The Carnegie Club Review

Another exceptional show at the Carnegie Club!

We made reservations for back to back shows, as we always do, for Steven Maglio and were able to sit in our usual seats.

As always the crowd was shifting around considerably in the club so we had to wait longer than usual in order to get drinks and cigars ordered. I usually prefer the Oban 14 year accompanied by a Winston Churchill.

The staff are wonderful, they literally handle everything without missing a heartbeat. At this point it's time to sit back and enjoy the show.

Steve is absolutely phenomenal, highly talented and a great guy. We had a wonderful time once again, had great conversation with Steve followed by photos. This club is an absolute gem!
Cheers!

Great Cigars! Even better ambiance!
Def plan on coming back!!

You gotta like whisky and cigars. But if that's your thing, this is the place.

Fantastic ventilation, good cigar choices, amazing cocktails, and an ambiance you would die for. 11/10

What a great place - really! Another good reason to vist New York again.

Classic. It's a very nice cigar lounge. Better do reservation to get a sofa seat

If you're looking for a cool smoking club that has a great selection of smokes than this is your place. While it isn't as big as some of the other more popular clubs they make up for it with a cool scene and live music. 2 floors and great staff, will definitely be back.

Whenever I visit Manhattan I stop by this cigar lounge. This time wasn't as pleasant due to poor service and rude waiter. Planning to go back to NYC in October. Hope the services and experience is better

Cozy and upscale cigar lounge but the cigar selection options are limited. I'm told their supplier is facing covid related delivery challenges l..
A great place to unwind.