Next Door Pub & Pizzeria Reviews

First time tonight....... hospitality was great, food was great (try the cucumber wasabi dressing!) and Linda our waitress was terrific! Everyone was pleasant and pitching in but I would ask for her if this is your first time too.

Bit pricey for a pizza joint! But the pizza is soooooo good!! Servers and bartenders are great, hosts seem to be on the b----y side.

Pizza is one of the best,,but be prepared to wait.always busy. Whether is dine in, pick up, or delivery,,,That's the price for greatness

After a long motorcycle ride in the heat arrived here because co-workers recommended. We sat at a table in the bar area and met Moses the bartender he was absolutely friendly and patient because I couldn't make up my mind what I wanted to eat! Very good drinks and the pizza was phenomenal! We also got garlic parmesan chicken wings and the Italian beef absolutely amazing! We will definitely be back!

Not from wisconsin. My friends and i got a pizza half sausage, tomato, and mushroom and the other half just cheese. I loved how it almost had extra cheese and it had overall great flavor. I thought the sausage was different though it kinda tasted like a meatball.

Service was good, had the burger special, burger was done as ordered, only disappointment was that the avocado used was not quite ripe enough.

Great local pub that's a little off the beaten path. Wings are perfect, nice and crispy with unique sauce options. Pizza is also delicious with that nice thick sheet of cheese you would expect from WI-style pizza. Everything was also reasonably priced for the quality - If you're trying to avoid tourist trap prices, take the short drive up to Interchange and check this spot out.

Great food, friendly service, large menu! Highly recommended.

Service is great! Friendly and prompt, you can tell it not "just a job" to them. The food? Amazing! The pizza is something you crave, look forward to all day for. Definitely a "go-to" spot!

The best pizza I've ever had...great customer service and fast service.. unfortunately the lemon cake was not a winner but that delicious pizza makes up for that 100 times over..

Great atmosphere, fantastic food - love their pizza, service staff top notch, delivery time was delayed.

Love every pizza (especially the new Maui wauwi) and couldn't ask for a better staff!! The new risotto bites were delicious!

Nothing but the best food here. Wisconsin cheddar soup was awesome. The ribs special they have on Thursday is quite nice. Some of the best ribs I've had! The shrimp in bourbon molasses sauce was awesome as well.

We give them a ton of business with carry out and entertaining out of towners because we truly like their food. Now to find out they are turning off the on line ordering option randomly because they get "too busy!" Between that and the limited menu at times tells me they need more staff if they want our continued business. Ridiculous...

Always great food, not a single bad item on the menu

Ordered for carry out. It was great. I wish I stuck around and ate there. Very welcoming and the pizza was some of the best I've had.

I call to order wings like normal and you tell me I can only order pizza. Very impressive next door pub what a joke.

Always a great place. Service and quality and locals. Great mix. Rarely ever disappoints.

always great with vet reasonable prices a good service

Food is outstanding!! Service is friendly!! Prices are right!! Best food in Lake Geneva!!

I have been a customer for 18 years basically since I was a waist high. I normally love next door pub pizza. However, the pizza I had tonight was like chewing on card board mixed with beef roast (advertised as steak), and brought it up to the wait staff that this is sub par. Heck we even tip the pan and water came running off the pizza, and charged full price. Being that the food was not measuring up to traditional or acceptable standard I doubt me and my friend will be dining at next door pub in the near future.

No burgers which was disappointing. Gourmet grill cheese was not gourmet at all. Meatball sub was good.

Probably won't go back as we are not from the area and would choose another place if out in Lake Geneva again.

The place was fill when we arrived but we got seated and had menus in 10 minutes. Appetizer up in less than 15. 3 alarm wings are Awesome! Meat Monster pizza is incredible. Probably the best crust I've had, great sauce, and toppings. The service is quick and very friendly. We'll be back soon

Great place for some ice cold beers and delicious pizza!

UPDATED 7/31/2018

This restaurant reigns supreme here in Lake Geneva. They beat every other restaurant in pricing and food quality. BE WARNED - their portion sizes are QUITE generous - an appetizer alone normally fills me up. I believe they've been in business for over 20 years and I can truly see why. Let this be the FIRST restaurant you try when visiting in Lake Geneva, be it delivery or an actual visit.

Don t recommend the fettuccine Alfredo. All they do is use regular spaghetti noodles. It seemed as if they poured the store bought Ragu Alfredo sauce and called it a meal. Not home made at all.It was horrid. Tasted bland and had no flavor. Noodles had a watery consistency. Chicken was grizzly could not eat any of it.Never again.

Awesome food and super friendly staff! We love to go there!

Ordered Pizza for the superbowl, they got great pizza, had a problem with the ice in my driveway and pizza got destroyed. Nate the driver was awesome showed up about an hour later with a new pizza. Great food and they care about their customers what more can u say.

We ordered curbside pickup during a fundraiser for school. Food was prepared on time and the server wore his mask correctly (+4 stars!) while brining my food. Stalls are clearly marked around back for pickup.

Food was still hot once we got it home so it wasn't sitting in the counter. Ribs were true fall off the bone and tasted great!

Excellent food at reasonable prices in a nice clean environment! What else do you want?

We have been going to Next Door for at least 15 years and NEVER had a bad meal, this is a great place.

The food was amazing and prices are sooo low for what you get. Parking is rough but the food and service was worth it!

My family really enjoys the pizza at Nextdoor Pub. (The Barbeque Pizza is a favorite of ours). The food is fantastic, the staff is very courteous and polite. The pick up area gets a little back up which can make you feel a little claustrophobic and in the way but overall a great place. Clean, tasty, and reasonably priced.

Good Pub. Great food and service! Many many options!

Fantastic food and service at the lovely restaurant. Despite it being busy, we were seen quickly and visited regularly to check we had all we needed. Prices were reasonable. I'd definitely go back.

Service was excellent staff was always hustling food was out of this world.
Baked seafood dip is better than spinach artichoke.

Sour cream
Cream cheese
Parmesan cheese
Crab & shrimp

Serve with pita chips

Food is always fresh and delicious. Beer is always cold. Great place to watch a game or just enjoy a great meal.

Very good food and great service. Their prices are really good for the fantastic quality of food, you won't be disappointed.

Ehhhh.. food was ok. Loud atmosphere. Expected more out of it though.

best food and best service ever my favorite place to go awesome place

Great service..fun atmosphere..and most of all amazing food!

Fun, casual establishment! Got there just before 6 on a Friday night, place was packed. Told our wait would be about 45 minutes. Lucky enough to snag a seat at the (also jam-packed) bar after a short time. Service was quick and friendly. Cucumber Wasabi Ranch salad dressing was outstanding! Just enough kick. The one-pound pretzel was delicious alone; their Octoberfest mustard was sinus-clearing but delicious. The North Shore pizza was also flavorful, but I missed the pizza sauce (comes without). My wife liked it just the way it was. We had a great time! Will definitely return.

Visit this place whenever we're in town. Highly recommend to anyone that wants good food, especially pizza & wings. Just be prepared to wait.

I had a really very good time at this joint. The food was great-they got good drink specials too I was very satisfied. Me and my two buddies had to wait a bit to get seated which is understandable they were busy! I can see why they were the food was great-we got some drinks while we waited and the bar is great. Anyway we got some pizza and cheesy bread-the cheesy bread is lit. Really tasty. I ordered more and almost didn't have enough room food for pizza between all the cheesy bread and beer. All in all great time. I'll recommend this place to anyway in Walworth county who asks! I gotta go back again.

The Pub is my go to place!! Always great food, great atmosphere, bartenders, and great service!!

Amazing Food! Great Staff & Service. You have to check this place out. Cheesy Garlic Bread & Burgers

Been going here for at least 25 years. All the food I'd great, but I always get the pizza

Great timely service, tasty pizza and Italian beef topped off with delicious raspberry cake! I will be back for more!

We had the lasagna it was very good. Waitstaff was great. Would recommend this place to others.

Almost always have a great experience. Except this time. We waited over 30 mins for our dinner and this is after we had our appetizers and salad. Now min you when I get my food it is FULL of oil and the rest of the tables food is cold. Now to add the icing to the cake. We had 2 tables sit order and leave while we are still waiting. The first excuse i get is they had pizza it does cook faster. Okay sure it cooks faster but not in 5 mins.
Then when we finally speak to a manager I'm told its I'm sorry but it's busy.. REALLY it's busy that's your excuse. I was there before "dinner time" and it wasn't busy at all. You had 1 group waiting and not to mention you are a popular resteraunt you should be use to being busy. It sucks cause we liked that place a Lot. But excuses like that make us not wanting to return.

Disappointed in the Pub Popper burger I had. Must be that all burgers are cooked to one temperature...well done...because my server never asked how it should be cooked and it was dry and not at all flavorful. Not what I would have expected from a custom blend of beef cuts as described on the menu.

They have a lot of fun cocktails, great pizza, and other items on the menu are delicious too. Warm and welcoming atmosphere.

REALLY good place for service and great food prices are great as well can't recommend enough, thanks

Always packed!!! Go see why!!! Love the mango habanero wings!!! THEY ARE RIGHT THERE!!!! Best Za in these here parts!!!

My husband and I drive almost an hour for their pizza. And as always, top notch service