsaokpainters.com and I am thrilled with the results. The team from Tulsa Christian Bros Painting was professional, efficient, and skilled. They completed the job on time and the quality of their work exceeded my expectations. I especially appreciated their attention to detail and their willingness to go the extra mile. I highly recommend them!
I recently hired Tulsa Christian Bros Painting to paint the interior of my office space, and I am delighted with the results. The painters were skilled, professional, and completed the job to my exact specifications. They paid attention to every detail and ensured a flawless finish. I highly recommend them for all your painting needs.
I recently hired professional painters to paint the interior of my home and I am extremely satisfied with the results. The team from tulsaokpainters.com was skilled, efficient, and organized. They paid attention to every detail and delivered a flawless finish. Moreover, they cleaned up before leaving, leaving no mess behind. I highly recommend Tulsa Christian Bros Painting for all your painting needs.
The team from tulsaokpainters.com did an outstanding job painting the exterior of my home. They were professional and efficient, ensuring that every detail was taken care of. The painters arrived on time, worked diligently, and delivered a flawless finish. I am extremely satisfied with the final result and would gladly recommend Tulsa Christian Bros Painting.
I hired Tulsa Christian Bros Painting to paint the exterior of my house and I am extremely satisfied with their work. The painters were professional and detail-oriented. They completed the job on time and the final result exceeded my expectations. The quality of their work is exceptional and I would highly recommend them to anyone in need of painting services.
The painting service provided by tulsaokpainters.com was top-notch. The painters were punctual, polite, and did a fantastic job with my home's exterior. The attention to detail was evident in every stroke of paint. I was particularly impressed with how they transformed the look of my house. I would not hesitate to recommend them to anyone in need of professional painting services.
👍 I can't express how happy I am with the painting job done by Tulsa Christian Bros Painting. The team was friendly, prompt, and did an amazing job with every aspect of the project. From the initial consultation to the final touch-ups, everything was handled professionally. The attention to detail and the quality of their work are truly commendable. I would definitely recommend them!
Questions & Answers
No questions yet — be the first to ask.
Sign in to post
Your text is saved — you'll come right back to post.
Don't have an account? Create one
News & Press
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
Photos
No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.
About Tulsa Christian Bros Painting
- Website
- tulsaokpainters.com
- Address
- 112 W Memphis St