Penny's Pastries Reviews

Absolute Deliciousness!
My family has been purchasimg donuts here for over 40 years and the quality and taste is phenomenal.
I now bring my children here to continue on the tradition even though i now live a hour away!!

Their donuts are AWESOME!! And the staff is so friendly!

They have been a family staple for special occasions. We will always get a couple dozen doughnuts, and there are never any left! The Best doughnut in the state! It is a hidden gem, just miles away from Lancaster and Hocking hills state park!

They doughnuts are always good and fresh. I stop in often to get for my staff

Oh my goodness! These pastries are to die for! I used to go by all the time while playing Pokemon & remember the aroma would be throughout all of downtown! I was always back home by the time they actually opened though so I hadn't tried them! One dayI just happened to be up with only an hour to wait til they opened so I decided today was the day! It reminded me of 20 years ago & surprisingly their prices did too! Now, I'm hooked! If you're looking for pastries that remind you of your childhood, this is the place! I have & will definitely continue to recommend this place! You'll love it! Just try not to wait all day because they do sell out sometimes!

Small town bakery covers both traditional and local favorites. So much more authenticity than the run of the mill franchise "bakery". Also have day old pastries for the budget minded. All if it is sugary and super good. And super good value!

This place is the best pastry place in southeast Ohio!!! Very clean and organized! Very polite people that work there! Love the donuts!

Amazing Donuts and their Bread is delicious as well.

My wife and I celebrated our 4 year anniversary by starting with these donuts for breakfast. Cake donuts were not dry, filled donuts were filled with tasty goodness, and server was kind and helpful. Highly recommend. (Picture is of the donuts and cream puffs)

Selection was crazy. Four kinds of cookies and two pumpkin muffins. That was it. Walked in and walked back out.

So freaking good. Their Glazed and Cream Filled are the best.

It s impossible to actually manage to get donuts from this place. They are either closed when they are supposed to be open. Or they are out of fresh donuts early in the morning. However, they have great donuts when they are available. I m from Louisiana so I grew up around a lot of fresh donut shops. So I m impressed with theirs. It would just be nice to actually be able to get donuts for breakfast more often.

Always fresh and delicious pastries that are surprisingly reasonably priced.

I love these donuts. And the people are always nice to me. I'm a picky eater but I love donuts..

Best donuts around. Prices are way cheaper than others

I finally stopped there this week I have been driving past this bakery for years&Iam glad I did,IVE BEEN TWICE IN JUST ONE WEEK AWESOME PASTRIES &WORTH IT.I usually only go to Resch's Bakery in Columbus,Ohio which is the best HANDS DOWN

Best doughnuts in town! If you can catch them when they are open ! They have strange hours and run out of product quickly .

Great little pastry shop. The turn-over's were amazing!
The donuts were really good. Very friendly. Could use a little decorating but still clean little place.

Oh. My. Goodness. 1. The prices are awesome! 2. They have cinnamon rolls as big as a small child s head! 3. They are super friendly. I just had an oatmeal cookie for 50 cents that was amazing!!!! Not too sweet, not too crunchy or too chewy, just perfect. Definitely stop by Penny s when you are in the Hocking Hills area. For 104 years they have been baking up heavenly goodness! #shoplocal

A staple of Logan Ohio. Best cookies and donuts around!

Great pastries and donuts. Staff are amazing. Products are amazing.

All hand&homemade ingredients. Family owned local people.

Absolutely delicious! They have the best doughnuts & cinnamon rolls I have ever tasted! Also, the employees are very friendly! I think there are just two women (sisters?) that work there & they know what my usual is when I go in!

WARNING:
The pastries are SUPER ADDICTING!!! :)

TIPS:
They're closed every Sunday & Monday!
Try to make it there as early as possible cause they do sell out pretty quickly sometimes! :(

We didn't buy anything, but the prices are insanely low for the portion sizes you get!

Not much of a variety, few donuts to select from, day old donuts very stale, definetly not a day old.

I have been all over the US trying donuts but Penny's bakery in logan ohio has some of the best.

Best donuts I've ever had without a question. The custard filled and raspberry jelly filled are my favorites

They have the best thumb print cookies and of course the little cakes. Peanut butter chocolate is the best!!

Penny's white cake Is delicious! Picked one up this afternoon which she held for me after calling on a moments notice! Moist and wonderful! Great price too!

just stopped by and got half a dozen,these are great donuts!

Theres no describing , BEST IN THE WORLD! #SPLITTOPSARETHEBEST!!!

Cheap but for a good reason. I have eaten homemade bakery doughnuts my whole life. They are good even on day 3. So I don't know how the doughnuts and brownies I got were so dry and stale. Yuck.

This place has the best donuts in the state of Ohio

I m not usually from around here but decided to try out this place! If you ever had bills donuts from Centerville, you ll love this place! The donuts are amazing and the place is tiny. Definitely
Will have to come back!

I would have to say probably the best donut in Southeastern Ohio.. and with the best prices

The best donuts in the Hocking Hills. The staff are so helpful and can handle the huge line while being welcoming and answering any questions. Love. Them.

Deliciously Fattening LOL Split cream filled are amazing! Yummy stuff. Just be sure to take smaller bills with you as they don't take anything over a $20. Obviously they have been stung so I don't blame them, just be prepared.