Olivia's Ice Cream Cafe Review

My family and I drive 30 minutes to come here. Its the best ice cream around! Nice location and benches you can sit and relax. We love it!

Today I had the chocolate chip mint milk shake and it was absolutely amazing! Cute tiny place and great worker if your looking for good ice cream definitely go there!!! I live it! Thanks olivias ice cream!!

The ice cream is delicious, every flavor we've tried is delicious and creamy. Best ice cream around. The staff is always pleasant and friendly, and there are many different selections to choose from.

Great simple ice cream , I suggest the mix soft served

Icecream was ok ices was awful..maybe picked the wrong flavor but i did exchange for icecream at no charge..

This ice cream place is very good. Great service good location

Please update your hours online :( I thought you were open till 10PM, drove there, and you were closed.

Excellant tasting ice cream , the best by far , soft ice cream but a little over priced 2 small soft plain cones $8.00. (Were not down the shore) were in farm land

I didn't like it ... they don't have so many flavors either

I have been to this ice cream stand numerous times and the service is ALWAYS great and the quality and quantity excellent. I am almost two hours from this place and every time I m close I stop off just to come here.

Best ice cream I've had in this area (yes including the ice cream stores in Princeton!) The hard ice cream was creamy and not icy, (which I find is a problem lately at many ice cream shops.) I had hard ice cream Pumpkin Pie which had a full, delicious flavor better than pie! With that little spice, maybe cinnamon? And not too sweet. Also had one of the chocolates, which had a rich full flavor. My friend had soft and liked it. Dare I hope you are open all winter?

Raspberry chip was phenomenal. Very special,top notch ice cream.

Such a great ice cream shop! The flavors are delicious and the consistency of the ice cream is perfect.

Cute little local ice cream shop right off of route 33 in Millstone. Check the hours online, but drive up even if it appears to be closed! Nice flavor selection; decent prices; very pleasant service. CASH ONLY

My husband has been coming here since he was a kid and always raved about it. About 15 years later, now under the name Olivia s, he still raves about out! As do I! It s the BEST Ice cream around. In the summer we try and go as much as we can and always consider it a special treat!

Stopped for chocolate milkshakes, we all got sick. Never go there again

I love Olivia's Ice Cream! Their icea cream is super delicious and creamy, and did I mention that their Italian Ice is amazingly delicious as well?!

This is the O.G ice cream spot, been coming since I was a kid. Hard Strawberry or Vanilla/Choc swirl soft Allday

Delicious ice cream and the flying saucers are out of this world!! It is our go-to place for ice cream!

Cute little ice cream stand, the Sugar free cherry vanilla was DELICIOUS!

Long-time locals and New Hipsters swear by this place, but during our visit, tables were dirty, food seemed sub-par, and the vibe was less than welcoming. There's an old saying that the cleanliness of the bathrooms is a good indication of the cleanliness of a restaurant's kitchen; if that's the case, God help the good folks who are dining at Eats. Not recommended.

Olivia's has some of the best ice cream in the area. Great service and very friendly staff.
Enjoy

Going to Olivia's is a treat! Great service, delicious ice cream!

For the google reviewers past, present and forevermore, whomsoever giveth less than 5 stars , you have NO tastebuds and you think Baskin & Robbins is to die for. Olivia's has the best tasting ice cream ever, in the history of history.

Stopped by here yesterday on a whim. The nice lady there i'm assuming was the owner, told me the story about how this place has been in the family since the 1950s, founded by her aunt (Oliva?).

The soft serve is handmade by the owner and the hard ice cream is made by a local company not too far away. It's the real deal. Not many places still around like this. An American treasure.

Came upon Olivia s randomly and WOW what a treat it was! I am definitely well experienced in ice cream and...just wow...this was the best I have ever had. I had the peanut butter swirl in a waffle cone on my way home from a trip exploring Princeton and the Washington Crossing park. I will absolutely be back in the next few days. Incredible! And the service was so pleasant! This is truly a gem of a place and worth a 40 minute drive!!

Best ice cream I've had in a long time! My favorite is the pumpkin spice and the Strawberry. It tastes so fresh! Delicious!!!

Small off-the-road ice cream hut, known best for their homemade soft serve! Lovely owner & great rural neighborhood!

Great service. Ice cream is delicious. Wouldn t go any place else

Best Ice cream and the nicest people working there. Love this place.

I just had Olivia's ice cream for the first time today. I had the chocolate, vanilla, strawberry and the pumpkin. This ice cream was absolutely the best I have ever eaten before. It was worth the 40 minute ride.

Convenient to get there right off of 33 but softserve vanilla is too sweet and not firm enough. It's OK.

Really neat old school ice cream stand. Not the largest of buildings nor selection of ice cream but what they do have is great. This place reminds me of my childhood... good ice cream with no frills. Also, this is cash only so keep some money handy. Lastly, there is a nice little sitting area so you don't have to eat in your car. Please give them a try and support a locally owned business.

It's been a while for me... long overdue, happy I went back, super friendly young lady and as always amazing sundae

Daughter loved it. We have the cookies and cream ice cream with Oreo toppings.

Friendly as always, nice country home town feel, and great ice cream.