Next Door Pub & Pizzeria Reviews

Absolutely fantastic! Service and food were both great. The pizza was delicious and the pasta with Alfredo was also yummy!!! Close enough to Lake Geneva to be convenient but far enough not to be a tourist trap. We'll definitely be back.

Good food, great value, nice people! It was standing room only and we had to wait nearly an hour for a table for 2, but I understand why.

Awesome build your own pasta and the pizza plus the pub pretzel is pretty awesome and a sight to see and eat... Restaurant has gotten larger over the past twenty years but stayed true to awesome food and drinks

We love love LOVE NEXT Door Pub,,pizza is the BEST EVER ,,AND we always have a gr8 experience ,,then we go out to the new Emagine theatre right down the street and watch a gr8 movie,,I am a mom of 3 teenagers and this is always their favorite mom and kid date!!

Absolutely love the pub! Great food! Great service! Great atmosphere!

The best pizza, wings, and pastas in the area. Everything on the menu is excellent, It's hard to pick a favorite, even their salad dressings are amazing. There's a reason the place is always packed and if there ever is a wait, it's worth it. The parking lot is often full in front, there's a lot more spaces available in the back lot.

Pizza was surprisingly good. Service was pretty average, but no complaints on any of the food other than that they serve Pepsi.

We were very impressed and we are anxious to go back. This is a place the locals recommend. Known for thier Pizza, but we haven't tried it yet.

Great family restaurant! Great atmosphere and delicious food!

This is the first time me and my family visited the pub and pizzeria and it will definitely be our last time. The service is outrageously terrible and very slow. It took 30 minutes to receive two sandwiches and an appetizer. And yet, when we asked the waitress where it was, she just nodded and walked away. The food was cold. There were 5 to 6 wait staff and the whole entire time we were there, we did not see anybody smile. This is probably the worst pub in american history. I do not recommend this place nor would I ever want somebody to waste their time at this place. This is the first time I've never left a tip. If I read the previous reviews, I wouldve never stepped foot in the restaurant.

I love this place, great food, great service, good waitresses , and decent prices . I can see why it's busy whenever we come here

Pizza was amazing! We ordered a loaded pizza it was delicious! Sausage pieces were huge! Loved it!

Best pizza in lake geneva. You have to wait a very very very long time.

Good food and drinks and good service. Cheddar soup is so good.

Fun, lively atmosphere, great food, great prices, great service.

Pizza was good, atmosphere was upbeat and beer selection was very good. Service was a little on the slower side, but only because it was a busy night..we never saw any of the servers, bartenders or waitstaff standing still, they were always busy...

Great food, great service, unnecessary but fun live band. Definitely coming back

Went there to just get a bloody mary but had to try some of their food. We got their big pretzel (yum!) and boneless wings which were also pretty good. The bloody mary was really good except my only complaint was that there was no beef stick (instead there was salami) or a cheese stick, and the pickles were sliced pickles instead of a pickle spear. But there was a pepperoncini and an olive also. It was still really tasty and i will be coming back for more!

Food was great. Service was amazing. Always a wait to get in but that's because it's so good.
THE RIBS ARE A MUST TRY!!

Excellent pizza. Ate here recently after 11 years of not being in the neighborhood.

Pizza was so good! Service was friendly, we had 6 guests (mostly boys) bought 2 large and one medium and ate 2 1/2 pizzas haha

Very friendly busy place. We enjoyed the environment and the food

Food was OK. Had the cod. Nothing exciting but not bad. Meh.

This place is ALWAYS a Must Stop by after skiing. Great Food, Great Service!!

Beat food in southeast Wisconsin!
Bartender Eric Rude ROCKS!

The food was delicious and the waitress was the best.

The food is just horrible I ordered take out chicken rice soup for 3 and an Italian beef and a club sandwich the beef was burnt and so dry I had to drink a bottle of water just to get a bite down and the juice was so salty I thought I put my tongue in it ocean the club sandwich the bacon was disgusting and the meat was fake and the bread taste stale the soup was not normal chicken rice soup and paid $30.00 for that we ended up throwing it out never again gross

Excellent pizza. Fresh ingredients and a lot of them. Crust is crunchy; not too thick and not too thin. BIG menu with all types of cuisine. Daily specials and the prices are very reasonable. The bar is quite large and they pour a good drink.

Great Food, ordered 2 pizzas and they were done right on time and were delicious!

This place is worth any wait you may have! From the amazing food to the happy and helpful staff all around one of the best spots to grab a bite when in the area!

Great food and value. Always a fantastic family night out! Love the wasabi dressing.

Great place
Good food

We love there thin crust with cheese and sausage. Beware the Buffalo shrimp is super spicy.

Food is outstanding! Their pizza is most definately out of this world and worth a try. I highly reccomend checking this restaurant out if you're ever in the area of Lake Geneva!

ABSOLUTELY BEST ITALIAN BEEF this side of Maxwell Street in Chicago! Flavor is spot on - some places are either bland or way too much of one herb or another. Take out can have same wait time on weekends during peak season (Lake Geneva is a hot spot in summer) more tourists are finding out about the small places off the main drag that are THE BEST if ur a "FOODIE!" Pizza is BEST in town. There is no one with "Chicago's" pizzerias... But if you love "good tasting" and not skimpy with toppings - this is only spot in Lake Geneva or nearby towns that you will come back again & again for their pizza & Italian beef for real!! Cravings now talking about it!

I had lake perch it was awesome! Price was awesome also. Very fast and friendly also.

Steak sandwiches, burgers here are excellent, very reasonable. However the last 3 times we've gotten carryout our order has been either incorrect or incomplete. From no salads to missing sides, to onions on a burger when specifically requested no onions. We shouldn't have to reopen bags and boxes to check at the restaurant. They did five us a $2 credit one on a $28 order.Not sure it we'll be returning.

Very good food and excellent service. An extensive menu that has pizzas, burgers and other sandwiches, huge wraps, salads and soups to choose from. All with many options to make your meal the way want it. They also have available a build your own pasta dish to truly customize your meal. A large beer selection and full bar. The bar staff, wait staff and servers were all very friendly. Didn't wait long to be seated, to get my drink and food ordered, and the food arrived quite quickly. I highly recommend this place for your next meal outing.

The pizza isn't great, but pretty much everything else is!

This place has the best pizza! It will be busy at dinner time, but it s worth he wait. excellent service too!

Food tasted good, I am disappointed it came out cold.

Great food, friendly service, and amazing prices. Definitely will come back again when visiting Lake Geneva.

Excellent food,great customer service and inexpensive. Busy,popular place.

It is always nice when the bartender ignores you and doesn't serve you any additional drinks. Food was fine, service sucks! Typical Next Door Pub.

One of the biggest hidden off main Street gems in Lake Geneva. A must every time we visit.