New Arthur's Supper Club Reviews

Amazing service great hot food. Amazing bread and butter. They definitely feed you here. All reasonably priced. Cheese curds are so perfect!

Mixed review. Multiple visits, generally very good. Recently went for all you can eat prime rib. Was happy to wait an hour in the bar (fantastic bartender), but once seated service was a struggle. Waited an hour for prime rib and salmon, and then was informed they had ran out of prime rib after several very small cuts. Definitely ate less than a king cut, still charged for all you can eat. Prime rib was great, hopefully they can better predict demand in the future.

The food was excellent. Service was mediocre because we hardly got checked on but it could be worse. Overall, I'd definitely come back

Good supper club. I appreciate their efforts during covid. They do their best to be safe without feeling too restrictive.

This steak restaurant is decorated whimsically with tapestries, waterfalls, and murals of Camelot. When I went with my husband, mother-in-law, and toddler, the place was nearly empty. It was a Tuesday night. The service was excellent, as was the food. The prices were fairly high, but it was worth it for such a pleasant experience.

Food was amazing, servive impeccable, our bartender (think her name was Maddie) makes astounding long island ice teas

Loved the low lighting, but could use an update. Service was good. Checked in often. Unfortunately, the food was very lacking. Nothing tasted fresh. Pasta overcooked and I do not think the alfredo sauce was made in house. Salad was limp and dry. They comped the alfredo, so I am happy about that. I feel like this could be a great place with some revamping of the menu. Food was boring and under seasoned.

The New York Strip and King Prime Rib were amazing! The bread was great! The cheese curds were very good! Laura, our server, was very up beat, friendly and provided great service!!! The sweet old fashioned was also tasty!

The place offers a vast variety of delicious food. I love eating here. The employees are always friendly, rates are reasonable and the place is always neat.