Can a place be bad if it has "pie" in the name of the eatery? Obviously the answer is no, no it can't. Arriving at 11:45 for lunch was a really good idea. The place fills up quickly. Some outdoor seating is available. The staff were super friendly and the food just different enough that you feel you have eaten someplace out of the ordinary.
Overall, I really like this place. I am only giving it 3 stars, because I do think the prices for the whole pies are a bit much. The "per slice" price makes sense - averaging around $7-$8 a slice, and you're able to try different pies. However, I feel like having the whole-pies be about $40 for a 10" pie is a bit pricey, and I don't think I would buy this again.
Setting that aside, the flavors are great, and it's definitely high quality! It tasted fresh and flakey.
D to the LISH to all of US. I will definitely be returning. The Eli's BBQ pie is the bomb. Also, the desert honey vinegar is surprisingly good. And of course the dark chocolate pie is going to give me dreams of heaven
Old Bay potatoes and Dark Chocolate Pie: two of their best offerings, enough even for a meal. Oustanding as always.
What a great idea. Enjoyed our Shepherd's pie. One slight slight critique, too much mashed potato topping and not enough of the spectacular meat filling. Good individual portion size. For desert had the pecan and chocolate pie. Delicious. Healthy portions, almost couldn't finish them. Good size to share between 2 people
Absolutely love this place. They have delicious menu items that switch up periodically along with a few staples, my favorite are the empanadas. The atmosphere is great for smaller groups, counter service and a cozy cafe feel. I ve always found the staff to be lovely. My mom and I frequent this place and they re on DoorDash now!
There was a smell present...my food had already been ordered and paid for so there was no backing out now, otherwise the fresh reek of a meth goblin's underpants would have made me reconsider my choice in food this fine evening.
I locked eyes with the girl working the cash register. She knew what I knew...there was no hiding it...but by this point the social contract was in full effect and it became apparent we were both going to pretend that the assault on our nostrils was not taking place. Such is the dance.
"Your order is not quite ready yet" she said with a smile but oh I certainly heard what was really spoken in those words.
"You messed up sir. You could have eaten anywhere in this town but you chose the place with invisible sewage wafting through the vents...and now I'm going to make you wait in it, fatty. Breath deep, we'll just be back here taking our time on your order while you contemplate every mistake in your life that lead to this moment. Remember when you were still drinking and you drunkenly pooped yourself at work? Well that chicken has come to roost. Go ahead and run if you like...we have your money, you're really hungry, and we've got you over a barrel."
How I hated her in that moment. The fact that she too had to endure the stench did little to abate my malcontent.
"What could possibly salvage such an unfortunate turn of events?" You may ask. Well let me tell you...
The food was amazing...slap your mama across the face fantastic. I would trek through a thousand bogs filled with three times the smell just for one bite of their delicious pies.
I was wrong to hate the poor child. Unless she digested a rotting beef carcass, the smell could not have been her doing...I felt myself a fool.
Brave the stench, dear reader. Brave the stench and receive your reward. You've earned it.
Wow. Just, Wow. Excellent Pie restaurant! We were out celebrating Pi day and found this place on Google maps. This place is impressive. I am not a fan of crust but the crust here is amazing. Puff pastry like. Like, perfectly laminated. They make sweet pies and savory pies. I had the Aussie beef. It was out of this world. Perfect balance of meaty, salty sweetness. For dessert, we had a slice of Honey & Vinegar pie and a slice of Lemon pie with whipped cream. The Vinegar & Honey pie had some course salt on top that really help balance out the sweetness. We are definitely going to return here. Service was fast and polite. The place was very clean. Nothing to complain about here.
Amazing food! The staff was friendly and helpful with recommendations. I got the saag paneer pie and it was so tasty. It tasted just like I was at an Indian restaurant. They had ran out of the pie my husband had ordered but they recommended the Hiker's hand pie in place of it and it was very good as well. The pie crust was so flakey and delicious. Will definitely be going back to try more options.
The pies were amazing, but the staff was even better! I'll definitely be back!!!
opieo.com