Reviews 358 Page 4 of 4
Filters:
Rating
Language
Sort:
Most recent

They're food (especially the raspberry shake) is y...

They're food (especially the raspberry shake) is yummy, but they take FOREVER. Easily waited 45 minutes for our food to be ready. Very disappointed with our visit as we have been going there for years!

Horrible banana shake with banana powder as a flav...

Horrible banana shake with banana powder as a flavor not real banana like across the street. Husband ordered peanut butter which was also a fake flavored shake.
GO ACROSS THE STREET THEY'RE WAY BETTER

Stopped for an afternoon snack while visiting for ...

Stopped for an afternoon snack while visiting for a weekend. The raspberry shake was delicious, thought more like ice cream than a shake. Definitley can not drink with a straw, must use spoon. The fresh cut fries were so good with fry sauce. Though we had to wait an extremely long time for our orders.

3 stars based on their raspberry shake. This was t...

3 stars based on their raspberry shake. This was the first place we went to this weekend so having nothing to compare it to, we thought meh. Maybe raspberry shakes are just overrated. After trying others nearby it was clear their flavor just didnt match up. It was a Holiday weekend, but we waited more than 30 minutes just to get the shake after waiting almost that time to order.
We didnt try any food.

We came for some great raspberry shakes, and that'...

We came for some great raspberry shakes, and that's exactly what we got! I can't say anything about the food since we didn't eat there, but the shakes are worth getting. The staff was friendly, and although there was a line, it moved quickly.

Great kick back spot for food and shakes! Always a...

Great kick back spot for food and shakes! Always a treat to go here. If it is during the vacation season expect a wait, but it will be well worth your time. All the shake flavors are wonderful and the service is impeccable! Highly recommended!

Good

The only reason it s getting 2 stars and not one i...

The only reason it s getting 2 stars and not one is because the shake was pretty great.
There was only one person ahead of us in line and it took a good 20 minutes to get our food.
The burger my husband ordered was pitiful... thin slap of meat with barely melted cheese...mcdonalds quality at that... my BLT wasn t any better. $7 was not worth it for a pathetic sandwich and my bread was maybe toasted for 5 seconds... next time we re going across the street. Oh... and nobody got straws for their shake...

Place is very popular. It tastes amazing. Plan on ...

Place is very popular. It tastes amazing. Plan on waiting quite a while with how busy they are but it is well worth the wait. People will wait over an hour to get their shacks. If you have a chance you should stop but expect to wait a bit.

We got fries and shakes, they were good but I'm no...

We got fries and shakes, they were good but I'm not sure we'd go again. Almost an hour wait for 2 shakes and a large fry, and for $24... This place is pricey, slow, and mostly just hype. Order ahead or don't order at all.

I don't usually eat here, the fries are good thoug...

I don't usually eat here, the fries are good though. My main reason for coming here is for the raspberry shake. I think it's the best in Garden City! I can never come to Bear Lake without getting one from here!

I was pretty disappointed with my burger and shake...

I was pretty disappointed with my burger and shake. The "Bear lake monster" burger was just a regular burger with some provalone cheese on it. I didn't like it, but I had to wait a long time to get it so I had to finish it. The fries weren't that good either. Maybe they just weren't cooked properly, but they seemed a little too stale

Definitely disappointed. Went specifically to get...

Definitely disappointed. Went specifically to get a snickers shake because I got one there last week and its one of the only places with that shake flavor that I've found. Extremely pricey. We paid $8 for 1 large shake. Waites quite a while. and then when we finally got our shake ended up with a what we think was a cheesecake or something similar flavor. Definitely not a snickers shake

I ve had good experiences here, but after today I ...

I ve had good experiences here, but after today I don t think I ll be able to go back again. I got a raspberry shake as I normally do, but I came upon a chunk of peanut butter mixed into the middle of the shake. I m allergic to peanuts, but it takes a lot to set off my allergy. I thought it would be fine, but after 10 minutes I started having a serious reaction. Needless to say, not the way I wanted to end the day. I wish they were a little more careful and clean when mixing flavors, especially flavors with peanuts.