This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz

5.0 195 Reviews
Haven't used This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz yet?
Ask Trustburn

What reviewers say about This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz

Based on 195 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 6 days ago

Customers describe the blog as a reliable go-to source for various recipes, praising the clear, elegant, and easy-to-follow presentation style. Many readers appreciate the transparency regarding ingredients and find the instructions helpful for troubleshooting cooking issues, such as making yogurt or hard-boiled eggs. Some users also enjoy the nostalgic taste of the treats and the convenience of the site for finding simple cooking methods.
What is This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz?

This Old Gal is a recipe and food blog run by Jill Selkowitz that shares homemade recipes with step-by-step instructions. The site organizes content by category, including low carb and keto dishes, holiday and seasonal meals, Jewish and Asian recipes, and dishes prepared using specific methods such as Instant Pot, pressure cooker, air fryer, and slow cooker. It also features a pressure cooker cookbook, kitchen tools, gift guides, and links to an Amazon storefront for cooking accessories.

What categories of recipes are available on the site?

The website organizes recipes by categories such as Keto/Low Carb, Appetizers/Drinks, Breads, Breakfast, Desserts, Main Courses, Soups, Side Dishes, and Casseroles. Additional seasonal categories include Rosh Hashanah, Halloween, Thanksgiving, Chanukkah, Christmas, New Year’s Eve, St. Patrick’s Day, Super Bowl/Game Day, Easter, Passover, 4th of July, Cinco de Mayo, and Memorial Day. Specific cooking methods like Instant Pot, Air Fryer, and Slow Cooker also have their own sections.

What products and resources can visitors purchase or explore?

Visitors can access a pressure cooker cookbook, shop for kitchen essentials, and browse a gift guide. The site includes links to an Amazon storefront for cooking accessories and offers a newsletter subscription. Additionally, there is a dedicated section for buying the cookbook and a page for working with the brand.

What do reviewers say about the potato salad recipes?

Several reviewers highlight that the potato salad has become a staple in their kitchens, with families enjoying it multiple times. Some users mention adding their own favorites like olives and radishes, while others note that the recipe serves as a great introduction to pressure cooking potatoes.

What do reviewers say about the holiday and seasonal recipes?

Reviewers mention that the site offers a wide range of holiday and seasonal recipes, including Super Bowl 2024 Instant Pot Party Food Recipes. These recipes are designed to help plan successful parties for guests.

What do reviewers say about the pressure cooker recipes?

Reviewers praise the pressure cooker recipes for their simplicity and effectiveness. Some users mention that the no-ice-bath method for hard-boiled eggs is particularly simple and effective, leading them to return to the site frequently.

What is the official website of This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz?

The official website of This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz is thisoldgal.com.

How is This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz rated on Trustburn?

On Trustburn, This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz has a rating of 5 out of 5 based on 195 reviews.

Is This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz on social media?

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram, Youtube.

Based on reviews, listing data and the company's website. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Liz Tardio
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz is my go-to source for gyros recipes! I appreciate the transparency regarding ingredients so much more than eating out. I usually swap pita for naan because I find it softer. Quick question: could I make this same recipe using ground chicken?

Annie M
Reviews 1

I had a couple of issues with my yogurt being too thin, but I figured out it was because I wasn't careful enough to keep my tools dry before incubation. Even a tiny bit of water from rinsing a whisk was enough to cause trouble. Now that I make sure everything is completely dry, the problem is gone. Thanks, Jill, for the helpful advice! I really enjoy making yogurt, and it tastes so much better than anything I can buy at the store.

Liz
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz has been my go-to for over two years when I need hard-boiled eggs. I love the simplicity of the no-ice-bath method so much that I still just Google it every time to find my way back here. I really should memorize the settings or save the page, but I’ll keep coming back to this site for now!

jenelle
Reviews 1

I’ve had issues with Sabrett tires blowing out, so I was nervous about trying these. I was careful to double-check that I started with low pressure and let them inflate fully to the recommended NPR. Since they didn’t burst, I’m wondering: is it actually necessary to puncture them before use?

Lauren D.
Reviews 1

Quick question for This Old Gal! The recipe instructs to chill the mixture for 6-8 hours, but does that imply I should wait to strain it? I’ve been straining it immediately, but I’m curious if letting it rest and cool down first would enhance the final result.

LuAnne
Reviews 1

As a customer of This Old Gal, I’ve found their methods reliable for years, especially for homemade Greek yogurt. The results are consistently great, though I did have one minor issue: milk tended to scorch on the bottom of the Instant Pot liner when I used the sauté function to speed things up, despite constant stirring. Cleaning that residue was tedious. Recently, I switched to heating the milk in a separate non-stick pot on the stove. It’s one extra dish to wash, but avoiding the burnt-on mess is totally worth it. Thanks to this small adjustment, I’m enjoying yogurt-making even more.

Angela
Reviews 1

If you are looking to make homemade gyro meat for the whole family, this is the recipe to use. I am actually about to start cooking it right now. One of the best parts is that it is free of fillers, and the results are consistently delicious. I have tested it in my pressure cooker as well as baked as patties in the oven, but I always stick to the same ingredients. It is a fantastic recipe just as written, so it definitely deserves the praise it gets. Thanks, Jill, for sharing this gem!

Sharon Sankey
Reviews 1

I absolutely adore this yogurt recipe for the Instant Pot! Since my husband is lactose intolerant, he can happily enjoy this Greek-style version. I really appreciate the flexibility of making it with regular milk that I heat and sterilize myself, which saves me from having to buy specific dairy products at the store. I use the yogurt as a versatile substitute for sour cream and buttermilk, but it’s also delicious on its own with a drizzle of honey and some fresh fruit and nuts. I’ve tried pressure cookers from other brands before, so I’m curious—how do you adapt this recipe if your device doesn’t have a dedicated yogurt setting? Thanks so much for the tip!

CF
Reviews 1

I have to give a huge shout-out to Jill at This Old Gal! Even though I was forced to make a few swaps in the recipe (which feels a bit rude to do to a new creation), the core technique and guidance she provides truly shine through. This was actually my first time making potato salad—I’m usually not a fan—but your description just sold me on trying it, and the result was absolutely fantastic. I had to improvise quite a bit: I used bread and butter pickles instead of dill because that’s what I had on hand, and I realized too late that I didn’t have Lawry’s seasoned salt. So, for the TOG (This Old Gal) spice blend, I had to whip up a quick substitute. Since I only made a half batch of the salad, I adjusted the spices on the fly: 1/2 tsp sugar, 1/4 tsp celery seed, and a tiny pinch (1/16 tsp) each of garlic powder, onion powder, and celery salt. Despite all that guesswork and improvisation, it turned out to be pure gold! Pro tip for next time: I did a one-minute delay before the quick release, and it caused the 3/4 to 1-inch potato cubes to break up more than I’d like. I definitely won’t do that next time. I’ll be making this again, but this time I’ll buy the real TOG blend and follow the recipe exactly as written, because I trust Jill’s methods completely. I’ll probably still avoid the dill pickles, but having all the other ingredients on hand will make a huge difference. If my improvised version tasted this good, I can only imagine how perfect the original will be. Thank you so much for the website and for all the great recipes I’m eager to try. Also, that hack about pressing hard-boiled eggs through a cookie rack is brilliant—those little squares fit perfectly! Delicious!

Crystal Clearwater
Reviews 1

Hi Jill! I’m looking forward to trying out this air fryer in my new Power Kalorik model, especially since I have the skewer attachments. Do you have any advice for adapting this recipe to use the skewers instead of a basket? Thanks in advance!

Jason
Reviews 1

At This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz, I’ve found that pressure cooking really does make a difference for pork dishes compared to using an Instant Pot or air fryer. The flavor is just superior, though this recipe turned out delicious either way.

sue bee
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz really nailed it with this recipe. I followed the instructions exactly and added a quick broil after slicing the meat, and the result was fantastic. I grabbed some store-bought tzatziki to save time, but I’ll definitely be making Jill’s version next time.

Kay
Reviews 1

I’m having trouble getting my Instant Pot to reach pressure with this recipe. Could you clarify which setting you use? I wasn’t sure if it should be on the standard pressure setting or the meat/stew function. After a few attempts, I switched to the meat/stew setting and it finally worked. Thanks!

Ellen
Reviews 1

Great recipe from This Old Gal! I just wanted to flag a small error in the instructions. The text says to mix leeks, turnips, and radishes together in one bowl, but then it instructs to sauté the leeks with carrots and peppers. This made it tricky for me to separate the leeks from the other veggies before cooking. Aside from that minor confusion, it’s a wonderful dish.

Ellen
Reviews 1

Finally found a winner in my cookbook! I was skeptical about adding turnips and radishes to the mix, especially after four decades of cooking, but this recipe won me over. The radishes blended in perfectly, and I even tricked my husband by using turnips instead of potatoes without him noticing. I swapped out the chili paste for red pepper, but it still turned out amazing. This one is definitely staying in the rotation.

Diane
Reviews 1

Pizza enthusiasts, you need to check out This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz. After trying countless recipes, I finally found one that actually works. The dough is incredibly easy to handle, a huge upgrade from the labor-heavy 00 flour versions I used to wrestle with. It’s so much more forgiving that my husband even noticed the difference in my mood during prep! The result is a perfect crust with that ideal balance of chew and crisp. Jill’s methods really deliver a superior homemade pizza experience.

Rita
Reviews 1

I’ve made this banana bread in This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz’s way ever since, and it’s my new standard. Accurately measuring the flour truly changes the texture. Thanks for the tip! I’m curious if cranberries would work well in this specific recipe?

Michelle
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz delivered exactly what I needed. I adapted the recipe using coconut sugar instead of white sugar, which resulted in a perfectly balanced sweetness—ideal if you prefer desserts that aren’t overly sweet. I baked it in a 3qt Mini Ultra Instant Pot for 22 minutes, and the batter yielded enough for three mini cakes (Amazon offers a suitable 3-cup Bundt pan). There was one small issue where a corner remained slightly undercooked, likely because I forgot to cover it, but that didn’t detract from the result. My husband, who usually avoids rich cakes, absolutely loved it.

David Edelberg
Reviews 1

I initially posted a one-star rating for this by mistake, but it absolutely deserves five stars. Please remove that earlier review if possible. This Old Gal’s chili con carne is hands down the best I’ve ever had. You do need to simmer it down to get the right consistency, but the result is phenomenal. Stick to the full recipe and don’t skip any ingredients—that splash of Thai fish sauce really takes the flavor to another level.

David Edelberg
Reviews 1

If you’re looking for the ultimate chili, look no further than This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz. This recipe is absolutely phenomenal, though you’ll need to simmer it down to get that perfect thick consistency. The key is using every single ingredient—trust me, that splash of Thai fish sauce is a total game-changer for the depth of flavor. I’ve never tasted anything quite like it!

Meg Anderson
Reviews 1

I’ve been making This Old Gal’s soup for months now and it’s become a staple in my kitchen. I whip it up every few weeks, and after making a batch last weekend, I just made another one today. My son visited from college and asked for leftovers to take with him, which convinced me I need to start stocking up on ingredients so I never run out! 😂

Terri
Reviews 1

I tried out a recipe from This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz tonight using my Instant Pot for the first time. It was such a relief to avoid heating up the house with the oven in this 100-degree weather! I made it healthier by swapping in applesauce for butter and cutting the sugar in half. The result was absolutely delicious. Thanks for the great guidance!

Logan
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz never disappoints. I’ve been making this recipe for years, and it’s a total hit. I usually toss in some chicken breast pieces, which turns it into a perfect dinner every single time. Our family absolutely loves it!

Tracey
Reviews 1

Fantastic recipe from This Old Gal! I made a few tweaks to suit my taste, but the base is solid. I used golden baby potatoes instead of the standard kind and cut the dressing amount since I only had a 1.5 lb bag. I skipped the dill and swapped pickles for sweet relish. For extra flavor, I tossed the steamed potatoes with a tablespoon of apple cider vinegar and let them sit for five minutes. I also cooked the eggs in their shells, mashed the yolks into the dressing for a deviled egg vibe, and just squished the whites by hand. It’s delicious now, but I know it’ll be even better after chilling overnight. Thanks, Jill!

Lori
Reviews 1

I can’t say enough good things about the potato salad recipe! I had some of the TOG seasoning on hand since my rare roast beef sandwiches from last weekend were such a big hit. While the recipes do require a bit more effort than others, the result is absolutely worth it. Thanks so much!

Wendy Mccammon
Reviews 1

I’ve been using Fairlife with This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz recipes for ages, and it never fails to impress my friends. It’s even become a hit with the kids, who lovingly call it "yogert icecream." I’m now excited to try the boil method to expand my culinary toolkit.

Diane
Reviews 1

I’m definitely getting more confident with this now, and I really enjoy the process each time I bake. My only goal is to get my loaves to look as good as yours! I do have a quick question about the yeast measurement. When I measure 1/2 teaspoon on my scale, it only registers as 1 gram. Should I be using a full teaspoon to achieve the recommended 2 grams, or is half a teaspoon correct? I’ve noticed my bread doesn’t rise as high as yours. Also, the bottom crust tends to turn out quite tough, thick, and sometimes burnt. I’ve tried using a baking stone with a covered pot, as well as a non-cast iron Dutch oven, but I’m still having trouble with the base. Thanks for your help!

Kim
Reviews 1

I haven’t got an air fryer myself, so I relied on my convection oven instead. I’m not entirely sure if the outcome would be identical, but it doesn’t matter to me since the result was truly fantastic. I’ll definitely be making this dish from This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz over and over again. Thanks so much for sharing.

Crystal Marie
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz really delivered! I improvised by skipping the broth and using a giant can of enchilada sauce instead. I also tossed in a peeled, sliced potato to make up for being short on chicken. Despite being out of onions, chili, and peppers, the result was still amazing. I’ll definitely be making it again!

Kimberly Hale
Reviews 1

I haven’t baked bread in years, but I was thrilled with how this came out—it was nearly perfect! Since I ran short on whey, I substituted mostly water; I suspect adding more whey might have boosted that authentic sourdough tang. My only critique is that the crust ended up quite thick, crisp, and chewy (which I actually love in crusty loaves), but the center wasn’t fully cooked through. I baked it in a cast iron skillet topped with a domed lid from my aluminum Dutch oven, so I suspect the thinner lid didn’t retain heat as effectively as a full cast iron setup would have. Next time, I’ll stick to just the cast iron Dutch oven and its lid. Absolutely easy to make and delicious!

Rosslynn
Reviews 1

Living in Portland, I’ve found that the Ninja air fryer is a game-changer for reheating leftovers. I usually set it to 270°F for about 13 minutes. Letting them rest for 10 minutes ensures they stay hot, and an ice bath for another 10 minutes works wonders. I might try reducing the time to 12 minutes next time for even better results.

Vivian
Reviews 1

My spouse and I finally tried the salt and pepper wings recipe from This Old Gal, and they turned out amazing. We shared them with both sets of parents, and the feedback was universally positive. Honestly, they taste even better than the takeout we usually get from our neighborhood Chinese spot!

Tanna
Reviews 1

I baked this in a 7-inch round pan inside my Instant Pot for 60 minutes, and the center came out perfectly done. I followed the tip to cover it loosely with parchment and foil, and swapped in half a cup of Truvia baking sugar for the sweetness. Delicious result!

Mary Kay
Reviews 1

Loved this dish from This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz! I cooked a large chicken (over 5 lbs) in my Instant Pot with the air fryer lid, cooking for 35 minutes on each side. I seasoned it with avocado oil, salt, and pepper, and used the included rack. The result was perfectly browned with crispy skin and super juicy meat. Thanks for sharing such a great recipe!

Christin
Reviews 1

I’m a fan of This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz and just picked up my first whole chicken from them for Christmas! It’s a healthy 5.89 lbs. Since I’m still getting the hang of air fryer temps—they behave differently than my oven—I want to be extra careful to ensure the meat is fully cooked through. Do you recommend adding more than the suggested extra 10 minutes to guarantee it’s done?

Jennifer Fish
Reviews 1

As a fan of Jill Selkowitz’s work, I found her advice on pickled beets to be spot on. Using an Instant Pot really simplifies the process. After peeling the cooked beets, I chop them into chunks and simmer them with the residual beet juice, some water, pickling spice, apple cider vinegar, and stevia (or sugar, if you prefer) for about 15 to 20 minutes. Once cooled, they store beautifully in the fridge for weeks. A terrific recipe that lives up to the high standards of This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz.

Lisa
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz really knows how to deliver a hit. I whipped up some leftover sirloin with Thai chilies using their recipe, and it turned out amazing. I’m actually surprised by my own cooking skills! Definitely skipping takeout for tonight. Thanks, Jill!

Pedro
Reviews 1

I gave this recipe a try over the weekend and was initially skeptical about the four-minute cooking time for pork shoulder. Following the suggestion to marinate the meat overnight in orange and lime juice made all the difference—the result was incredibly tender and delicious. I also thickened the sauce using some Robin Hood Easy Blend Flour before serving. This is easily one of the best Instant Pot pork dishes I’ve made. Thanks for sharing, This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz!

Teresa P
Reviews 1

I’m sticking with my guns regarding the "Air Fryer ROTISSERIE Chicken" recipe from This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz. The name promises a rotisserie result, but the instructions simply tell you to cook it in a pan. That’s a basic roast, not rotisserie, so the title feels inaccurate. It’s misleading right from the start, and I won’t be using this recipe.

Karla
Reviews 1

I tried the recipe from This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz and it was absolutely delicious! The only adjustment I made was due to a fresh jalapeno shortage at my local grocery store. I really wanted to make it that evening, so I substituted two cans of diced jalapenos (not pickled) instead. The result turned out great despite the swap.

Leslie
Reviews 1

I made the gnocchi with chopped tomatoes, mushrooms, and a touch of Italian seasoning at This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz, and it turned out delicious. It’s such a simple dish that I’m actually thinking of adding some kidney beans to the leftovers tomorrow. Really easy and tasty—thanks, Jill!

Leslie
Reviews 1

This looks delicious! I’ve been enjoying all of your recipes. I’m curious if this would work well in an Instant Pot Ace Blender without using the blended soup setting? I just worry the tortellini might end up overcooked. Since I’m still building my collection of blender recipes, I’m always on the lookout for new ideas. Thanks for sharing, Jill!

Wanda A Gossman
Reviews 1

I’m usually not a fan of cauliflower, but since I had one in my produce box this week, I figured I might as well use it up. Thanks to your suggestion, I decided to give it a shot, and we actually really enjoyed it. I’d definitely make it again and will keep making it. I tell everyone to check out your site thisoldgal.com. I’ve loved every single recipe of yours that I’ve tried so far. Thank you!

Karl
Reviews 1

As a pickle enthusiast, I usually skip them in potato salad, but I love adding a kick by blending spicy giardiniera into the mayonnaise. This Old Gal’s mayo is the perfect base for this hack. Once you try this simple trick, you’ll be using it in all sorts of dishes that call for mayo. Highly recommend checking out this Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz for your condiment needs!

Leslie Honey
Reviews 1

This Old Gal’s potato salad recipe is a winner. My family really enjoyed it. I made double the batch and used two cycles in my 6-quart Instant Pot. For the dressing, I swapped the dill pickle for a splash of vinegar to add a bit of tartness against the mayo. I’ve tried a couple other recipes for this dish, but this one is hands down the best. Thanks, Jill!

Kerrie
Reviews 1

I have made This Old Gal’s sauce multiple times now and I always double the batch, keeping it stocked in the fridge for those lazy days when I need a quick, flavorful tofu and veggie lunch that doesn’t taste like the usual one-note sweetness I’m used to getting from takeout here in San Francisco. I was honestly skeptical at first because I usually hate bottled sauces, but the depth of flavor here really reminds me of what I used to enjoy back in the Bay Area years ago. It’s complex and satisfying. I even swapped in apple cider vinegar on a whim once and it turned out just as delicious.

Barbara Boeske
Reviews 1

Jill’s detailed instructions made this process a breeze. My batch turned out perfectly, and I’m currently straining it in the fridge after an 110-degree incubation for 12 hours. Since I was working late, my boyfriend kept the yogurt warm to prevent spoilage, which worked out flawlessly. I just pulled it from the fridge this morning, and it has reached a lovely sour cream-like consistency. It tastes amazing and yields a generous amount. I used about four tablespoons of store-bought yogurt as a starter.

laura
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz has another winner here! I’ve cooked this dish more than once and the whole family is always eager for it. I didn’t have fresh red peppers on hand, so I improvised with jarred ones, and it turned out just as delicious. After blending the base, I stirred in some shredded chicken, and my daughter loved adding a dollop of sour cream on top. Truly delish—thanks for the great recipe!

Mike
Reviews 1

Big fan of your recipes, especially this one! I’m currently out of vanilla bean pods but have paste on hand, and the label notes that 1 tablespoon equals 1 pod. Based on that conversion, should I adjust the amount of vanilla extract called for in your recipe? Thanks for your help!

Gerry
Reviews 1

I have a quick question for Jill at This Old Gal: would it work to mix dry cardamom with the sugar, and if so, what amount do you suggest? I plan to use vanilla extract along with either sugar or Splenda. The result looks wonderful and refreshing.

John Libby
Reviews 1

I recently picked up a cast iron skillet from This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz specifically to try out her recipes, and it was definitely worth the purchase. I followed the instructions exactly, and the result was outstanding—honestly, it rivaled or even surpassed the best Thai dishes I’ve ever had. The guidance provided was clear and easy to follow. Thank you for sharing such a fantastic recipe!

The Coasties
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz really delivers! The flavor is fantastic, especially if you like things hot like we do. I’ve found that blending a bit of Chipotle in Adobo sauce from the market into the mix works perfectly. Just add a tablespoon or two and you’re in for a treat.

Questions & Answers

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

News & Press

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying widget on your website — its a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Embed code

<script src="https://trustburn.com/widgets/index.js"></script>
<div class="trustburn-widget" data-trustburn-protocol="https:" data-trustburn-domain="trustburn.com" data-trustburn-widget="score" data-company-path="thisoldgal-com" data-lang="en"></div>
More widgets

About This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz

This Old Gal is a recipe and food blog run by Jill that shares homemade recipes with step-by-step instructions. The site organizes content by category, including low carb and keto dishes, holiday and seasonal meals, Jewish and Asian recipes, and dishes prepared using specific methods such as Instant Pot, pressure cooker, air fryer, and slow cooker. The site also features a pressure cooker cookbook, kitchen tools, gift guides, and links to an Amazon storefront for cooking accessories. Additional sections include contact information, privacy and cookie policies, and terms and conditions.