Mikey Likes It Ice Cream Reviews

Good place but lacking in chocolate flavors. Service is very slow.

Mike is an amazing guy who makes amazing ice cream. There is always something new to try with some old favorites mixed in the bunch. If you're looking for gormet ice cream look no further, this is the spot for you!

Nice little Hideaway place but you gotta go there cuz ice cream is very very good it's a little pricey but it's worth the price and it's hidden away so I say give this place a great stop by at least if you're in New York City at least one suspect in the area of Avenue a and 12th Street side yeah definitely give that place a shot

Had the peanut chew milkshake and it was a lovely experience, no chewing str8 sipping

The flavors here are amazing and the service is even better! Definitely a spot to pass by and Mikey is incredibly kind. Support your local businesses!

There's more than meets the eye at this tiny blue-and-white ice-cream shop. The homemade flavors are delicious and come in wild combinations: balsamic macerated strawberries with black pepper or banana ice cream with chocolate-covered peanuts. Founder and owner Mike Cole's inspirational story makes the hip-hop-inspired ice cream all the sweeter.

Mike is a man of integrity who cares about his community. Ice cream is on point. Support local! Much love!

Place is ok! Seems like an upscale Johnny Rockets! I ordered the Fenton Club, it literally had one piece of ham and turkey! I thought it would be loaded with meat. The ice cream is ok. I been wanting to come here to see what the rave was about.

If Mikey likes it, I like it!

The ice cream was delicious and Mikey is super friendly. Can't recommend this place enough!

The Ice Cream was amazing here, satisfied my wife's 1AM ice cream craving when she was pregnant. We went back yesterday for Ice Cream and it appears the business has been seized by New York State. I hope it comes back soon.

Great ice cream choices, the woman on staff was very helpful and friendly.

Kind of a hip hop theme going, which is awesome. I'm not cool enough for a place like this but they took care of me anyway. Great flavors in the ice cream and a fresh waffle makes it heavenly.

OMG! Ice cream is so delicious add the red velvet waffle and mmmm.... The staff was nice and helpful. He let me try EVERY flavor before I decided..

This ice cream was beyond delicious even though he was closed he still blessed with a marvelous pink treat five stars all the way

Small shop with creative and delicious ice creams.

The ice cream generally has certain things mixed in and preset combos.

Worth stopping by after eating at one the areas many options.

$4.50 for a single scoop in a cup
$8 for a shake

A cool small space but cranks out delicious ice cream flavors/combos including a signature classic vanilla, shakes, ice cream sandwiches and waffles. The service is friendly and the music is on point.

Ordered a single scoop vanilla which was deliciously classic. Creamy and had a slight whipped malt flavor - very nice.

My friend got a chocolate shake which is also good and creamy but not heavy just rich.

Definitely coming back for other flavors.

This the the best ice cream I've ever had in my life. How do they make it so good?!? We ordered some pints for delivery. They had car trouble, so our delivery was two days late - but it was totally worth the wait! I'm ordering more all ready. We got Truffle Shuffle, Jack and Jill, and Southern Hospitality. I can't pick a favorite they are all too good.

All I know is that the Ice cream here is absolutely amazing! and you get to meet the man (Mikey) behind the flavors.
The new flavor that Mikey has out in collaboration with rapper POUNDS448
the all new
VEGAN TIRAMISU ICE CREAM is a hit
Come and check it out for yourself!

Decent Icecream. But the counter guy wanted me to wait for change and I had to wait more than 5 min in to-go icecream place. When I went back for ask change, he even said you didn t paid. So I had to explaind what he said to me 5min ago. Such a bad experience. They shouldn t make a business like that. Definitey hate it.

EXTREMELY GOOD. NICE POLICE CURTIUS SERVICE. WILL GO BACK AGAIN. HE GIVES BACK TO THE COMMUNITY. GOD BLESS HIM.

Omg I haven't been here in over a year but so miss this place
1. The service is good efficient and quick. I love the texture of tge red velvet waffle it holds up to the ice cream perfectly

I love love love the ice cream I still can't believe that the cookies and cream is non dairy absolutely delicious and the owner Mikey the owner is very personable and kind. Many blessings to this business to be around forever in the community!

Homemade ice cream by Mikey himself, who's a really cool guy by the way! He's got a big heart, loves his community, and has a great story - chat with him if he's there when you stop by! Every flavor is amazing!!

You do not pass straight when you hunt one attraction after the other in New York - but this little detour is definitely worth it: the ice cream is just awesome ...

I don't get to go here often, but whenever I do, I'm always impressed by the different ice cream flavor concoctions! The last time I went, I had the Facts of Life and it was delicious. I also love supporting my friends businesses whenever I can. Mikey's is always worth the trip

The icecream tastes really good and great customer service. The only thing is the place is small.

Love bit...found it at Patchogue im going to be the client number one..love it

Really nice local place. Mikey was outside and talking with customers. A line out the door made sense because the ice cream was so good. It s not cheap but nice to support what they got going on. Check it out! Super cool flavor combos and everything is fresh

Truly amazing Ice cream. & the staff is super friendly !!! 11/10

A little on the pricey side, but pretty good ice cream.

Worlds greatest ice cream by the very BEST to do it... @Mikeylikesit

Super nice folks. Ice cream is good and the waffles are banging.

Great product and small business that gives back to the community.

O.m.g. the diet will have to wait because we're definitely coming back to try all the other flavours. Dough Boy already was an ice cream connoisseur's dream. Definitely go there when you want great american ice cream.

The most creative and delicious ice cream I ever had in my life . Celebration of the pop culture . open late night. Wonderful service.

I had the vanilla and pralines ice cream on a red velvet waffle excellent!

One of the best Ice Creams I have ever had. Creative flavors served always by friendly staff. A great date spot.

Fire ice cream and great waffles. Staff was also very nice.

A fantastic scoop worth the trip to alphabet city. Try the waffle sandwich, amazing!

My favorite ice cream spot. Always friendly and the flavors are unique.

Fantastic service and variety of flavors. Everything tasted pretty good but at $9 for 2 scoops it is a tough treat to justify for the ice cream alone. Will definitely come back and try the waffle sandwich though

No frills but lots of flava" ice cream shop in LES.
The ice cream is soo EXCELLENT. My favorite is the Foxy Brown which is mocha ice cream with salted caramel and crushed oreos. You have the choice of scoops, mac daddy, shakes and sundaes.
I chose the mac daddy-red velvet which is your ice cream sandwiched by half a red velvet waffle. Made to order, fresh hot waffles by the way.
I also love the fact that the workers have the old school ice cream parlour outfit and the place is super clean. Whenever I'm in the LES, I will definitely stop here for some ice cream.

Great service. Got the southern hospitality ice cream and it was really good. Taste EXACTLY like honey Teddy Grams.

Delicious and interesting flavors, with varieties of waffles that make this place worth an inebriated visit.

Inspired flavors, absolutely delicious ice cream, very chill vibe. Tell your friends!

Ive never had it I live on the west cost.but its not as good as reids dairy I can all ready tell

Great flavors and great service! The best ice cream shop in NYC!

Terrible service!! I placed an order on 9/22 for local delivery to be sent to my little cousin for her birthday and she never received it. The next day I realized I didn t get a delivery confirmation so I contacted them via email and didn t hear back. On 9/24 I called and was told they were very backed up and my order would go out for delivery that Sunday. It was ridiculous for a food order but I wanted to be understanding and support a small business. That Saturday I received a call and text telling me my order was being delivered and to meet them downstairs. I called back and explained that the order was for a family member and I provided the code they needed to ring the apt. I figured they were able to deliver it but to be sure I texted my cousin asking if she received it and she said no. I call back MLI and the woman on the phone tells me my order wasn t in the bag and that my order was delivered the day before which was totally incorrect because I already asked my cousin if she received the order and she said no. I asked the woman to cancel my order and to have her boss call me and she said she would but I never got a call or a refund. I ve spent so much time trying to get my order that I ve given up. The sad thing is I really liked their ice cream and I try to support small businesses but they re customer service and delivery is awful. I wouldn t recommend them.

The ice cream is amazing and they have unique flavors, but they are always out of at least some of them (sometimes up to half of the total flavors). The last time I went they didn't have vanilla.

If you don't mind that your options might be limited, it's definitely worth it for great ice cream.

I really liked the ice cream at this place and it's one of my favorite ice cream places i have ever been to.

Food was so tasty. The service was helpful and kind. This place has a nice atmosphere. Menu is similar to a restaurant in Jacksonville I liked.

Very good ice cream and huge balls, but I picked vanilla ice cream which is not the greatest next time Ill make sure I try something else.

Absolutely delectable flavors, great atmosphere and friendly staff. My kids and I love it here!

Interesting choice of flavors and the ice cream tastes amazing!

Choices are few and flavors are a bit weird. My wife liked it, but I would try some of the other spots nearby.

Extremely slow service and inattentive staff. Most flavors not good. The good flavors are out by the time it's dessert. Be prepared for a long wait for mediocre ice cream.

Incredibly friendly and quick! Let us try a ton of flavors. The ice cream is amazing and the flavors are super creative. Also, the design is really cool. Definitely coming back!

Love the Butter Pecan flavor oozing with candied pecan overload.

$$
There ice cream so great, so much flavor .Please add waffle to your ice cream it's not complete without it . It's open late and it won't disappoint.

I stopped by Mikey Likes It Ice Creamduring a food walking tour and enjoyed the iIce Cream. The atmosphere is retro and a nice change of pace.

I am an ice cream connoisseur and this place is top notch! I ve been here twice in the last two days. The ice cream is smooth and creamy. The flavors are creative but not too crazy. I loved the hint of salt that balances the sweetness of the mix-ins. We liked this better than ample hills. Mikey likes it and so do I!

Great Ice cream! I Had a plain waffle with Pink Floyd and Dough boy! The pink floyd ice cream has cheese cake chunks inside of it and is has a very rich taste. The waffle is made to order and served warm and slightly crispy. They guy behind the counter and very nice! You can also order root beer floats and milk shakes. Check out the celebrity clocks on the wall, they're pretty cool!!!!