Lost River Pizza Co. Review

Great play to hang with family and friends! Great Pizza! Friendly staff!

The deep dish pizza was like a bowl of pizza soup. Digiorno has better deep dish for a third of the price

Maybe it was just a bad night for staffing. The waiter was not very friendly.

Great pizza! Was super busy so staff was not as attentive as they could be.

The saltiest burger I've ever been served. Messed up both our burger orders. If it's called a fried green tomato burger, put a fried green tomato on it. Wait staff was quick to bring out a tiny slice of friend green tomato on a plate to make up for it. They have an ambitious menu, but they are lacking the skill to properly execute it.

Honestly was super disappointed. The pizza is average sized, bland, over cooked and unseasoned.
It took over an hour to get just our salads. Our drinks ran empty. When we did finally get our appetizer, it was black (burnt) on the ends...
For the price, this place should have at least been decent.... Even the dog wouldn't eat the leftover (pretty much a whole pizza) ....

We were greeted in a friendly matter by the staff and seated right away. The atmosphere was nice, comfortable. There was a good selection on the menu other than just pizza. Large amount of burgers, sandwiches, wings, and some "other". We were a little disappointed with the price of the pizza. A 16" was around 22 to 25 dollars for thin crust. We ordered a specialty pizza and it came out in a decent amount of time. The pizza tasted good and was cooked well, not underdone or overdone. Our server came back and filled our drinks regularly. Overall, a good dining experience, but not a place we would come regularly due to the price.

I had previously given a five star review but the last several times I have eaten here I have been really disappointed. The pizzas have gone way down in quality. The last time, they gave us our pizza for free and we hadn't even complained. They knew it was that bad. We ate two pieces of a full pie and didn't even take our left overs.

Also, with covid 19 happening, they had had every other table marked off but then paraded people by our table to seat them, many weren't wearing masks and neither were we because we were trying to eat. It made for a very uncomfortable dining experience. I didn't feel that they had taken proper precautions to keep all customers as safe as possible.

The service was not as great as it once had been. Our server kept disappearing for long periods of time. We needed drink refills and could not find her or any other server for that matter. It wasn't until many other customers came in that they reappeared and being busy with them we were left to wait even after signaling we needed help.

Since this my spouse and I have decided not to go back there again even though we like to support our local businesses. The service, quality,and safety are lacking.

I'm sorry Lost River but my love affair with you is over. Best of luck to you. I hope you will take my critique and use it as a learning tool to become the awesome restaurant you once were.

The food was great and the lunch special was very affordable.

Worst place in town.. worst service... they do not close till 11pm and said they ran out of wings at 7pm... I WOULD NEVER RECOMMEND TO ANYONE!!!

If you suffer from an antisocial disorder I would recommend not to go on a night that Kenticky Basketball is playing. It was very loud and I'm very thankful my autistic daughter was not with us. However, the wings were delicious and the staff was on top of everything, especially with how crowded it was! We'll definitely return to dine here. Next time we will have to try the gluten free pizza!

Kinda over priced...but when you get you pizza you think it's worth it

All ya can eat wings were awesome and good cold beer selection..

Great environment, service, and food! Very unique pizzas.

The pizza was really good. The drinks from were very well made and reasonably priced. The bartender Angelea was very polite

I worked at 5 different pizza places in college as either a driver or cook. I have tried their pizza twice and it is the WORST I have ever had! Both pies cost over $25 each and I wouldn't give $5 for either one. Beer prices are high also. How they stay in business I'll never know! Many friends with similar experiences too. Stay away!

Pretty good pizza, although nothing mind-blowing. Beer selection is great.

Extremely nice/clean every single time. The staff seem to genuinely enjoy themselves. Finally, what's not to love about All-you-can-eat wings on Sundays! All of their sauces are amazing.

Not impressed, I've had 2 meals there, my 1st and last! Place wasn't busy at all but for our family of 4 they brought out 2 entrees for 2 of us and 15 mins later brought the other 2. Mine was 1 of the last ones, a chicken bacon ranch wrap, it was burnt very dry and overcooked! The tots were overfried! Pitiful!

this place is super over rated... I came in one time and wasn't spoken to for at least 5 minutes and then they blamed it on being busy... the place maybe had 20 people in it.. anyways after being seated it took another 10 minutes to put in our order...FOR DRINKS! so at this point it could only go up. wrong. the bill was jacked up and the food wasn't fully cooked. I wouldn't go back. not to add it was super pricey. I do hope this can change as I know it is locally owned and hate to see this but it is what it is..also I was never asked if they could make it right...not that it helps any.

Always ice cold beer and great pizza. The taps rotate, so always ask what they have today.
Best kept secret. Wild boar pizza. No longer listed on the menu, but still available, if you know to order it. Custom Sausage, ham, onions, peppers and their cheese. Nice, not sweet, sauce. Service with a smile. They support WKU students.

The menu is a little confusing as many of the pizzas shift have good descriptions. Service was mediocre and the server was not useful at answering questions. That said, we ordered the steak pizza. It was good. The steak was overdone, but the crust had a nice flavor and texture. As did the cheese. I'd give it another shot.

Great pizza and best cheese bread I've ever had! Service was excellent as well!

Love this place for pizza. Their pint night is a great way to try new brews.

Delicious, deep pizza, and nice selection of brews. Pricy though.

Waiter didn't know the specials and their TVs needed replaced. Green bay was in pink helmets, not really but tvs displayed it that way and computer receipt was so faded you can't read it.

Excellent appetizers, wide selection of beers on tap.

Every table was filled, everyone was super nice and our food came out super quick and was very delish! Would def recommend!

I have eaten there a few times and loved their food. However, took my wife their for a lunch date and we sat down at the table. 10 mins passed and a waitress throws menus on our table as she passes. We look over the menu decide on what we want. Sat there another 5-10 mins and was NEVER waited on! Not even a drink order was taken! I love to support our locally owned businesses! And they have great food but what does it matter when no one comes to wait on you just as they waited and served everyone else!

Food was pretty good but kind of pricey. Waitress was awesome though!

Great food not just pizza. Overall great food, I have ate at this numerous times and have enjoyed many dishes. Specifically there pizza and hamburgers are top notch. I would recommend this place and it s usually not to crowded.

Best pizza in town! Great staff. Good local eatery! We go often and have never had anything but great food and service!

Food was really good. Emmory was my server and was fantastic! Good beer choices too

Great wings and all you can eat on Sunday with a great beer selection.

Rude and unprofessional owners. They are trying to be funny or modern but it came off as very disrespectful, calling customers Karen's when they provided reasonable feedback, and insulting customers physical appearance. While I appreciate the attempt at humor (hence two stars) it was poorly done and ill received, at which point they should have apologized. By not apologizing they've only hurt themselves.

Amazing pizza, and a great place for a quick lunch meeting. The staff are nice and attentive, and the atmosphere is great. Again, amazing pizza. If you dig on swine, try the all meat pan.

Did this place get new management or new cooks or something? It used to be my absolute FAVORITE place to go (hence why 2 stars instead of 1) but our recent experience was so awful I don't think I'll ever go back.

Service was quick and polite, pizza is a little expensive however.

Delicious deep dish pizza. The "supreme" is the best option.

Good pizza, good beer selection on tap. Decent prices.

Amazing food, service and background music. A+ all the way around!

We had this delivered to the house and it didn t disappoint. We live in TX but this will be our go to pizza spot in Bowling Green. Two thumbs up

All indications are they close at 11pm. Even the sign on the door says they close at 11pm. Went in and they wouldn't serve us. Said kitchen closes at 10pm. Doesn't say ANYWHERE the kitchen closes at 10pm. Apparently they don't need the money or the customers. Avoid it.

Delicious gourmet pizzas and awesome wings. Do.leave this place without trying some of both!

If you want thin fetid "New York style" slices go to Sbarro in the food court. For pan or deep dish this is your place

Best pizza restaurant in BG. Good prices and huge beer menu. Great brisket pizza. Fried dill pickle chips are great, too.

Took my brother and mom here after a WKU graduation. It was overpriced, dirty, and seemed crowded even with very little people there due to the mismatched tables. Ordered the fried pickles as an appetizer and they were subpar--overly sour, super bland, and just limp. Portion was large but that was a bad thing--I felt like we HAD to eat them to get our money's worth. We ordered a supreme pizza and it was overly soggy and lacked flavor. I would have enjoyed Mellow Mushroom far better and wouldn't have paid over $60 for large pizza and 2 appetizers. The wait was also incredibly long even with the several open tables in the place. It was incredibly expensive and lacked atmosphere and flavor. Only positive was our server--she was very polite and did what she could with what she had.

Good beer. I'm a Chicago boy, so nothing compares to Chicago pizza. Most people don't know but Chicago has great thin crust.

This place is good in its own right. For being in KY it beats Pizza Hut any day

Best pizza we've found since moving to Bowling Green, try the "local"

Great place for sports and food. Fun atmosphere, laid back and local restaurant. Everyone should try it out.

Great beer selection, and pretty good pizza. Good stop for our road trip

Deep dish style pizza is really good here. But my favorites on the menu are actually the Cuban sandwich and the chicken and bacon wrap.

Not even close to NY style... Flavorless, undercooked. Also ordered fried pickles that had to be sent back as they were more like hot pickles dipped in sauce. Serious waste of money as a 12" pizza should not cost $18 with
veggies on it. Staff was nice and beer was good (it was bottled elsewhere). Wont be back n wont recommend.

Lost River Pizza is a everything pizza should be and more! We purchased the Grizzly which had the perfect amount of toppings with a crunchy thick fresh crust and stringy mozzarella. I noticed a FB like counter top left of the bar. Of course I hit my like button only to be amazed at the counter adding my one! LRP is a must have pizza if you love crafted pizza. We had soft drinks, looks like they serve craft beverages too! Their website is old and should be updated with current prices and pizza sizes.

Great place! Food is fantastic... you are going to pay a little more, but you get so much more in terms of quantity and quality.

Staff is friendly, beer selection is plentiful and the place just has a great atmosphere.

I highly recommend the all meat pizza or boneless garlic parmesean wings.

But no place is perfect... the one nitpick about LRP is even during slow periods, it does take quite a while for the food to come.

This is my second favorite place in Bowling Green to get food and watch a ball game.

I came in off interstate and got a 12 dollar deal they had with 5 wings and small pizza. It was good, got it to go. I was in and out in less than 20 minutes and I had a beer. Everything was 5 star. , edit I originally gave 4 instead of 5 star because I said bartender had attitude. She probably has to act like that due to the fact she hot af. Probably gets hit on every time someone sits down. I wasn't doing any of that. Still I give that star back due to that.

Just paid almost $40 (through Takeout Waiter) for a Detroit style with sausage, ham, mushrooms, and extra cheese. I got a loaf of bread with very little ham, very little sausage, a few mushrooms, some cheese and some sauce.

Went through drive thru and was ignored for 10 minutes had to beep my horn 3 times to get someone's attention. Both waitresses ignored me after seeing me and continued to play on their phones. Finally a gentleman acknowledged me. And the blonde waitress was rude and the price changed from 11.19 on the phone to 12.19 when I got there eventhough I had already requested the extra sauce on the phone and was quoted the 11.19. I love lost river but it took me 20 minutes to get my food after I already ordered it 20 minutes ago and now I get lukewarm food. Hope this experience never happens again. Then come to find out. They put the wrong sauce on my wings. So I wasted my money. Never again.

Horrible food, horrible owner, not following COVID safety practices.

The pizza and wings were really good, especially the Kentucky bourbon glaze wings. The service was fast and friendly. Will definitely come here again.

So not worth what u pay for it i want go there again

Very Good Menu for Sports Restaurant & Bar & Sodas. Wings, Pizza, Chili Burgers, fries & appetizers etc. Several TV's & Great Food & Service!!!!!!

Pizza good, to many SNOBS, think their money is better, they took mine the same, and I'm a plain old man

We are from out of town so we ordered several choices from their menu. Their beer selection is great. The staff is very friendly and the service was great. The food was amazing. I recommend their BBQ pork fries. They were delicious. Will definitely be back when we come to town.

The pizza is very good. Nice sauce, crust, and toppings. They handled a problem with our takeout order perfectly -- textbook customer service style.

The service here was excellent. They had an enormous selection of beers on tap including local brews. The food was delicious and the wait was short. Definitely look forward to coming back!

Within 10 minutes of being sat our waitress (one of the managers) was completely rude. We came in on a Sunday because we read on the website that it's 9.99 for all you can eat wings. When We got here we confirmed that price and was told it was correct by the guy that sat us and then told it was NOT correct by the waitress (super high pitched cartoon voice). And that she couldn't do that price for us because it was "ridiculous". We didn't care to pay full price. We just wanted to confirm. She showed us that on Facebook the correct pricing was listed and that what it said on the website wasn't her responsibility so it didn't matter and then she walked away as we were speaking. We we're never once rude or even spoke with a tone. She then gave our table to another server and we asked to be changed as well. He apologized and was gracious. The food was great and they played really great 90s music. But unfortunately I don't think I'll go back.

Dough for pizza way over proofed like they used everclear instead of water making it and the aroma was like a drunk hobo sat on our table. Lots of toppings as a plus. $22 for a 12" inch pizza is steep.
Wings are Hooters like. Ton of Toppings on salad, feta was the star of the whole meal.