Bay Street Theate Reviews

This is a fun spot to see some really great shows! Grab a drink and a friend. You won t be disappointed.

Great place for comedy shows. There is literally no bad seats. Only holds around 300 max. Nice bar and waiting area. Lots of entertainment history here.

Great theater in the heart of Sag Harbor. This theater has style, charm and a very welcoming and comfortable ambiance.

Non profit performing arts center in Sag Harbor Village at Long Warf the Bay Street Theatre, or BST has been an important cultural hub of the Hamptons since its opening in 1991. The venue hosts shows ranging from plays, stand-up comedies, cover bands and live musicians throughout the year, events often end in a meet-and greet scenario hosted in the theatre s lobby/bar and though I haven t been in the past year, was always a good time.

What a GREAT theatre!!!! The talent, stage, music, props and backdrop - incredible! What a gem tucked in the Hamptons!

Attractive and charming theatre setting. Good viewing from almost all seats. Nice warm intimate atmosphere. Shows plays. Also show classic movies with visits and discussions by the writers/directors and/or producers. All in all a very enjoyable experience.

My favorite place to catch some of the most professional, well-attended theatre out East. Pay what you will night allows everyone to attend at very affordable rates. All of their performances are excellent, not a bad seat in the house as all sightlines are clear to the stage. Personally, I love the side sections. If you're on a budget, grab the $25 seats and have a great night out!

Summer and winter always a treat. Great performances right in small town venue.
Plays. Concerts, Classic Readings, Broadway stars appearing regularly.
Great for the whole family*****

A wonderful professional Equity theater who's dramatic and other productions are always top-flight. Also, a great community resource with a strong commitment to education and support of the local community.