Haven't used The Cooking Jar yet?
Ask AI

What reviewers say about The Cooking Jar

Generated with AI from 299 reviews on Trustburn · updated 2 days ago

Customers generally find the recipes easy to follow and delicious, with many noting that the dishes turn out well and become regular fixtures in their meal rotations. Reviewers frequently praise the quality of the recipes and the helpfulness of the photography and tips provided on the site.
What does The Cooking Jar do?

The Cooking Jar is a recipe website that publishes cooking instructions organized by course, ingredient, and cooking method such as air fryer, oven, sheet pan, slow cooker, and stovetop. Its content covers categories including appetizers, breakfasts, casseroles, dips and sauces, main dishes, sides and salads, and soups and stews. The site presents itself as a resource for making cooking approachable with simple ingredients.

Are there any complaints about The Cooking Jar?

The critical reviewers wrote that some recipes resulted in gummy or gluey dumplings, while others were described as watery, bland, or having an off balance of ingredients like excessive mushrooms. One reviewer also mentioned that a specific product had too much sugar and did not live up to expectations.

What do people say about The Cooking Jar outside Trustburn?

Outside of Trustburn, discussions mention the website as a resource for cooking, with one person noting that it is a great skill for boys to learn and that the site can help inspire interest in cooking.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Elizabeth
Reviews 1

I stuck to the instructions for The Cooking Jar recipe exactly, but the dumplings ended up gummy and turned the whole dish into a sticky, gluey mess. The flavor was completely masked by the taste of raw dough, even though I used less biscuit than the recipe called for. It was a letdown. Next time, I’d probably bake the biscuits separately and use them as a crunchy topping at the end instead.

Alexa Goldstein
Reviews 1

This dish was incredibly simple to prepare! I made it using budget-friendly Great Value products I already had in my pantry. For the sauce, I took a 22-ounce jar of their Alfredo and enhanced it with a pinch of nutmeg and about a tablespoon of garlic powder, adding extra sauce on top for even more flavor. It’s so easy that I’ll definitely be making it again, this time opting for higher-quality ingredients.

Caden
Reviews 1

The pasta portion in the recipe is quite generous for The Cooking Jar, as we found it heavy even when my mom and I cut the noodles in half. To get that perfect creamy texture, you might want to reduce the amount of pasta significantly. Also, don’t skip the seasoning; the cream base is fairly mild, so adding extra salt, pepper, and plenty of onion and garlic really enhances the flavor.

Michaelle
Reviews 1

I was really impressed with the results! The tip about toasting the breadcrumbs was a game-changer. I had some buttermilk on hand, so I used it to dip my chicken strips in, along with my favorite spice blend. The flavor was outstanding. Thanks for the great tip!

Laura
Reviews 1

A new staple in my recipe collection. I cooked the salmon in a pan with olive oil while my cinnamon raisin bread baked. After setting the fish aside, I quickly sautéed the garlic before tossing in the pasta and the rest of the sauce ingredients, using a bit of pasta water to get that perfect creamy consistency. It was absolutely delicious, even without the cheese.

Yvette Owens
Reviews 1

The chicken cutlet recipe from The Cooking Jar was a huge hit! My husband couldn't stop raving about it, saying it was so good he’d be hosting dinner guests just to show off his cooking skills. I served it with fresh parsley, butter, and spaghetti, and it was perfect. Next time, I think I’ll pair it with mashed potatoes instead. Kudos to the team for such a delicious recipe! 😋

Kim
Reviews 1

I’ve found The Cooking Jar to be a fantastic resource for customizable, home-style cooking. The recipe is forgiving and encourages you to use up what you have on hand—I tossed in sautéed mushrooms and bell peppers, plus a touch of anchovy paste for depth. While the smoky flavor wasn’t quite my preference today, swapping in Hungarian sweet paprika worked well, and I’ll definitely experiment with smoked paprika next time. I also wish I’d stirred green onions into the sour cream and cottage cheese blend for an extra kick. Since I work from home and prefer to avoid takeout, these casseroles are a lifesaver. After cooling overnight, I portion them out, freeze them in ziplock bags, and they reheat beautifully in the microwave. One tip from my own kitchen: I stick with cottage cheese over commercial ricotta in baked dishes for a much better texture, unless I’m making fresh ricotta from scratch. Thanks for the great recipe!

Nancy North
Reviews 1

I stumbled upon this recipe here on The Cooking Jar and instantly recognized it as the classic dish I saved from a newspaper clipping about four decades ago. It’s been sitting in my physical recipe binder all these years, but I never digitized it, so finding it online was a pleasant surprise. The dish remains simple and consistently delicious. I’ve made it a habit to swap in sausage for the ground beef to give it a little extra flavor.

Aubrey
Reviews 1

I’m actually making this dip for the second time in just four months after finding that perfect photo of it back in February. I’d never tried buffalo chicken dip before, but I can’t get enough of The Cooking Jar’s recipe. I nearly had a meltdown this week thinking I’d lost the instructions, but luckily it was bookmarked in my Safari. Leaving out the blue cheese and green onion worked perfectly—the flavor is just incredible. I’m sticking with this one for good.

RP
Reviews 1

I followed the instructions from The Cooking Jar exactly as directed, but the result was disappointing. It ended up tasting watery and bland, and the texture made it hard to shred. The final dish looked nothing like the demonstration video. I really hoped the positive reviews would hold true, but this just didn't live up to expectations.

Paula Larsen
Reviews 1

I just whipped up The Cooking Jar’s recipe for dinner and doubled the batch since it was such a hit. The taste was spot-on and the texture was cooked to perfection. I’ll definitely be adding this dish to my regular weekly meal plan.

Cristina
Reviews 1

I absolutely loved the meal from The Cooking Jar! It’s definitely going into my regular rotation. I made it my own by using cheddar since that was what I had available, and I added 3/4 tsp of salt to the cheese sauce to enhance the flavor even more.

Onyx
Reviews 1

I’ve made The Cooking Jar tacos four times so far—once for my birthday, once for my partner’s, and twice just because I love them. I’m pretty sure I’m going to make them a fifth time very soon! I was initially skeptical about how little water they call for, but the result is always perfect. I have no idea what kind of kitchen magic happens at thecookingjar.com, but I’ll be a repeat customer for life.

Stacey Hartline
Reviews 1

I’ve made The Cooking Jar’s beef recipe several times now and it’s a family favorite. We prefer a richer consistency, so I always double the sauce ingredients while keeping the beef at 1lb. Adding Rotel and cheddar jack gives it that extra kick we love. Highly recommend!

Edna Fay Sapp
Reviews 1

I just whipped up this dish at The Cooking Jar and it was a hit with both my husband and me. The portion size is generous enough to serve a crowd, so I’ll definitely need to halve the recipe for a couple of us. Has anyone here tried freezing it?

Andrew
Reviews 1

If you’re looking for a go-to dish at The Cooking Jar, this one is it. The meat comes out incredibly flavorful, and it’s a huge hit with my kids. My secret tip: let it sear nicely on the pan bottom on both sides toward the end to build up that crust, then deglaze with a splash of water to keep everything juicy and tender.

Ethen
Reviews 1

The Cooking Jar has truly become my go-to source for cooking inspiration. That recipe was an absolute game-changer for me—I found myself watching the video just as much to stave off hunger as to learn the steps! I also can’t recommend the Million Dollar Dip paired with Ritz crackers highly enough; it’s simply delicious.

Susan
Reviews 1

The Cooking Jar’s air fryer salmon has quickly become my go-to for a quick and delicious meal. It was incredibly simple to prepare and turned out fantastic. I’m already planning to add some red pepper flakes next time for a bit of extra heat.

MONICA V.
Reviews 1

My family and I absolutely adored this simple yet delicious chicken dish from The Cooking Jar. I was hoping to find a new chicken recipe to try, and this fit the bill perfectly. I served the meat over a pile of thick pasta, and it turned out great. The only thing I might do differently next time is double the sauce for extra flavor. Thanks for sharing such a fun and tasty recipe! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Sam
Reviews 1

This recipe from The Cooking Jar was a huge hit with my family tonight. I almost skipped the refried beans, but glad I added them—they really tie the flavors together. I stuck with the corn tortillas as written, though I did add the onions and garlic to the ground beef while it browned for extra depth. The dish is delicious as is, so don’t feel like you need to change anything. We just finished it off with a dollop of sour cream, some picante sauce, and a bit of extra cheese. Highly recommend!

Patti
Reviews 1

I’m really happy with the salmon dish from The Cooking Jar. We’ve been trying to eat more fish, and this recipe is now a permanent fixture in our weekly meal plan. Just a quick tip: I lightly sprayed the fillets with avocado oil before applying the rub, and the result was fantastic. Thanks for sharing such a simple and delicious recipe!

Kristy
Reviews 1

I absolutely loved this dish from The Cooking Jar! I stuck to the instructions but added a bit extra garlic for that extra kick. It was super simple to put together and packed with flavor. I’ve actually found a great way to handle leftovers: I warm them up with a dash more soy sauce and a drizzle of sesame oil, which keeps everything moist and tasty instead of dry. It’s definitely going into my regular rotation.

Lisa
Reviews 1

I’m really impressed with the taco seasoning from The Cooking Jar. The flavor pack was generous, so I only needed a small amount of chili powder to avoid it being too spicy. I made it with white corn tortillas and skipped the refried beans, though I did add fresh lime and sour cream for extra taste. The result looked as good as it tasted—truly a keeper.

Debra
Reviews 1

Just prepared The Cooking Jar’s dish for dinner tonight and it was a hit! The flavor is incredible, especially since I followed the recipe and seasoned it to my liking. I did add some mushrooms for extra depth. Honestly, it beats traditional lasagna any day. Highly recommend!

Traci
Reviews 1

I’ve been making this dish in a skillet for years after screenshotting the recipe back in 2017, though I missed the slow cooker instructions. I usually toss the seasonings, including Worcestershire sauce, directly into the meat, then add marinara, sugar, and spinach once it’s cooked. After the spinach wilts, I stir in the noodles and cheese. While it might not be the traditional method, it works perfectly for me! I’m curious to see how The Cooking Jar’s version turns out in a crockpot, though I’m sure both methods yield a delicious result.

Sonia J
Reviews 1

The Cooking Jar made this recipe a breeze to recreate! I based the meal on some leftover taco meat, sticking to the standard measurements even though I only had a pound on hand. Since I was out of chili powder, I improvised with a mix of paprika, cayenne, and cumin that worked just as well. We topped it off with fresh guacamole, chopped cilantro, and sour cream. The result was absolutely delicious.

Diane
Reviews 1

Absolutely delicious! My husband isn’t a fan of seafood, but he really enjoyed this meal. I marinated the fish for 45 minutes and cooked it in the air fryer. It was topped with sauteed mushrooms, onions, and peppers. The Cooking Jar provided a fantastic product. Highly recommend!

Tori
Reviews 1

I have prepared this dish countless times at home. It is incredibly simple, quick, and practically impossible to mess up. The flavor is outstanding, and even the leftovers taste amazing. I am planning to make it again this Christmas Eve and finally realized after all these years that I should have left a review sooner.

Rochelle Sohl
Reviews 1

I enjoyed the concept behind this meal from The Cooking Jar, but it could use some tweaks. I found the Rao’s alfredo and pesto sauces a bit too salty, so I’d recommend saving half of the alfredo to add at the very end. Also, ensure the ravioli is thoroughly covered in sauce. While it’s a simple and good idea, I plan to reduce the spinach quantity by more than half in my next order.

Reanna
Reviews 1

I made this dish twice in just one week because the whole family was hooked. The noodles are hands down the best part of any hibachi meal, and this comes surprisingly close to the restaurant version. I’d recommend cutting the sugar down to two tablespoons; the first batch was a bit too sweet for my liking, but otherwise, it’s a 10/10 recipe from The Cooking Jar.

G. West
Reviews 1

I tried a recipe from The Cooking Jar and it turned out surprisingly well. I was out of my usual corn tortillas, so I improvised by softening flour tortillas in a greased skillet. To make up for the missing corn flavor, I crumbled some tortilla chips on top of the refried beans. Since there weren’t any black beans on hand, I followed the suggestion to use pinto beans instead. I also threw in some bell peppers along with the onions and garlic for extra flavor. It was a tasty result despite the substitutions!

Julie
Reviews 1

This is hands-down the best yum-yum sauce I have ever prepared at home. The flavor profile is incredibly similar to what you get at a local Japanese steakhouse, making it a perfect copycat. I made a slight adjustment by swapping the Sriracha for ketchup, and it turned out great. Highly recommend for anyone looking to recreate that restaurant experience in their own kitchen.

Lara
Reviews 1

The Cooking Jar delivered exactly what I needed. As someone who just started using an air fryer, finding reliable salmon recipes can be tough. Their instructions were spot-on and made the process easy and delicious. Great resource for anyone looking to upgrade their home cooking.

Erin R
Reviews 1

The Cooking Jar’s recipes are a game-changer. This one was incredibly simple to whip up, yet the flavor was outstanding—honestly, it’s easily in my top ten home-cooked meals. I followed the instructions exactly, though I substituted mini spinach and ricotta ravioli just because I had them on hand. Highly recommend trying it out!

Denise Rogers
Reviews 1

I’m whipping this up for dinner tonight, and it’s instantly transported me back to a recipe I’ve loved for nearly four decades. My sister-in-law gave it to us way back when, and it’s been a staple ever since. I was digging through my old recipe box just now but couldn’t locate it. I took a leap of faith and searched online, and lucky for me, it’s here at The Cooking Jar—exactly as I remembered. My husband loved it too, and it’s going to bring back so many great memories. It’s genuinely delicious, super simple to make, and pairs perfectly with a fresh salad or any steamed greens.

Mona Journey
Reviews 1

The Cooking Jar delivers some seriously delicious soup. We customized ours by mixing sausage and chorizo, which was perfect for our family’s preference for a bit of heat. Truly a standout dish. I’m curious, does the recipe work well for stovetop preparation?

Jen
Reviews 1

The Cooking Jar’s recipes are incredibly user-friendly. I’ve customized the dish by swapping the pasta for white rice, or even using kielbasa and pierogies in place of the standard sausage and noodles. It’s a reliable hit every single time.

Collin
Reviews 1

If you want to make a real deal with your tacos at The Cooking Jar, try this trick. Shred your beef and dip one side of a soft tortilla in the cooking juices before placing it wet-side down in a pan. Add cheese, meat, and fold it into that classic taco shape. Fry until crispy, then unfold to pile on fresh onions and cilantro. It’s absolutely worth the effort.

Sally
Reviews 1

I tried a recipe from The Cooking Jar last night and my husband and I absolutely loved it. He’s already asked for it to be made again! I followed the instructions exactly, just making the sauce a bit creamier as suggested, and served it alongside mashed potatoes. Simple, delicious, and definitely a keeper.

Mama Bunkfish
Reviews 1

I found this recipe to be a simple, budget-friendly hit. We didn’t have chili powder on hand, but the dish still packed a punch of flavor. Greasing the casserole dish with olive oil made serving it up a breeze. It’s officially joining our weekly Taco Tuesday rotation!

Rhonda Graddy
Reviews 1

I tried the Hibachi noodles recipe from The Cooking Jar for lunch and it was a huge success. My nine-year-old loved it so much he said he could eat it every day, which I definitely agree with. I stuck closely to your instructions, only adding an extra clove of garlic for flavor. It’s become a regular in our rotation.

Theodore
Reviews 1

The Cooking Jar really nailed the flavor with this one. I’m firing it up tomorrow using a chuck tender roast and I’m seriously looking forward to it. Regarding the oven method, I actually prefer slow-roasting at 250 degrees myself. My go-to trick is smoking the meat for about an hour outdoors before finishing it in a low oven for 6 to 8 hours. It turns out incredibly tender and just falls apart.

Heather Hoover
Reviews 1

I absolutely loved this recipe from The Cooking Jar! I improvised a bit since I was out of Rotel and black beans, so I swapped in green chili peppers, chili beans, and skipped the chili powder. I stuck with flour tortillas, and the result was fantastic. I finished it off with sour cream, fresh chives, and lettuce. It’s definitely going into my regular rotation now. Thanks for sharing!

Jennifer
Reviews 1

I rarely bother writing reviews, but I had to make an exception for this pasta salad recipe from The Cooking Jar. It’s hands down the best one I’ve ever put together, likely thanks to the homemade dressing and those crisp, fresh vegetables. Even my sister, whose Italian husband is notoriously picky about food, was thoroughly impressed. Thanks for sharing such a wonderful recipe!

Joan Emran
Reviews 1

The Cooking Jar delivered another standout recipe. I kept it simple, just stirring in some paprika to the flour mix. My husband decided to brighten up the sauce with a dash of lemon juice, which balanced the sweetness perfectly. It’s already earned a permanent spot in our rotation—I’ll be making it again and again.

Questions & Answers

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

News & Press

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying widget on your website — its a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Embed code

<script src="https://trustburn.com/widgets/index.js"></script>
<div class="trustburn-widget" data-trustburn-protocol="https:" data-trustburn-domain="trustburn.com" data-trustburn-widget="score" data-company-path="thecookingjar-com" data-lang="en"></div>
More widgets

About The Cooking Jar

The Cooking Jar is a recipe website that publishes cooking instructions organized by course, ingredient, and cooking method such as air fryer, oven, sheet pan, slow cooker, and stovetop. Its content covers categories including appetizers, breakfasts, casseroles, dips and sauces, main dishes, sides and salads, and soups and stews, featuring recipes like cucumber sandwiches, easy chicken tetrazzini, honey glazed salmon, and creamy pesto chicken pasta. The site offers a recipe index and a free eCookbook that subscribers receive when they sign up for its newsletter. It presents itself as a resource for making cooking approachable with simple ingredients.