Bentino’s Pizza Reviews

Friendly staff. Delicious food and great atmosphere.

The pizza and salads are great. I will drive out of my way to go back.

I've eaten here 100's of times and never have I ordered something I didnt feel was made fresh and flavorful! I've always received fantastic service too!!!

The food here is excellent. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. Was definitely worth the short drive off of the highway. Will be stopping there again on future trips!

The food is always excellent and the service is great! We appreciate having a local place to go that is so good! Love everything I have had but the Cobb Salad is just awesome!

My daughter has Downs syndrome and is very picky about her wings.( No bones) The last 3xs we ordered from Bentinos bones were in her wings. BUt... when addressed. They quickly gave us a credit. We love their pizza and want to continue to support hometown!

Fun place in a nice little town. Is a favorite place of a good friend.

Excellent calzones. Thin and crispy buttery crust. Quiet, cozy atmosphere. Full bar. Three local beers on draft rotation. Bull sticks were very good too.

Would be better if patio was non-smoking. Great service though - Jaala was excellent.

Bud light is cold and the calzones are delicious. Great restaurant for a small town. Class act service and quality food. Come and check it out!

Fantastic food, super friendly employees, constantly awesome mood. They charge fair prices and the food quality is good. I recommend this place.

Food is great but if you are accustomed to the yellowsprings location, don't go to this location expecting a similar vibe. It's a beautiful restaurant but I took my small child expecting a more laidback environment and definitely ended up feeling super uncomfortable when I realized how different this location was. Wouldn't recommend for small noisy children.

Great pizza good atmosphere and draft beer great place for dinner

Very nice, has small bar great place 2 grab dinner with family also

Stopped in for lunch and had a chicken parm hoagie and greek salad. Greek Salad was really good. Chicken parm was just ok. Sauce, cheese and bread was good but the chicken seemed just like a giant chicken nugget patty (which is not a bad thing) but the chicken just didn't have much flavor. Sauce and cheese made up for it. Service was great and clean, neat atmosphere/bar. Waitress recommended the calzone and pizza. I'll be back again to try a calzone or pizza

The service was awful, the waitress was only worried about bringing me the bill, even when our glasses were completely empty. The kitchen made our sandwiches wrong so it took even longer then normal to get our food to begin with. If you dine here, bring your own drinks and napkins because they wouldn't bring me either....

Had the best Calzone I have ever had for lunch today from here. Would highly recommend.

Excellent pizza with great service. If you like traditional Italian pizza, go for the Margherita, it's not Italy but it gets close. Nice atmosphere, and a great place to take some friends for an inexpensive, delicious bite.

Had a great time with my son Kyle Hargrave and his family..He had only eaten at Bentino's 2 other times.Its a great family atmosphere and loved seeing my distant cousin Jason Garringer the owner.So proud of his success.The Garringer's are a great family in Jamestown and always have been.:))

Good food geat sphegetti.. And my harley is in the storage buildings they rent behind the place

We all enjoyed our meals,seemed there was something for every taste. This is a mid point meeting place, so we'll likely meet there again

Spaghetti was good, pizza was average, friendly staff. For a small town it is a good restaurant, clean.

Benitino's is able to custom make food to meet most dietary needs. This an added bonus - the food and service is great.

Thank you

Very busy but delicious food. Including gluten free pizza! Staff explained careful precautions for gluten cross-contamination, which was appreciated as I have celiac! Also great options for the whole family!

Good food place was busy odered out didn't get our saled

They make really good pizza in the establishment is set up like a sports bar so you could enjoy sports and beer while you eat I recommend it

The pizza was sooo good!! The cheese fries I thought were way over priced for what they were.

We walked in and filled a table of 6...we were welcomed. Great food, service and atmosphere. There is always an interesting and special craft beer here as well. We'll be back.

The garlic's knots are great. The pepperoni pizza was very very greasy.

Great local pizza place. I try to stop in whenever I pass through Jamestown. The pizza is excellent, the subs and salads are very good and the staff is always friendly. Of you are looking for a local place to spend your money and get your money's worth then this a a great option.

Always fast friendly service and the food is delicious

Pizza is great, very favorable, good selection of beers

Quick service, the pizza was very tasty. Bull sticks were a good starter for the meal. Spaghetti was a large portion with multiple meatballs.

This place is my favorite. I eat in a lot of restaurants but to this one I constantly return again and again. The crew is very friendly and the cooking they cook is so fresh and tasty. I am always happy to have a nice meal here. I recommend this place with pleasure.

I've been coming here once a year for five years to celebrate a November anniversary. It's the same great experience every time. Excellent pizza, fresh salad, clean tables, classic rock at a moderate volume, wait staff that is happy and friendly. Works for me!

Drove 50 minutes out of our small town to find something new to try, and this was so worth it. The breadsticks alone are worth the trip. The entrees are just a plus! I had a delicious pizza and my boyfriend enjoyed the gyro deluxe.

Run out with the little lady when we want to do something special but close to home.

Nice italian place for a small town. Friendly people and staff.

I celebrated my nomination last night in this fine place. I am glad to say that we had a brilliant evening and the venue was indeed one of the reasons for the fruitful event. The crew collaborated in a graceful way, the cuisine was delicious and my friends were extremely delighted. We shall no dout return for more joyful events. thanks very much.

A neighborhood tavern with good food, and friendly service.

Food was fire, everything was great. Waitress was on it. The manager was pretty great too. Clean professional yet great hometown feel

Love the garlic knots and the Greek pizza. Always yummy!

First time order last night. Meat Madness Pizza was delicious! Generous toppings. Glad we got the large as leftovers today were just as good! Regular breadsticks were just OK. Will have to try the cheesy bread next time. A bit pricey but well worth it. Will order again!

Sunday evening, light crowd, service was prompt but relaxed. No waiting for seating or drinks. Great selection from the bar, loved the hard cider and microbrew beers. The Greek salads were a huge hit with the entire family - unique crisp and generous. Buffalo wings were fresh and hot, nice balance of sauce and crispness. Calzones were perfect, hot, crisp, tender and well filled with fresh ingredients. Cheesecake and Tiramisu served fresh and cold with delicious toppings. Eat here, often!

We stop in from time to time for a pizza or salad. We've always had good and prompt service, and the food is good. Location is only 10 minutes from Xenia, so it's nice having another option for living in a smaller town. They have a bar area too and draft beer on tap. Recommended for families too.

The garlic knots are divine. They usually have at least two craft beers on tap, as well as the regular domestic lineup.

The pizza was great. My chicken parm sandwich hit the spot. Great service. Will be back.

We happened upon this place while out exploring and man am I so glad we turned around and tried them out! The pizza was PHENOMENAL! We had the greek and margarita pizzas and man... I've never had a margarita pizza that good. The fresh basil really set it off. They had some great seasonal craft beers on tap and a really good bourbon selection for a restaurant that doesn't specialize as a local hot spot bar. We have stopped going to our local pizza places and make the trip to Jamestown whenever we have a hankering now. It's totally worth the trip.

Tried their newer thin crust and liked it but their regular crust is still the best. Their Jamestown store is so much better than than their Yellow Springs store, I am we checked it out.

Been there a couple times really decent little restaurant