Pepperoni's Tavern Reviews

Good wings. Good service. Deco is a little dated, but very family friendly.

I ordered a large pepperoni pie which was a Little pricey, but good pizza nonetheless. The wait time for food was quick. The only turn off for me was the strong smell of cigarette smoke, They allow smoking after a certain time. Overall a good place for drinks and sports. For family not so much.

Got in town late and stopped for a quick bite. Pizza was excellent. Happened to be Karoke night so the entertainment was great too.

Good service, good food, I got the football game that was on.

Good spot for tasty bar food and drink specials with lots of giant TVs for the game!

Smoky terrace/patio, such a shame smokers and cigar lovers are allowed. Will never eat there for that reason.

Love the pizza! Sports bar decor, very casual and good place to watch the game.

Great karaoke! Nice bartenders! Best Jello shots! Pizza need some work...the crust was doughy...no seasoning! I'll visit again!

Best pizza I've ever had and very friendly staff that make you feel welcome the moment you walk in.

So mad. Stood there for 30 minutes before we even got to order, then wait 45 min for our food that was *wrong*. Service was awful, food was definitely not worth paying for and didnt even get the food we wasted our time on. In all honesty one star is to good for this place. Will never be back.

Always enjoy the pizza and the atmosphere . Great place!

Been coming here for over 10 years..... best pizza in Alpharetta hands down

Good staff, good patrons, and good food for a good time

Main kitchen closes at 10. Wings and pizza stop at 1am. Delicious food and super clean bathrooms.

Good pizza. The only thing is they only had one person attending the whole place, so service took a little longer than usual, but she was doing her best. It was past midnight though. Need an extra person helping her.

Good food and value. Only had the wings and salad but it was easy in and out. Friendly service too.

Cool place good bartenders and crowd.. Food also above average

The manicotti here is amazing. I ordered it and didn't expect it to be all that great because this place has more of a sports bar atmosphere and not an Italian restaurant atmosphere but I was blown away. We eat here at least once or twice a month. I'd definitely recommend trying it if you're ever there.

Pepperoni's has great pizza, but I was quite unhappy with something the last time I went to pick up our to-go order. I was a little early so I stood around and observed the kitchen. While there, I saw how the cooks managed their equipment and stations. One in particular was flipping a spatula and dropped it on the ground several times. I saw him run it under water for a second, but he continued doing so and dropped it more. I saw plenty of people handling food not wearing gloves and more. For this reason, we will not be returning. Even though we enjoy the food.

Also, to note, not all cooks were wearing masks. I can't recall if any of them were.

I hate to give a local place a bad review especially when we enjoy the food, but I wanted to share our experience. If we could trust a safe and clean experience we would definitely return.

Food was great. Staff was less than happy to see us? Weird cause I I m a customer.

Fantastic place, great pizza, and an amazing atmosphere to watch sporting events. You won't be disappointed at Pepperoni's. The owner, Phil, is a fantastic host and makes you feel welcomed.

The waitress has a bad attitude I felt a racial tone

Good Pizza and Wings also a friendly staff. However this restaurant can stand to be aired out a bit.

This place has such a fun atmosphere and very friendly servers. I have only been once but I felt at home here.

Great pizza place! They also have poker and ladies nights. Cool local hangout spot

Went out not knowing exactly what we wanted for dinner, so we chose Pepperoni's Tavern. The menu had a decent selection of bar / Italian food. We decided on the Pepperoni's Special pizza. Probably would have enjoyed it more but we prefer a thinner crust pizza. Sauce, toppings, etc were fine, but it was similar to a Pizza Hut pan pizza. Also ordered the Mac and cheese bites which were really tasty, and my daughter had the chicken tenders and fries which she enjoyed. I would go back and try something other than the pizza, but if you like a thicker crust, this may be for you. Service was good also (not too busy when we went).

Food was decent, customer service was lacking we sat at booth for at least 10 minutes without being acknowledged until my husband chased someone down.

Nice bar...super local on the weekdays as in even the people that work there...drink there.
The atmosphere is homely, food is average pub food, but they take pride in making sure it is correct. Drink special are decent. Maybe a happy hour during the weekday for food and dinner would draw a better crowd. Overall decent place.
BTW...not sure why the whole railing is there directly at the bar, it just kinda makes you feel further away and ' don't sit' vibe.

Sandwiches we're ok, but the pizza is really good. Service is great, friendly and very accommodating. Will definitely go back for the pizza!!

Fun pool hall type environment. I wish there was more than one pool table, but people are friendly and it isn't too busy.

The customer Service is amazing. We got a pizza that was just meaty and delicious on a cold night! :D

Customer service was great but drinks and food weren t anything to die for. Cool spot and open late tho

Went for lunch with Co workers. Took a little longer than expected for lunch. Everyone seemed to like it just fine.

I got a pepperoni slice and a cheese slice. It was good. Pizza is about one inch thick.

Love this neighborhood bar; decent selection of beers, yummy wings and pizza with big screen/TV. Great place to watch sports.

Not a fan of their food, but Great place to drink, watch sports, and play pool

We were excited to try this place - we are new to the area and the reviews looked good. We placed our order online and selected the delivery option associated with the restaurant.

After an hour wait, we called the location to inquire about the status of our order. Everyone seemed super confused, they said they didn t get an order and the don t do delivery (at least today)

The manager said he d make it right and bring the food himself. He said it would take 10 minutes - took closer to 20, but who s counting after you ve waited over an hour.

The pizza was ok - not bad, but no better than the chain guy s.

All we can tell you - DO NOT use the order online functionality for this restaurant. They obviously DO NOT check to see if they receive orders and apparently may or may not deliver.

Super frustrating - for the business - please don t use the services if you are not going to follow the system. Update your deliver times and availability.

This is NOT rocket science

I love the food and karaoke is so much fun!!! London is the best at DJing!!! Peps is great!!!

Good place to visit for late night food and drinks. Smoking is allowed after 12 AM mid night. Open until 2 AM. Very tasty pizza option for food after having some drinks. Inside casino make it even more happening place.

Loved this pizza since the early Duluth days. Phil and team still serve up great food. Try the meat lovers pizza. Best in Atlanta.

Great place to chill and eat. Attentive staff and very friendly. The food is actually very good and the pizza is great. You can watch all the sports and enjoy the beer too. I think the chef is exceptional if you are looking for something prepared to your exacting taste.

Late night stop for food. Hated to leave. The atmosphere was so friendly I wanted to stay longer. Great karaoke too.

The meatballs and marinara is absolutely delicious!

The salmon was great. I enjoyed the atmosphere. The server did really well. The manager, Matt C. MADE the experience. He knew the menu very well and helped guide us to the best food & was on point through out the night. We will definitely be back.
Thanks Pepperoni Tavern Team

Cool place for watching football and having a beer! Great bar food!

I had lost touch with Pepperonis for a few years after they moved to Alpharetta , to my surprise my son turned me to the new location which is only better with an updated Menu including burgers that are Unbelievable! I have sent in a suggestion for a visit from Burgers with Buck on Fox 5 and he confirmed he was putting them on the list!

Food was awful. Pasta was swimming in some watery liquid, mushrooms were store bought. Horrible!

Clean bar. Great pizza and wings. Friendly staff. Couple pool tables outside patio pet friendly. Great chill/hangout spot.

rough place. bartender girl tried to start a fight with me when I asked her not to serve my boyfriend anymore to drink. he had already fallen off the stool and was clearly drunk. she poured him a full glass if straight vodka and looked me right in the face as she gave it to him. he hadn't even ordered it. I went to management for help and to take that drink away from him. he told me it was fine and for me to leave if I didn't like it. I asked if he was going to be responsible for taking care of him. manager said no, that's your job. I was livid. I was not drinking and he told me maybe I should. never go there.

Always amazing food been going here for years. If getting pizza always get the parmesan crust and the great white pizza is fantastic!!

Great pizza. I got a small pepperoni, pineapple, olive, and it was delicious. Definitely will come here next time I come up.

Great Reuben, great atmosphere. I look forward to the wings next time!

The burgers are hands down awesome. The staff, awesome. Everyone had masks on.. there were touch less menus.. sanitizing stations.. the owner talked to me too much but he was super friendly. (I m joking! I love The owner Phil!)

I went to Pepperoni's last night. We have been going there for over 15 years. It is our favorite pizza place because of the quality and consistency. We have tried other pizza places, but continue to come back here We live 20 miles from the restaurant, but still make the trek, because to us it is the best. Phil, the owner, is very personable and has established a very consistent product.

I will say that to travel 20 miles through metro Atlanta traffic will tell you all you need to know about the pizza. Make sure you get the cheese loaf too. It is a staple order for us along with the pizza.

Margherita Pizza didn't taste like it's suppose to. It tasted like a thin crust pizza slightly burnt with some cheese. Two of the employees were messing around loudly, cursing and throwing drinks at each other. No professionalism whatsoever. The host was nice and the gentleman that made the Pizza seemed polite. Won't be returning, ever.

Looks were deceiving and the great atmosphere and friendly staff were a pleasant surprise. Plus the food is not bad either. I stopped by one night when they had karaoke and even though the acoustics are clearly not made for it the crowd was lively and participation was high. The bar also has a good beer selection.

Long wait to get beer or to get your check and to pay. So many places in the vicinity that want to serve you beer and get your buck...

Was there last night and the place is awesome. Its open late too, which is a plus for me. Wings are also off the chain!

Food is the best.The staff is very friendly.great service

Fun environment, cheap drinks, and incredible pizza

Still smells smoky inside but the pizzas are great and the service friendly.

First time I had their pizza (in July) it was fantastic. However, the second go-around I had 1 piece and had to throw the rest of the pizza away-- I ordered pick up around lunchtime on a Sunday and what I picked up was sooo greasy that bite after bite you could only feel your teeth coated and mouth flooded... the only positive the grease served was masking the taste of crispy blackened pizza. But hey, the salad was good...

Maybe this was an off day for Pepperoni's but the last pizza left a lovely scar in my mind so don't say I didn't warn you.

Pizza sluce for lunch was not good . too many herbs and tasted old.

Celebrated a friend's birthday here and it was FABULOUS! Pizza is excellent...very fresh and tasty! Highly recommend!

If you are looking for a bar that also serves pizza then you have come to the right place

You've got to go here. We were looking for a new pizza experience (yes it's a thing) and stumbled on Pepperoni's. We used to have this pizza joint up north when I was growing up, had the best tasting pie anywhere. Years later and never able to find another. Until this place. The pies are succulent, attractive and difficult to put down. Yes, we're talking about pizza here!! We haven't even tried other menu items yet, but will be soon. Go grab a Pepperoni's, you won't be disappointed.

nice local pub. Lots of beer selections and food that is above normal

Overpriced. But of course im hooked on the wings and the people are super friendly.

Its great the atmosphere was fantastic the staff was wonderful and the food was delicious don't miss out on this 1.

Loved this place ,,,pizza was surprisingly great ,,, can't wait to go back!!

The pizza here is excellent, and they have a full menu if you don't feel like pizza! The staff is friendly and it's even has games to play. The bar is a somewhat neighborhood hang out with a good selection of domestic and craft beers. Overall We've been there many times and I would suggest Pepperions to anyone