Next Door Pub & Pizzeria Reviews

Best restaurant crew in LG. Always great food and service regardless of time of day or wait.

What a hidden gem. This feels like a local eatery and watering hole. Extensive menu, spacious seating, attentive wait staff, good food. Be sure to eat here at least once in your trip.

Good food, good drinks and good service. Everything you'd want in a pub and pizzarea.

Went here for dinner our first night in town and were very impressed!!! Had to wait for a bit because the place was packed, but totally worth it! Service was great even thought they had their hands full, and the food was amazing!! Overall, great service, prices, and food. Back again today for lunch!

Burgers are the best thing to get here, for me. Didnt eat any of the chicken parmesan. Maybe it was an off day but we didnt get it hot. Burgers get 5 stars.

Best freaking homemade food!! Fish tacos are amazing !! Ribs ! Mac and cheese pizza!!

Good restaurant with friendly staff. Food is good. I'm just from Chicago so I'm holding out on that 5th star .

They offer a surprisingly extensive list of cocktails like various martinis, mules and multiple variations of Long Islands for $6!
The food is tasty, our server was friendly efficient, informative and really added to my positive sense of visiting! Wish I recalled her name for deserved kudos.
My only request is the lack of healthy options besides salads. Then being charged an extra $1 for a gluten free bun option.
I will be more likely to visit again based on how nicely the staff treated us!

Wonderful service and outstanding food at affordable prices. We loved it and will totally be back!

My family had the chicken parmesan sandwich, the chicken salad sandwich on garlic bread, pepperoni pizza & cheese curds. ALL were Delicious Great service, friendly staff & great prices!

Had the brisket bread bowl, was not a fan. It tasted like a pot roast on pizza, not brisket. Flavor was to bland.

Good family friendly place to eat. Food was delicious. Glad we found them while visiting.

The food is amazing. It's family friendly, it's very affordable and it the best food Lake Geneva. The servers and staff are very friendly. I highly recommend.

So dependable. great red and white tablecloth Italian. They seamlessly move a multitude of diners happily along their journey to satisfaction.

My experience,we went there for years and really liked it, then one afternoon I went there alone and was so badly humiliated by Moses, wrote both owners to tell of the experience, never received a reply. Haven't been there since. My husbands friend visited yesterday and always liked it, so they went. My husband did not mention my experience to him. The hostess was so rude to both of them, that they said they would never go back. They obviously don't care since they have plenty of business and good food, but we won't go back.

They only deliver at certain times i called to order a pizza and they said sorry we're not delivering at this time which was 5:00 p.m.?? Very unprofessional phone service the person taking my order wasn't polite by any means very rude. And the thing that really irritated me was finally at 8:00 p.m. we got our pizza and it was beyond burnt. We tried to get a replacement and the manager wasn't available to speak as he wasn't there at that moment. Do yourself a favor save your money and go somewhere were your actually respected as a customer.

Sincerely, Joshua

We had good food and great service. It was a busy Friday lunch, but everything went smoothly.

What's not to love! Food is yummy, kid friendly, great staff and decent wait times

Great food. Great pizza and great service! In town visiting family and had a delicious experience. The cheeseburger in paradise was definitely a favorite along with the maui waui which had jalapeno and pineapples. The garbage pizza was good as well though I thought it had a little too much sauce. Also ordered a 1lb Bavarian pretzel which was soft and came with 3 different dipping sauces. Definitely recommend this place!

Best pizza and wings in town! We always enjoy eating in or taking out. It can be busy especially on the weekends so make sure you take that into account. Otherwise the place is great.

They have really good food. I would recommend this place to anybody. The locals come here often, that says a lot about a place

If you are a fan of Garbage pizza you have to try this place! I have had several people recommend trying Next Door Pubs garbage pizza so I got a personal garbage pizza for carry out. Appearance of the restaurant was clean, and inviting a typical pub pizzeria atmosphere. Front desk/register person was friendly and quick to help. All in all store experience was very good and I assume it would be a nice place to dine in. As far as the pizza everything was perfect I loved the sauce (and they give the perfect amount of you like alot of sauce), the cheese and sausage were both very good, but the thing that really won me over was how perfectly cooked the pizza was cheese was nice and melted and the onion and green pepper were cooked but still slightly crunchy. The pizza was absolutely wonderful and has made this my new favorite pizza place.

A lot of places claim to make the "best pizza". This place truly does and that's from somebody that is not a big pizza fan to begin with. The ingredients are stellar, the composition of each of their pizzas flawless. And Next Door Pub is not skimping on the toppings. I can highly recommend (and have) their pizza. Best pizza ever. Oh and while you are there, try the wings also. Fantastic.

I have been coming to Next Door Pub since I was a small child. The food is amazing and the staff are outstanding. Definitely a place you should check out while in Lake Geneva.

Just a tavern for regulars but the pizza is fantastic

Had the buffalo (level 1) wings and garlic Parmesan for carry out. Good enough because I was hungry but wouldn t order again

Great food, great portions and great service. My girlfriend and I loved it here and plan on returning.

One of my favorite places to go for a great burger or awesome Pizza. Their large Italian salad is plenty for sharing or to have delicious leftovers. The meal choices give agreat Wisconsin taste experience. The also have a very nice beer menu. Highly recommended local favorite

So I swung buy on a wim and had the piggy stardust. Best pulled pork sandwich I have ever had and I have had a lot of pulled pork in my life. The wait was kind of long but nothing to concern yourself if you are a true foodie

Excellent food and great service! Reasonably priced and a must stop if you're in the area. Can't say enough about this restaurant!!

Great variety of unique and original Pub food. Wings are fantastic. Generous portions and a 5 minute drive from TimberRidge lodge.

Nick at the bar was awesome and very good at what he does and very polite and a very happy server and a good bartender . Awesome food and awesome drinks and very reasonable prices

Parking for handicap was horrible. We parked in designated spot. It had a bad slop. Ramp went down from side of car and I attempted to wheel my chair down. Too steep, chair slid and hit side of ramp. Fell over and myself and chair hit the ground...parking lot. Couldn't get back in chair. Delivery boy helped me. Dirt all over clothes, glasses bent and wrist sprained. I was lucky.

Was just there this afternoon our server was excellent. I ordered the Brisket bread bowl which isn't always available and it was something I would definitely get again
Their food is always awesome

Still the greatest pizza in all of Walworth County. The outdoor seating now offered is also really nice, especially in these times. You'd be hard pressed to find a single bad item on the menu, but the standout is the Garbage Pizza, and their wings!

Awesome food. It can get busy, but worth the wait
.

Great pizza and pastas, mac 'n cheese pizza, raviolis and eggplant parmesan delicious. Reasonable prices, good service

Service in bar was exceptional. Restaurant was below par. Never had service. We left. Won't go back. Don't have enough help. Too bad.

Great pizza and reasonably priced drinks. Just expect a short wait time during weekends

Great home made garlic bread and pizza. Awesome bar drinks

Food always Delicious I ordered the cheeseburger in Paradise pizza it was DELICIOUS!

Food was great. Had the cheeseburger pizza and homemade chips. Bartenders were great!

Great place, food is really good but almost always too busy. Not worth the wait for me.

Excellent food, staff, prices, we go their all the time,,

Pasta Monday's is a great deal. Sat at the bar had a great experience.

Love Next Door Pub! The food is always fantastic and the service both in the restaurant and bar is excellent.

Great food, staff, prices, and live entertainment in the awesome bar WITH a connected smoking room!!!

Great food. Love their pozza and chicken wings. Always packed.

They have good unique burger options. Very noisy when busy might not be best place for a first date hard to have a conversation when busy.

Best pizza around I have been a customer for over 18 yrs BEST pizza,around.rest of food ok great service