GHU Paris Ile de France Ouest Reviews

I went to CPOA a few days ago. I was cared for by a very calm, patient and competent nurse and doctor. I forgot the names but thank you.

Sarah

I am Jean Pierre Norcia, I have just been operated on by the Raymond Garcin neurosurgery department.
I can only praise the competence, the benevolence, of a team united in a collective spirit to the services of the hospitalized people, and this at all levels.
A big thank you to Doctor Gilles Zah-Bi, whose competence is matched only by his human quality.
A big thank you to the team of nurses, physiotherapists not to mention the caregivers, who despite a difficult job, carry with kindness, care and comfort, always with a good mood and a smile.
This service carries with great fervor the public health service of which we must all be very proud.

What is it, how is such a high amount possible?

Best regards, Adam Widomski

not thinkable, this is my bill:

Hospital to flee. No empathy for patients, especially do not ask questions because this is perceived as a challenge to the skills of practitioners who are then on the defensive.

My brother who is hospitalized in your home since yesterday already filled up. The staff speak very bad very wake up with dice kick on the bed! It is unacceptable !!!

I went for my epilepsy at the request of the MDPH I was received ....

I have inexhaustible memories of this place, I know good people there. I can testify that, among so many others, I remember
a very understanding and interesting teacher ...
His Limitless Culture made me forget everything, just for one visit: Professor Gorceix.
Mrs Lansier,
Professor Kebir. Who him. Successfully complete the Tour de Force. To force myself to express myself. To get out of my prison at last, the door was open.

Finally. An Old Friend for me.
Professor Marcel. .


And then the nurses who console, who welcome and advise.

. Many structures, with contemporary architecture, welcome researchers from all over the world.
a nursing school. Library or Relais H. Les Laboratoires.
And then, All these mysterious, closed and disturbing places, prison services, care units guessed at the end of an alley.
The pavilions lit up in the middle of winter.
The list is long.
A city within a city.

I had the need to explain.
For my Survival.
If my grain of salt can be used. I am proud.

Each one, each his own little grain of madness Leave mine alone Please. everything to be in him his own. The little grain of madness that makes us endure, that tells us that nothing is in vain in this lower world.
Anna.
July 2020.

Opinion for Neurosurgery - Raymon Garcin

What to say
St Anne has a reputation for being the hospital of madmen, in reality, well it's almost true
As much as the surgeon may be cutting edge and very competent, but organizationally speaking, it is the test of the Asterix administration.
Admission and very nice nursing staff, but on the other hand, before the operation, doctor / surgeon and anesthesiologist with subscribers absent, ditto after the operation, and even a few days after, we wonder if they are not ghosts, and we I still don't know how our operation went and the possible complications to follow.
We manage to have some information on the suites, sequels / re-education / discharge by the nursing staff, but without confirmation because they do not know everything (and this is not their field), those who know, the surgeons / doctors , do not pass, suddenly we remain in a rather distressing vagueness for the patients, who would like to know what is happening to them, and will happen to them afterwards.
Another point, it plays a lot with musical chairs with the bedrooms too; admission to one, and after operation, hop, we move to another, super convenient for visitors who take the opportunity to visit the floor and unnecessarily disturb other patients or nursing staff.
TV and Wifi are offered, but that does not compensate for the total lack of consideration of surgeons and doctors towards their patients.

Impossible to have the medical imaging department to know if they are doing the "cerebral CT angiography" examination and to make an appointment by phone.
I made all the phone numbers indicated on their site, all day long, respecting the appointment schedules. In vain ... How to take RV?

Very warm welcome from attentive staff and attentive to patients.

My mother was in the intensive care unit in neurology following a stroke. This service has a huge communication problem.
And being able to have an opinion from the internal doctor is an obstacle course .... Then, moved to another room, on the day of the discharge, a nurse or a caregiver spilled her after a blood test so that 'she vacates the room immediately .... Without helping her to dress ...... It's inhuman .... Scandalous ..... A 77 year old woman .... I know that the nurses are doing a remarkable job and that they have to undergo the orders of the doctors ... Fortunately my mother did not have a fall? Imagine ......

Very good service of neurology. Fast, efficient and kind as I have rarely had in a hospital.

That erroneous information concerning the reception of teenagers and young adults: I agreed to answer the phone "oh well all the information on the site, it's about anything, it's not us who did it" in short mock of the world at this point! ......

No empathy for the patient.
Robots that just shoot us so that we close our mouths ...
Active listening, helping relationship?
No, we ask them too much
infected staff retaliate in the event of resistance.
Sickness is suffering. No humanity. Thank you .... hospital to flee.

Two operations for an aneurysm in the brain that went very well ... the first with opening of the cranium and the second with embolization. Now all is well! Thanks to the whole team

I was operated at the Raymond Garcin center (2 weeks) ... nurses and doctors very courteous and attentive ... Good hygiene of the premises ...

Thank you to those incompetent who have misplaced my life card when I am very seriously ill and I have to pass many exams. I will be dead in 2 or 3 years and these people deprive me of vital card for 2 months minimum ...

HONTEUX 2 months for the "doctor" Angela Marchis deign to send a report that was to be sent just with our appointment of May 22. No excuses on his part, no ethics, no professionalism. She wants to find an excuse saying that normally the mail should have left (speech held via the person of the secretariat). It is about the Health of others !!! We are not at the supermarket. This doctor may have a diploma (reliability to review) but is a very bad doctor no ethics.

For my part I found the staff very friendly to listen competent I'm used to hospitals in Paris

Very mixed quality of staff, but good quality care overall, especially in sector 13 on the first floor. Certainly, some caregivers behave in a revolting manner (at a time when I was in a crisis, a caregiver shook me like a plum tree), but the majority are capable of empathy, pedagogy and attention combined with firmness when necessary. They basically helped me a lot and gave me treatment and care that helped the success of my life plans. A place where, often, it is possible to contact in case of distress. After, it is likely that it does not work as well with everyone ...

Treatment of infantilizing patients, unbearable on the part of the staff. To avoid. Only the doctors are listening.

It is true that many things are to be reviewed lack of caregivers and old locals But I was operated by a really top neurosurgeon. Without him I would be gone. I am better thanks to him and also to the care of the nurses.

Very nice home. And good follow-up from very professional staff. Thanks to the real service. Neurosurgery

high level comments doctors
still have work

So-called quality hospital, when they can't even get the results of the exams they do ("on purpose"?) In the same establishment. Do not tell me clearly that they are not "interested" in making me benefit from their High Tech care because my case does not fit into their desideratas of case studies ...
I have been waiting for my MRI scans since the beginning of the year, that is six months, to be told that they "cannot call the department concerned 15 times a day"! The French healthcare service is dying, because of the lobby of leaders who want to block access to healthcare via social security! Everything is as they please, a shame!

Poor organization of scanner and MRI services
Very long wait and aggressiveness of office workers .... already reported

Mixed. it was my 4th hospitalization for bi polar disorders. As much as the first 3 times, it was short. As much as the last, I was over-medicated and above all very little listened to. 41-year-old patients, who also take their treatment and are followed "in the city", should not be infantilized. On the nursing staff side (nurses / nursing assistants) RAS- they are at our disposal and especially most of the time very pleasant and smiling. The PSY is here, the REAL CONCERN !!!!! they are not often in the service (open sector) and especially do not bring you therapy. In short, a drug monitoring without care in parallel. INSUFFICIENT, REVOLTANT and above all INHUMAN. Part of me was taken away from me during this last stay in this hospital.

A perfect home, sleeping boards are very comfortable and roaches very nice! (I made some cockroach friends)
The caterpillar sandwiches are excellent I recommend this delight!

Thank you to all the service of the reanimation and the medical team of their know-how and know To be. cordially

Bad experience with this establishment. Locked up very hard to live with, manipulative and disrespectful staff. Being interned there is a real ordeal that never seems to end because of the procrastination carried out by the administration, the vagueness in which the doctors tell you. The deprivation of freedoms and reprisals from staff (in the event of resistance) are also very present. I just hope to get out of here soon.

A specialized hospital whose reputation is well established. The architecture consists of small buildings connected by covered galleries gives it a special charm. The many inner streets are named after some famous patients. It allows you to travel in the artistic world in a way that is original to say the least. The establishment is dotted with multiple small green space to isolate quiet if desired.

Physicians with expertise in neuroscience and spinal trauma.

During his internship, Dr. Monteil De Maricourt, who had since become De Maricourt, had been in charge of establishing a report of hospitalization of a non-patient-launcher-alert, caught on a stretcher in a hospital. medical imaging service.
This account of manipulated indiscretions, some of which were even simply false, was supposed to be part of a medical record deemed "secret".
To discredit the launcher-no-ill and make sure that he has a false reputation for being disturbed, young intern Monteil De Maricourt, blithely trampling on the terms of the doctors' Code of Ethics, decided to broadcast the report. hospital report.
This young man had not been sanctioned, but promoted.
This was before the law on shared secret.

long care in the emergency but well ... arrive in the service late but very well received by a nice nurse just I was not in the place adapted to my pathology but understood that he had to play caution.
caring staff listening but it quickly shortens our questions at the same time talking in a corridor his share quickly in riots patient restless.
on the other hand it would be nice that each caregiver have the same speech example you are told ok 9:30 am you can smoke arrive another person tells you not a doctor agreement while the day before I was able to smoke with the evening team ???? I'm told ben last night you had luck ha !!!!!
received by the head of department very attentive and help to go to the clinic montsouris or I already had been and had a good memory which has nothing to do with saint anne my phatology is more blows of tiredness and slight depression.
otherwise I thought it was worse than his but no it is well structured the premises are clean.
on the other hand I if so diabetic person in the morning came to my gyclemie I ask him myself same evening ditto attention vigilance about him.
I do not tell you soon but it's not too bad.

good to you

madam fofana born robillard Emmanuelle

In neurology in garcin building
Deplorable hygiene (5 days of hospitalization and not a single cleaning including in the bathrooms knowing that there are two patients per room). In addition, the caregivers are embittered and make us feel it.
Of all the hospitals I have stayed in since my cancer, it is by far the worst.

SECTOR 16 - pavilion J and K. - Services composed only of psychoanalyst doctors.
Refusal of this sector to direct towards CBT services and therapies - (long live the respect of the patient's rights with regard to the choice of treatment).

Followed for 11 years by Lacanian psychoanalyst doctors. My condition kept deteriorating there.
Their misdiagnosis made me suffer and waste 11 years of my life. The doctor who followed me at the time always refused to inform me of the diagnosis made.

I was lucky to get out of this toxic environment in my eyes.

I did a lot and also had the chance to meet qualified psychiatrists, with different approaches. The diagnosis of Asperger's autistic person after several cognitive and IQ tests allowed me to resume the studies that I had to stop for lack of adaptation. I was then able to integrate professionally.

What the psychoanalysts rather than questioning their methods and changing their approaches claimed to be impossible.

I suffered HDT and forced separations from my family environment. Parents are very commonly qualified by these professionals as pathogens.
The great majority of psychoanalysts refuse to be evaluated on the grounds that psychoanalysis is based on the unconscious and the subjective.

Perhaps we should study the subjectivity of psychoanalysts to refuse these evaluations.
Do they not have more interest than patients in being able to continue applying their methods?

A scientific study conducted by INSERM was conducted in 2005.
Under pressure from some lobbies, it was removed from their site for a while, before being reposted.
This study admits a possible lack of harmlessness of their methods.
For having undergone psychoanalysis, I can confirm this fact, as far as I am concerned.

Certain administrative biases, dubious from a legal point of view, were used, to my detriment by the doctors of this hospital. I was hospitalized in HDT and I was no longer allowed to go to my parents on weekends.

I had asked to meet with the person responsible for inspecting forced hospitalizations. The day she came, surprised not to see her, I asked when she would drop by.
The nurses informed me that the HDT had been lifted without my knowledge and that it would not pass.
I managed to catch up with her just before she left and talk to her about my wish to see my parents more often.
This meeting was positive since I was able to spend the following weekends with my parents.

So that my remarks are not confusing, I recognize the existence of very good psychiatrists, some of whom are also trained in psychoanalysis. The moderate and detailed use of psychological therapies helps people.
What I denounce is the absence of objectivity and the arbitrary interpretations which lead, for lack of medical and scientific approach, to diagnostic errors, some of which have cost their lives or led to disabling situations for people with the disease. autism, epilepsy, hyper-thyroid or various rare diseases.

Certain diseases are expressed by cognitive impairment which can mimic psychiatric difficulties. The first-line examinations carried out in the emergency department do not always allow a formal diagnosis to be made.

It seems to me all the more important that if a psychiatrist's opinion is requested, it is based on objective and concrete elements.

Very nice but difficult to find but thank you for helping I would come back. Very beautiful outdoor very pretty.

c is quite funny patients who talk about architecture (green spaces and lol ... of this hospital .... what we ask a hospital is not much the quality of care ??? it makes me think of a friend who said of her doctor "he is nice" but that is not enough because she ended up at the cemetery

I would like Monsieur le PREFET DE POLICE from Paris to check the structures more often.

It is not a suitable place for people with severe depression who suffer they will pamper their patients how they always do it never put your children the bah you destroy them they feel abandoned go out in the forest breathe offer their activities or even better when it's like its a pet like a cat or a dog will help them a lot it helped me a lot it's the best thing to do .. your children will see things not to see and there they go to take a liking it is even worse good day St Anne that I am very clear and it is everywhere the same you are mean you have no mercy. So I don't like you thanks for those who can understand.

Badly polite secretariat, no respect for people. Dark atmosphere, not recommended.

Very beautiful place, loaded with a lot of history.

psychiatric emergencies? or an outlet for incompetent and frustrated pseudo-medical staff? change job !
there are more competent and human people who are just waiting to feel useful !!!

I give a very negative opinion not on the care or the doctors, but on the staff who take care of the cleaning of the toilets
it's a complete shame! I go regularly in the Raymond Garcin pole in clinical neurophysiology, go in their toilets is really an obstacle course: as soon as you enter, a terrible smell of urine jumps in your face,
I work in a large institution for children in the City of Paris, believe me, if the cleaning agents were doing such work, they would be fired on the field !! It should not be forgotten that this happens in a hospital, so hygiene must be even more impeccable than elsewhere!

Urgency to flee. Hospital staff to flee. No empathy for patients. What a disappointment, what a disappointment!

Excellent care, neurologists are effective, empathic, nurses form a very good team ... welded. I recommand it
Eric

Operation of a successful meningioma, but reception, follow-up, post-op patient nullissime. Ah yes I forgot, no need to phone, no one answers, as to write .... The administration in all its splendor.

I like the color of the stones, very pure. But the feeling inside dislikes me, it smells of turmeric, I do not like turmeric. But the flowers are beautiful, they are very green and alive, I love flowers.

Null!
Not examined, drunk neuroleptic, while I had a kidney tumor!
Yet I brought the biological results!
"It's nervous!" They said!

The GHU told me that they take my opinion into account to improve the quality of care ...

And suffer me?
The loss of quality of life?
The abuse suffered in Saint Anne?
Side effects of neuroleptics? I have late effects like tardive dyskinesia!

Not to examine a patient is a crime!
The minimum was not respected and my word disqualified from "delirium"

The psychiatric service is worthy of a gulag
Drugs galore, go and I stuff you with Haldol, Tercan, Zoloft and all the other crap that will destroy you and make the wealth of bigpharma on your back. Do not be afraid of words, psychiatry is quackery

In case of psychiatric abuse, do not hesitate to seize the CCDH, Citizens Commission for Human Rights.

Medical teams at the top (doctors, guards, nurses ..). Young, very good communicators, friendly and very welcoming, I find them very fast in terms of diagnosis and treatment. In addition they are hypers well equipped (technology). I recommend !

Quality care, there is an art therapy service that is great.
By cons difficult to get a first appointment quickly

we are not all 1.70m 43 foot size false advertising on the outfit provided !!!! message to a certain psychiatrist very old and slow: go to retirement !!!!! but fried with vegetables yum I love the statues

Waiting long enough to make an appointment with a specialist in Psychology / Neurology.

former student nurse impossible to join them to have an attestation employer..to flee even like employee !!!

Very high quality of care by the nursing staff (nurses and doctors). A high level public service

The hospital is big. You will lost if you don't have detail building information in French. But the hospital is beautiful.

My friend is in care without consent in flag E.
I got their phone number in order to make contact and each time I am very "astonished" of the "welcome" ... we will say it like that.
- no presentation during the hitch but a "yes!"
_ the staff speaks badly (they allow themselves to think only about themselves, and use an annoyed tone)
_ obviously lacks empathy.

Psychiatrists are depressed and do not give patients the chance to dialogue.

My father was operated on at home with a blood clot in his head.
Everything went well during his hospitalization despite the dilapidated places.
I wanted to thank the entire medical team of the neurosurgery department (Dr. Zanello, internal Bozier, nurses, caregivers and Ms. Olivier).

I can not say that this is the tourist place par excellence, since here is a psychiatric asylum Dam-dam-daaaam ! Okay, I stop the Hollywood drama, though it's good to build a "clinical asylum" that Napoleon III decided to redevelop the old farm Saint Anne managed by patients.
Subsequently, the Sainte-Anne Hospital has developed and specialized in psychiatry and neuroscience to become one of the most renowned centers in the field. A museum is located in the hospital compound, it even exposes works of patients!

A super efficient team available in real time
Nice staff with patients even those in sedation
Completely satisfied also with care
A very competent medical team

Cruel lack of empathy on the part of the staff. We could (for the most part) replace them with robots / automata, it would not make any difference.

Super team, available as much as they are possible, they also offer a small waiting garden in addition to the waiting room. For emergencies, it's pretty nice.

I am a private detective in charge of a worrying disappearance file for a man recognized as schizophrenic. Out of all the establishments contacted, only the switchboard operator (contacted on 05/13 at 4:10 p.m.) from this establishment made no effort, or even that of understanding my request for the dissemination of a description form, but now that I think about it, maybe it was a patient who had grabbed the phone ... (irony)

Do not bring your family or friends back to this hospital. No reception of patients. Poor support. The nurses and especially a young woman in the psychiatric ward for adults have no sense of respect for others. Moreover, she treats trainees very badly in front of patients. These are future nurses must be respected and make them love their future jobs. And from what I've seen, these trainees are very much appreciated by patients. Even more than this lady. What a lack of respect for all these nurses, nurses, caregivers.
The human is not at the heart of their concerns. It shows. I advise against.

Very good management of neurosurgery. Dr. Lepage operates the hernia discales.equipe very available

EXCECRABLE reception and secretarial staff. Unpleasant at most. Zero friendliness. Treat us like cattle. And allow us to threaten us !!!
3 hours of waiting for a simple consultation without keeping us informed of the progress! I strongly advise against the reception and treatment of patients. To flee.

We brought our 21 year old daughter 2 years ago. She suffered from depression and severe anxiety attacks. She was very bad and we, the parents, very worried. We had a good "global" care, family, and it was very reassuring. Psychiatrists and nurses spent a lot of time with her and with us as well.
The staff was friendly and attentive. They kept her all night, which in such a situation was reassuring for her, but also for us. Of course, they did not have enough time to really diagnose but they "managed" the crisis and relieved it a little of its torment.

To flee from any EMERGENCY, worst psychiatric hospital in France, they make completely false diagnoses on their patient and do not hesitate to put them under duress and interned on bad diagnoses, the worst and most More

historic hospital, soothing rest, thanks again to the staff

I am hospitalized for my tca is frankly the service is great. Nurses are very caring and very attentive. They deserve. Thank you to the entire 2nd floor team for their patience and support. The rooms are very clean and the food good

I was in the '92, for drunk one night for desoule, four on you to make an injection it was not my place, the next day a discharge was signed for my release I'm never returned that from the Shit.

No switchboard and Nobody answers the radiology department (morning and afternoon). In short, the sad reality of what has become of public service and medicine in France! This is undoubtedly what we call "the greatness of France"!

CPOA service: thanks to the nurse at the dread locks the blond. Very attentive! Rather a good care despite the long wait for the ambulance! A big thank you to people like him because it is not easy to come and ask for help for troubles .. he has projected bcp d ampathie

very good hospital 3 floor hospitalize for a tumor to the head but really very good hospital nurse very well apart from 1 who calls himself rough on the 3rd floor neurology otherwise everything else and perfect I recommend this hospital

My daughter has returned to emergency for malnutrition and bad general, I thought it was a good hospital and gave my validation even if the hospital would have validated automatically.
She was treated sedated ++++ It was a robot she could not even speak I was able to see her after 4 days in premises + that dilapidated, with people who wandered in the corridors sometimes without panties or with diapers.
The water was accessible because in a fridge closed by a lock.
After 4 days my daughter (25 years) had still not been received by the doctor or seen by a nurse (they are the ones who told me), I had to intervene to get an appointment.
How to trust them?
Flee this hospital if it's an emergency.
I deeply regret leaving it there and I feel guilty.
This is a message that you do not make my mistake, she is angry with me and I understand it, I thought of doing well because we remain on the good reputation of Saint Anne but it is a false information.

To flee ... in any case, with regard to the neuro-epilepsy center. They seem competent at first but stuff patients with drugs until they end up in the emergency room. Doctors who endanger the lives of their patients ... sincerely, for your sake, look for another hospital. I do not wish anyone to be treated this way.
The only good thing is the secretaries who are adorable and helpful. A big thank you to those who welcome us as human beings and not as customers (a patient, is supposed to be listened to, supported and relieved see treated).

An intern (not even a doctor) for 30 patients. Three days without seeing a doctor to hear from a father who had been operated on three days earlier. The public service is dead in France. The hospital service is in great danger and with it the patients. It must be lived to unfortunately realize it.

Quality food
Very human care staff, attentive and welcoming
Generous doses of Vallium
Access to the park
Flat on the bedding
I highly recommend this quality establishment: remember to book!