McNally's Irish Pub Review

My husband's birthday, the food and service was excellent! We love this place.

Excellent service and excellent atmosphere. I suggest trying the nachos

I payed 30 dollars for two appetizers... Thats kind of ridiculous.

Great food and service at the outside bar but you've got to do something about the Flies and the bees

Service was fantastic! Ask to be served by a guy named David. He'll get you what you need!

Absolutely the best! Every time we come to Sioux Falls we come here once or twice before continuing on our trip. Just love this place.

Great food and even better customer service. A Dublin Ice Tea along with their Irish BLT Se my favorite

I had the steak! It was WONDERFUL! The service was excellent. The atmosphere is that of an Irish pub.

They know how to pour a Guinness. Always attentive cheery staff

Haven't found a bad meal yet. Try the Crispin/Guinness mix.

Live music and a roaring fire make this an awesome pub

Quick trip in and out on way to Aberdeen, SD. Marvelous atmosphere, great Guiness draw, and wonderful food. Just right for those with an Irish palate!

My absolute favorite pub! The atmosphere is perfect and has a wonderful Irish feel. The staff is always friendly, the bartenders are crazy knowledgeable and the food is awesome! Have you ever tried muscles? I would highly recommend McNally's!

Awesome service, and a fantastic Rubin Sandwich. I will be back!

Not great service. Food wasn't good (philly cheese)

Great 2 for 1 burger special on Tuesdays!!! Good Burger! !

Good spot. Atmosphere, pub food, drinks are all solid. Don t order a White Russian though. They don t have a clue. Haha

Wonderful atmosphere, good food at reasonable prices.

Great place for a quick lunch. Sandwiches were yummy and a perfect size. Server (Sarah) was very good and super polite.

Fun atmosphere, good background music, and quick staff!

Great Irish atmosphere. Best Rueben is town. Leek soup is great. Nice selection of boutique beer and Irish whiskey. Service has been up beat and prompt.

This is a pretty nice place. The food is better than bar food, but not as good as a typical restaurant. The beer selection is good enough that you should find something decent. The service, the food, and everything else about this place are pretty decent. The place itself has a very cozy and relaxed feel. It's a place where you can enjoy a nice relaxed date in front of a cozy fire over a cup of spiked mocha ... depending on the time, of course.

We arrived not knowing if we seat ourselves. We sat ourselves and removed a chair, for wheelchair access, not knowing where to put it. Curious as to why the place had so few people on a Sunday at supper time, I eventually realized why. My cocktail was watered down. I could hardly taste the monkey 47 gin. The deviled eggs were tiny but the filling was good. We were charged eight bucks for three eggs when the menu said seven. We didn't say anything about it. My reuben was what appeared to be a lunch portion. I left wanting something more, but from somewhere else. The steak tips were cooked properly but from a very tough cut of meat. The server was alright, wouldn't have minded faster table service but it appeared she was the only server. FYI, throwing dried paprika and chives on everything doesn't make a fancier meal.

I'm a little concerned about how you're handling the covid 19
I've been to a couple breweries in town that have taken the situation much more seriously
I would like to see you clean the tables and chairs much more thoroughly

PARENTS TAKE NOTE: Children aren t allowed in McNally s on any day but Sunday despite being a pub and grill.

To be fair to this establishment, we have no idea how the food or service was as we weren t allowed in with our 8 year old on a Saturday afternoon. (If there was an information section that didn t require star ratings I would put this there instead). Parents just take note before driving across town for lunch if it s not Sunday.

5 STARS is my rating.

Real Irish menu.

I had the Bangers & Mashed.... perfection.

See the menu for excellent selections. Kitchen until 10, bar til midnight.

Indoor and outdoor bar/ dining.

Look no further... press the 'directions' button now.

It's kind of tucked away in a strip mall so plenty of parking, all service staff were enjoyable to talk to, and it does have a small slot machine room on the way to the restrooms.

Not pictured but also got steak tips, those were very good!

Solid 4 out 5 stars, food wasnt jump off the plate amazing, but very good along with the service. Would recommend for a relaxed lunch / dinner / drink.

Best local bar in the area! Great service, delicious food and wonderful atmosphere.

Nice casual atmosphere, and service has always been average to great. No complaints, and a great place to grab a drink and some food

Good food, good drinks, good service nice atmosphere with a big fireplace

Always great food and drinks, and amazing staff. Service is a little slow, and prices are on the high side.

AWESOME customer service and food. Excellent environment!

Bread pudding was excellent! 5 bagpipes might be a little too much inside. Emma is a great server!

One of my favorite Irish pubs in the country - excellent wait staff, limited menu but great mussels and pub chips for appetizers.

A wonderful meal and we met many new friends at Pups and Pints.

Great strawberry salad with a small piece of grilled salmon. Really good ice tea. No refills on tea or water. I did enjoy the music and copper ceiling. Service questionable.

Great music outside in the patio area. Was very comfortable. Service was great.

Great food, excellent service! Enjoyed the setting.

I travel to Sioux Falls a few times a year for business and always stop in for at least one meal. The food is sooo good. The decent beer selection helps with washing down the rib tips I love so much. A little hard to find first time there but worth it when you do eventually find it.

Awesome food. Great drinks. Always good time. Expect to spend a little more here vs other places, but you won't be disappointed.

Really loved the meatloaf! The service was also very good.

Great food and selection of brews - comfortable atmosphere.

Get a Dublin Tea. Also, love the live music on the patio.

Always a neat place, pricey, but they have live music every time I've been there. The staff is always super nice and helpful and the food is always on point!

I went. I got drunk. Drinks were delicious. Waiter was awesome. But said

Great atmosphere & good food. We always enjoy our visits here.

Great atmosphere & great food. Wonderful happy hour.

We love McNally's! The best Irish pub around, without a doubt!

We had a great experience on the patio...the food and service were great!

Had the Ruben and potato salad both time I've been there. The service is very good,the potato salad also very good,the sandwich,while very tasty is sloppily put together and that's the reason for four stars instead of five.

The BEST Bloody Mary's in town!! The meatloaf is amazing too!

Great atmosphere love the outdoor bar the service was amazing was an awesome place to go give that a 10

Josh quite possibly makes the best old fashioned in the entire city of Sioux Falls. Highly recommend!

Quiet trendy atmosphere.
Attentive servers!

Sat on the covered patio. Service was excellent and food is always outstanding. Save room for the bread pudding!

Friendly, well-kept neighborhood bar. Laid-back atmosphere.

Great selection of beers.
Alli is a great waitress

Great food , Awesome staff the owner is generally around keeping the experience top notch.