Gatti's Pizza Reviews

I ordered a sampler pizza which is almost like a supreme pizza with everything on it according to them. I didn't like at all it didn't have enough cheese it wasn't cheesy. It had way too much black olives and mushrooms hardly any pepperoni it was dry plain to taste. They could make them a lot better. A Digiorno pizza would of been a hell lot better for a quarter of the price it was over priced as well. Not worth it what a disappointment

called in order for 2 SMALL pizzas 30 min before I got there waited another 1 hr while other people orderd large pizzas with sides got thier orders before me and the staff was rude owner tried to give me a free meal and admitted that the person didn't put my order in until after the other orders where put in that I can understand not all the smug smiles I recived from all the employees then when I complained on their site some know it all trolled the site and told me it takes 1hr and 45 min to make 2 SMALL pizzas worst thing about it I didn't want to go to that uppady place guess their sardines don't stink SMH

Got the basics, just 2 pepperoni pizzas with 2 sides of salad and 2 drinks.

Pizza was cold and hard. Salad was turning brown and seemed very old. They only had diet soda available. Payed some $30 for all of that. I would not recommend.

Quality is nothing like it used to be. Servings are small, and the service is slow.

I love the large selection of food, very friendly. Very respectable to food allergies! Delicious spaghetti!

Best calzone anywhere. Large meat calzone is amazing.

It's went down hill from a year's ago...dont know who the new owner's are but hiring college kids and high schoolers who views that as just a job so they dont care about speed of service, customer sevice, and just down right have no common sense

I made a simple 1 pizza & 2 salads on line. Got my confirmation email. After 50 minutes and no Pizza I called. I was told they had had a rush and it would be another 25 minutes. As of this review it s been 30 more minutes and still no pizza. Frustrating to say the least, certainly do not feel like a valued customer at all!!

We were driving through this town and stop to get Something to eat. compared to Giovanni's in our little town this place has a way to go.

Great place to eat lunch at and get some great ice cream at

Great pizza, salads, pasta and sandwiches! Locally owned and family operated, friendly service too! Great atmosphere for dining in but you can also order takeout or they will deliver! They even have an app for that! ;) Be sure to check sizes and slice counts if it's your first time and you're ordering for a crowd. They aren't a chain so every pizza is made special, it's delicious and totally worth the few extra minutes you might wait if they are super busy.

Food is great and dinning area are much cleaner now. Will be returning soon.

Love that place! The food is a good as I remembered from college.

I hate to give bad reviews. I'm giving 2 stars because the pizza was ok and the shake was a basic normal shake. The service was ok. Wasn't horrible customer service but wasn't great. Let me start by saying there wasn't hardly any customers when i placed my order. I ordered at 6:01. Received my pizza by 6:48. I have 3 young children who were super hungry and getting restless. This was my first time here so we wanted to try some place new for us. After receiving my pizza over 45 minutes later they still hadn't made my shake. I got my shake when we had all finished our pizza and were putting our jackets on ready to leave. This place is over priced for sub par pizza that takes forever to get to you. Not worth it. We won't be back. The people that were working were just fine I just think they should communicate better with customers. I was unaware that orders were coming in from online as well as a drive thru? Idk. But 30 bucks for 1 pizza 4 drinks and a shake ain't worth it.

I have been waiting over 1 hr 20 minutes for my pizza .I will never order from this place again...when I called them I asked where my pizza was an I told them you already have your money now I want my pizza. Period

This place took forEVER to get our food to us when we dined in. We sat at the table for about an hour. Food wasn t anything to write home about. Probably won t be back.

We're been Dublin 6 years. Stopped in for pizza. Outstanding we will be back

Little bit of a long wait but then a guy came in to pick up a whole bunch of pizzas so I'll let it slide. Other than that the calzone was delicious very crispy and flaky although the 'garlic bread left a little to be desired'

Waited over an hour for our food to be delivered. Food was cold. I use to love pizza place.

Amazing pizza!! But really slow service. 5 stars if food was ready quicker

Ordered my food for delivery tonight. Over 1.5 hours later food showed up cold.

Pizza was bad I d say a 1 out of 10 Dominos is better. The spaghetti was the worst I ve ever eaten, I ve had better frozen spaghetti. Salad was terrible, the lettuce tasted like bleach the French dressing wasn t even close to French dressing. And when I placed my order they said about 45 minutes for delivery it was an hour and a half

They have the best pizza, spaghetti and sub sandwiches... it's been good for a long long time... been going there since I was in high school in the late 70s

Over priced for what you get. Ordered extra cheese but got less than what should come on a regular cheese order. The meat didn't taste fresh and the jalapenos weren't spicey at all. Even the mushrooms seem to be out of a can. Free refills about the only thing worth the wait.

The Meat Lover's Pizza with black olives was ordered by phone. My friend and i drove to pick it up. It was ready at the time promised.
I am not a big fan of pizza. We might eat it 4 times a year. That said. The extra large had 12 slices. The meat topping was generous.
I did not go in. The parking lot is ample and well maintained. This resteraunt has a perfect handicapped accessible entrance.
They serve Blue Bell ice cream. Prices are reasonable. They make subs and salads.

The food was cold when we got it. Wasn't very happy

The people who are currently working there are hard workers and very polite. I can not find any flaws with my last visit.

They have really good pizza. If you haven't eaten here then go ahead and try it.

You do have to wait for the food for a while but it's worth the wait. Great food, awesome environment, great ice cream chooses, plus the prices are not bad. It's a great hang out place and it family friendly!!! Customer service is great. All around a great place!!

One of our favorite places to eat when we're in the area. Really like their homemade ranch dressing and subs are the best, pizza is as good as it gets anywhere.

This place used to be delicious. They changed their spaghetti recipe and now it tastes like ketchup.

A fav location for quality pizza. The service was very kind and attentive.

Not what I expected, the pizza did not taste a lot of tomato sauce and little cheese

Not bad pizza not great

If you're A high or drunk college student it's perfect

Very disappointed this evening. Haven't ordered in a while, but the pizza we brought home tonight was thrown together and IF it had cheese, my wife and I couldn't find any. Used to be our favorite place for pizza. Sad....we used to love this place, but won't be back.

My husband said his pizza, today, was the best he has ever eaten there.

The pizza was good, which is why I came, but the staff is always rude or unfriendly. One time I ordered a pizza, got it, and paid, and the guy never said one word the whole time except the amount. They definitely need to brush up on some customer service skills.

We had just a plain pepperoni pizza but it was the BEST pepperoni pizza I have had on a long time! Good service but could use a little more salad dressing with the salad.

This is not a bad restaurant but then again I wouldn't call it good.

Here's my breakdown based on a five star scale one being the worst ever and five being the best ever.

Service
Price
Environment
Food Quality
Food Taste
Parking
Menu

Would I eat there again? No, it was overpriced and their signature item their pizza wasn't even as good as Domino's. Dont wast your money just go to fast food pizza chain, or if you want real pizza go to an authentic pizzarelli.

Absolutely love the pizza and salad. Great service as well

Very tasty grub here, they not only serve pizza, but also pasta, salads, and potato spuds. It is popular with students but is not always crowded. Great place to order from or eat in; probably the best pizza in the town. 4/5 stars.

Lasagna was really good. Service was great for takeout that day.

Great place! I love their pizza and the other items like subs, calzones, and spaghetti are great too. I feel like it could be a little more efficient and the kids running the joint most days could be a little more professional since the entire kitchen is visible to the dining area, but a solid choice for unique and yummy! pizzeria food

Great prices but the pizza was a little bland for my liking although our daughter really liked it. We finished up with some Blue Bell ice cream.

The hamburger pizza is not the same anymore. They are cutting corners and not putting as much hamburger or cheese on it. This has been the case the last 2 times we got pizza. Gave the benifit of the doubt the first time but not this time. Unless they go back to the original recipe we will not be back :(

Good service, amazing pizza and Blue Bell ice cream!! What more could you ask for!

We ordered at 5:30 and were told the wait was 45 minutes, over an hour and 15 minutes passed and we finally went up to ask about it. We don t think the pizza was even meant to be ours (it was sitting in a box on top of the oven) and it wasn t hot, we had time to eat one slice before leaving with the rest in a to-go box because we needed to be somewhere at 7 and thought an hour and a half would be enough time to eat here. The pizza was ok, but definitely not worth the wait and frustration.

Great pizza! Nice people! Great handicapped accessible bathroom and parking!

My top site for quality Pizza. i love this place always quality food & service. i've had nothing but enjoyable experiences here and plan to keep visiting. prices are reasonable i would say.

A fav place for Pizza. this place is absolutely one of my favorites. the service was very friendly and kind. bring your hunger - portions are generous.

I was in Stephenville for a game at Tarleton State and heard about this place as they were one of the sponsors of TSU athletics. They've been serving pizzas for over 5 decades and hence we decided to check it out. Went in with high expectations as they've been around for a long time and I was not disappointed!

The place was nice and cozy. We ordered 3 pizzas and some garlic bread and the food was really good and made from good quality ingredients, we all really liked it! The food did take a while to make it to our table but it was made to order from scratch and so I didn't mind waiting at all, it was worth it.

Definitely worth paying The Pizza Place a visit!

Needs a good cleaning. The sandwich was average. Little guy working the front was very nice .

Waited over an hour for our food to be delivered. Food was cold. I use to love pizza place.

One of my fav spots for delicious pizza. next time i'll be back with my friends. if it wasn't far from my work i would come by more.